Text 2: diplomatic immunity, espionage and recognition

1. Diplomatic immunity. The sanctity of diplomats has long been observed. This sanctity has come to be known as diplomatic immunity. While there have been a number of cases where diplomats have been killed, this is normally viewed as a great breach of honour. Genghis Khan and the Mongols were well known for strongly insisting on the rights of diplomats, and they would often wreak horrific vengeance against any state that violated these rights.

2. Diplomatic rights were established in the mid-seventeenth century in Europe and have spread throughout the world. These rights were formalized by the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which protects diplomats from being persecuted or prosecuted while on a diplomatic mission. If a diplomat does commit a serious crime while in a host country s/he may be expelled. Such diplomats are then often tried for the crime in their homeland.

3. Diplomatic communications are also viewed as sacrosanct, and diplomats have long been allowed to carry documents across borders without being searched. The mechanism for this is the so-called "diplomatic bag" (or, in some countries, the "diplomatic pouch"). In recent years, however, signals intelligence has led to this use of diplomatic bags being largely discarded.

4. In times of hostility, diplomats are often withdrawn for reasons of personal safety, and in some cases when the host country is friendly but there is a perceived threat from internal dissidents. Ambassadors and other diplomats are also sometimes recalled by their home countries as a way to express displeasure with the host country. In both cases, lower-level employees remain to actually do the business of diplomacy.

5. Diplomats as a guarantee. The Middle East and other parts of the world had a very different tradition. In the Ottoman Empire, Persia and other states diplomats were seen as a guarantee of good behaviour. If a nation broke a treaty or if their nationals misbehaved the diplomats would be punished. Diplomats were thus used as an enforcement mechanism on treaties and international law. To ensure that punishing a diplomat mattered rulers insisted on high-ranking figures. This tradition is seen by many as the basis of the 1979 Iranian hostage crisis. In imitation of previous practices supporters of the Iranian Revolution attempted to punish the United States for its misdeeds by holding their diplomats hostage. Diplomats as a guarantee were also employed sometimes in pre-modern Europe and other parts of Asia.

6. Diplomacy is closely linked to espionage. Embassies are bases for both diplomats and spies, and some diplomats are essentially openly-acknowledged spies. For instance, the job of military attachés includes learning as much as possible about the military of the nation to which they are assigned. They do not try to hide this role and, as such, are only invited to events allowed by their hosts, such as military parades or air shows. There are also deep-cover spies operating in many embassies. These individuals are given fake positions at the embassy, but their main task is to illegally gather intelligence, usually by coordinating spy-rings of locals or other spies. For the most part, spies operating out of embassies gather little intelligence themselves and their identities tend to be known by the opposition. If discovered, these diplomats can be expelled from an embassy, but for the most part counter-intelligence agencies prefer to keep these agents in situ and under close monitoring.

7. The information gathered by spies plays an increasingly important role in diplomacy. Arms-control treaties would be impossible without the power of reconnaissance satellites and agents to monitor compliance. Information gleaned from espionage is useful in almost all forms of diplomacy, everything from trade agreements to border disputes.

8. Diplomatic recognition is an important factor in determining whether a nation is an independent state. Receiving recognition is often difficult, even for countries which are fully sovereign. For many decades after becoming independent, even many of the closest allies of the Republic of the Netherlands refused to grant it full recognition. Today there are a number of independent entities without widespread diplomatic recognition, most notably the Republic of China. Hardly any nations officially recognize the ROC's existence on Taiwan, but rather they retain informal links. The United States, for instance, maintains relations through de facto embassies known as the American Institute in Taiwan and the Taipei Economic and Cultural Representative Office.

9. Other unrecognized countries include Abkhazia, Transnistria, Somaliland, Puntland, and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus. Lacking the economic and political importance of Taiwan, these nations tend to be much more diplomatically isolated.

10. Though used as a factor in judging sovereignty, Article 3 of the Montevideo Convention states, "The political existence of the state is independent of recognition by other states."

11. Informal diplomacy (sometimes called track 2 diplomacy) has been used for centuries to communicate between powers. Most diplomats work to recruit figures in other nations who might be able to give informal access to a county's leadership. In some situations, such as between the United States and the People's Republic of China a large amount of diplomacy is done through semi-formal channels using interlocutors such as academic members of think-tanks. This occurs in situations where governments wish to express intentions or to suggest methods of resolving a diplomatic situation, but do not wish to express a formal position.

AFTER-READING activity

• Read the text in more depth to do the ‘After-reading exercises’.

Ex. 1 Comprehension questions

1. What is normally viewed as “a great breach of honour”?

2. What were Genghis Khan and the Mongols well known for?

3. When and where were diplomatic rights established?

4. What Convention were these rights formalized by ?

5. What Convention protects diplomats from being persecuted or prosecuted?

6. What is a diplomatic pouch?

7. Why diplomats are sometimes recalled by their home countries from the host country?

8. Were any diplomats held hostage in the history of diplomacy? Give an example.

9. Is diplomacy linked to espionage? Prove your viewpoint.

10. What is information gleaned from espionage used for?

11. Is it difficult for countries which are fully sovereign to receive recognition? Why?

12. What is track 2 diplomacy?

• Work with the dictionary and consult the text to do ex. 2 and 3

Ex. 2. Translate from English into Russian

To observe the sanctity of diplomats; a great breach of honour; to wreak horrific vengeance against a state; to established rights; Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations protects diplomats from being persecuted or prosecuted; times of hostility; guarantee of good behaviour; deep-cover spies operating in many embassies; track 2 diplomacy

Ex. 3. Translate from Russian into English

Дипломатическая неприкосновенность; нарушать права; совершить серьезное преступление; отзывать дипломатов; нарушить договор; высокопоставленный человек; собирать информацию

Ex. 4. Find sentences in the text to illustrate the usage of the following vocabulary:

Think tank; breach of contract; sacrosanct obligation; host country; home country; to glean; in situ; counter-intelligence; reconnaissance; interlocution; hostility

Ex. 5. Translate the words in brackets into English (Key)

1) Members of these sects are ruthlessly (преследуются). 2) He was (преследовали) for fraud. 3) How much did you pay the man to (следил) on your husband? 4) The (святая неприкосновенность) of private life. 5) To suspend (военные действия ). 6) The family were so ashamed when the youngest son was (выгнали) from his school. 7) Terrorists seized some tourists (в заложники). 8) You are (выгнали) from the house which you have indelibly disgraced.

Ex. 6. Translate into English (Key)

1) Приостанавливать военные действия. 2) Cвятая неприкосновенность личной жизни

3) Террористы захватили туристов в заложники. 4) Семья не знала, куда деться от стыда, когда младшего сына выгнали из школы. 5) Его преследовали за мошенничество (fraud). 6) Члены этих сект безжалостно преследуются. 7) И сколько же ты заплатила этому человеку, чтобы он следил за твоим мужем.

Ex. 7. Work with the dictionary and consult the vocabulary list to translate the text from English into Russian in the written form.