Клиническая психиатрия_Каплан_Седок

&/,1,&$/ 36<&+,$75<

6<1236,6 2) 36<&+,$75 +$52/' .$3/$1 0 '

3URIHVVRU RI 3V\FKLDWU\ 1HZ <RUN 8QLYHUVLW\ 6FKRRO RI 0HGLFLQH $WWHQGLQJ 3V\FKLDWULVW 8QLYHUVLW\ +RVSLWDO RI WKH 1HZ <RUN 8QLYHUVLW\ 0HGLFDO &HQWHU $WWHQGLQJ 3V\FKLDWULVW %HOOHYXH +RVSLWDO 1HZ <RUN 1HZ <RUN

%(1-$0,1 - 6$'2&. 0 '

3URIHVVRU DQG 9LFH &KDLUPDQ 'HSDUWPHQW RI 3V\FKLDWU\ 1HZ <RUN 8QLYHUVLW\ 6FKRRO RI 0HGLFLQH $WWHQGLQJ 3V\FKLDWULVW 8QLYHUVLW\ +RVSLWDO RI WKH 1HZ <RUN 8QLYHUVLW\ 0HGLFDO &HQWHU $WWHQGLQJ 3V\FKLDWULVW %HOOHYXH +RVSLWDO 1HZ <RUN 1HZ <RUN :,//,$06 :,/.,16 %DOWLPRUH ‡ +RQJ .RQJ ‡ /RQGRQ ‡ 6\GQH\

=B DZieZg ; >` Kw^hd

DEBGBQ?KD:Y IKBOB:LJBY

BA KBGHIKBK: IH IKBOB:LJBB

< lhfZo

lhf

I_j_\h^ k Zg]ebckdh]h ^hdl f_^ gZmd < ; Klj_e_p

Fhkd\Z ©F_^bpbgZ

;;D D M>D

Ba^Zgb_ j_dhf_g^h\Zgh ^ey i_j_\h^Z ^ f g < G DJ:KGH<UF aZf ^bj_dlhjZ GBB ikbobZljbb FA JN

>ZggZy dgb]Z ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc qZklv [hevrh]h jmdh\h^kl\Z \ dhlhjhf hibkZgu hkgh\u debgbdb ^bZ]ghklbdb b e_q_gby ikbobq_kdbo jZkkljhckl\

< i_j\hf lhf_ ijb\_^_gu hibkZgby jZkkljhckl\ gZ[ex^Zxsboky ijb hj]Zgbq_kdhf ikbohkbg^jhf_ aehmihlj_[e_gbb ikbohZdlb\gufb \_s_kl\Zfb Z lZd`_ [j_^h\uo khfZlhnhjfguo ^bkkhpbZlb\guo b ^jm]bo \b^h\ jZkkljhckl\

Dgb]Z ij_^gZagZq_gZ ^ey ikbobZljh\ b ki_pbZebklh\ kf_`guo ^bkpbiebg i_j_\h^ gZ jmkkdbc yaud

H=E:<E?GB?

Ij_^bkeh\b_

=eZ\Z Debgbq_kdh_ h[ke_^h\Zgb_ ikbobq_kdb [hevgh]h

=eZ\Z Lbibqgu_ ijbagZdb b kbfilhfu ikbobq_kdbo aZ[he_\Zgbc =eZ\Z DeZkkbnbdZpby \ ikbobZljbb '60 ,,, 5

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z gZ[ex^Zxsb_ky ijb hj]Zgbq_kdhf ikbohkbg^jhf_

=eZ\Z IkbobZljbq_kdb_ Zki_dlu kbg^jhfZ ijbh[j_l_ggh]h bffmgh^_nbpblZ KIB>

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z k\yaZggu_ kh aehmihlj_[e_gb_f ikbohZdlb\gufb \_s_kl\Zfb

=eZ\Z Rbahnj_gby

=eZ\Z ;j_^h\u_ iZjZghb^gu_ jZkkljhckl\Z

=eZ\Z Ikbohlbq_kdb_ jZkkljhckl\Z gb]^_ [he__ g_ deZkkbnbpbjm_fu_ >jm]h_ gZa\Zgb_ hlkmlkl\m_l >GH

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z gZkljh_gby

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z \ \b^_ lj_\h`ghklb beb g_\jhau lj_\h`ghklb b nh[bq_kdb_ g_\jhau

=eZ\Z KhfZlhnhjfgu_ jZkkljhckl\Z

=eZ\Z >bkkhpbZlb\gu_ jZkkljhckl\Z

=eZ\Z K_dkmZevgZy kn_jZ q_eh\_dZ

=eZ\Z Khg b gZjmr_gby kgZ

=eZ\Z Bkdmkkl\_ggh ^_fhgkljbjm_fu_ jZkkljhckl\Z

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z dhgljhey gZ^ k\hbfb bfimevkZfb gb]^_ [he__ g_ deZkkbnbpbjm_fu_ >jm]h_ gZa\Zgb_ hlkmlkl\m_l >GH

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z Z^ZilZpbb

=eZ\Z Ikboheh]bq_kdb_ nZdlhju \ebyxsb_ gZ nbabq_kdh_ khklhygb_ikbohkhfZlbq_kdb_ jZkkljhckl\Z

=eZ\Z JZkkljhckl\Z ebqghklb

IJ?>BKEH<B?

IkbobZljby k_]h^gyrg_]h ^gy ^he`gZ ih^q_jdb\Zlv ]mfZgguc b khqm\kl\_gguc Zki_dlu f_^bpbgu >Zggh_ jmdh\h^kl\h ihk\ys_gh wlhfm ]mfZgbafm dhlhjuc qZklh l_jy_lky \ l_ogbq_kdb hkgZs_gghc kh\j_f_gghc f_^bpbgkdhc ijZdlbd_ Lhqgh lZd `_ \aZbfhhlghr_gby f_`^m mq_[gufb f_^bpbgkdbfb nZdmevl_lZfb b klm^_glZfb lj_[mxl ih^q_jdgmlh]h \gbfZgby _keb fu ohlbf ba[_`Zlv ihy\e_gby ih^h[guo dhfivxl_jm \jZq_c jh[hlh\

< Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlZo :f_jbdb ikbobZljby y\ey_lky _^bgkl\_gghc f_^bpbgkdhc ^bkpbiebghc dmjk ij_ih^Z\Zgby dhlhjhc ijh\h^blky g_ij_ju\gh \ l_q_gb_ q_luj_o e_l ?keb ij_ih^Z\Zgb_ \_^_lky gZ ^he`ghf mjh\g_ wlhl dmjk ^he`_g [ulv \hegmxsbf gZihfbgZgb_f \k_f h lhf qlh aZ^ZqZ f_^bpbgu²klZ\blv ^bZ]gha e_qblv b ^h[b\Zlvky h[e_]q_gby [heb kljZ^Zgby b aZ[he_\Zgby hkgh\u\Zykv gZ ih^oh^_ d [hevghfm dZd d p_ehklghc ebqghklb

Gh\h_ ba^Zgb_ \ mf_gvr_gghf jZaf_j_ WlZ dgb]Z y\ey_lky qZklvx [hevr_]h ba^Zgby \ dhlhjhf ho\Zq_gu hkgh\u ih\_^_gq_kdbo gZmd b debgbq_kdbo ikbobq_kdbo jZkkljhckl\ >Zggh_ f_gvr__ ba^Zgb_ \dexqZ_l hibkZgb_ lhevdh debgbq_kdbo ijhy\e_gbc ikbobq_kdbo jZkkljhckl\ Jmdh\h^kl\h \ iheghf h[t_f_ ^Z_l \hafh`ghklv klm^_glm ihevah\Zlvky dgb]hc gZ ijhly`_gbb \k_o q_luj_o e_l mq_[u \ f_^bpbgkdhf bgklblml_ >Zggh_ jmdh\h^kl\h ]h^blky ^ey klm^_glZ dhlhjhfm lj_[m_lky mq_[gbd \dexqZxsbc lhevdh debgbq_kdmx ikbobZljbx Fu kqblZ_f qlh lZdZy ]b[dhklv h[_ki_qb\Z_l \hafh`ghklv \u[hjZ ^ey rbjhdh]h djm]Z qblZl_e_c aZgbfZxsboky ikbobZljb_c ikboheh]b_c khpbZevghc ^_yl_evghklvx \ ikbobZljbb ^_yl_evghklvx kj_^g_]h f_^bpbgkdh]h i_jkhgZeZ \ ikbobZljbb ih\_^_gq_kdhc j_dj_Zpbhgghc\hkklZgh\bl_evghc l_jZib_c b ^jm]bfb Zki_dlZfb k\yaZggufb k ikbobq_kdbf a^hjh\v_f

Gh\u_ baf_g_gby \ wlhf ba^Zgbb WlZ dgb]Z kh^_j`bl gh\_crb_ jZajZ[hldb \ debgbq_kdhc ikbobZljbb < qZklghklb \ g_c ij_^klZ\e_gZ ghaheh]by jZajZ[hlZggZy \ lj_lv_f bkijZ\e_gghf ba^Zgbb :f_jbdZgkdhc IkbobZljbq_kdhc :kkhpbZpbb ©>bZ]ghklbq_kdh_ b klZlbklbq_kdh_ jmdh\h^kl\h ih ikbobq_kdbf aZ[he_\Zgbyfª

'LDJQRVWLFDO DQG 6WDWLVWLFDO 0DQXDO RI 0HQWDO 'LVRUGHUV '60 ,,, 5 dhlhjh_ [ueh him[ebdh\Zgh \ ] < g__ \dexq_gu ^hklb`_gby \ h[eZklb bamq_gby hj]Zgbq_kdh]h ikbohkbg^jhfZ b k\yaZgguo k gbf jZkkljhckl\ gZjmr_gbc h[mkeh\e_gguo mihlj_[e_gb_f ikbohZdlb\guo \_s_kl\ kh^_j`blky gh\uc b jZkrbj_gguc jZa^_e hibkZgby jZkkljhckl\ kgZ Ih^jh[gh h[km`^Zxlky ihke_^gb_ j_amevlZlu [bheh]bq_kdbo bkke_^h\Zgbc \ oh^_ dhlhjuo [ueb h[gZjm`_gu wlbheh]bq_kdb_ nZdlu e_`Zsb_ \ hkgh\_ jZaebqguo ikbobq_kdbo jZkkljhckl\

I_j_kfhlj_g jZa^_e ihk\ys_gguc lj_\h]_ dZd ghjfZevghc lZd b iZlheh]bq_kdhc <dexq_gu ihke_^gb_ jZajZ[hldb \ h[eZklb ^_lkdhc ikbobZljbb \ lhf qbke_ kmbpb^u m ^_l_c Bf__lky h[rbjguc b ih^jh[guc h[ahj e_q_gby \dexqZy ijbf_g_gb_ eZ[hjZlhjguo l_klh\ \ ikbobZljbb

< k\yab k ih^q_jdgmlhc debgbq_kdhc gZijZ\e_gghklvx wlh]h jmdh\h^kl\Z Z\lhju ^Zeb jy^ hibkZgbc debgbq_kdbo bklhjbc [he_agb \ ijbeh`_gbb Hgb ijhbeexkljbjh\Zeb fgh`_kl\h jZaebqguo aZ[he_\Zgbc hibkZgguo \ ^Zgghc dgb]_ Wlb hibkZgby \aylu ba©Dgb]b bklhjbc [he_agbª '60 ,,, 5 him[ebdh\Zgghc :f_jbdZgkdhc IkbobZljbq_kdhc :kkhpbZpb_c b i_j_kfhlj_gu Z\lhjZfb \ k\yab k lj_[h\Zgbyfb kh\j_f_gghklb ^ey lh]h qlh[u hgb khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb '60 ,,, 5

Bkihevah\Zgb_ dgb]b klm^_glZfb MgbdZevghc hkh[_gghklvx wlh]h jmdh\h^kl\Z y\ey_lky _]h ihjlZlb\ghklv b hj]ZgbaZpby Bf fh]ml ihevah\Zlvky b l_ klm^_glu dhlhjuf g_h[oh^bfZ qj_a\uqZcgh ih^jh[gZy bgnhjfZpby h iheghf ^bZiZahg_ ikbobq_kdbo jZkkljhckl\ b l_ dhlhjuf gm`gu hkgh\gu_ fhf_glu oZjZdl_jbamxsb_ dZ`^h_ jZkkljhckl\h \ ^Zgghc dgb]_ hgb ij_^klZ\e_gu \ lZ[ebqghc nhjf_ ^ey h[e_]q_gby ihevah\Zgby Ijb\h^ylky lZd`_ ^hau ij_iZjZlh\ ihdZaZgby b ijhlb\hihdZaZgby d bo ijbf_g_gbx \dexqZy \_s_kl\Z lhevdh qlh klZ\rb_ ba\_klgufb =eZ\Z ihk\ys_ggZy g_hleh`ghc ihfhsb \ ikbobZljbb \dexqZ_l gZb[he__ agZqbfu_ ^Zggu_ >Zggh_ jmdh\h^kl\h ih debgbq_kdhc ikbobZljbb b ©Kbghikbk ih ikbobZljbbª khklZ\eyxl h^gm qZklv ljhcghc kbkl_fu jZajZ[hlZgghc Z\lhjZfb ^ey h[e_]q_gby h[mq_gby ikbobZljbb b gZmdZf h ih\_^_gbb >jm]Zy qZklv wlhc kbkl_fu ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ©<k_klhjhgg__ Jmdh\h^kl\h ih IkbobZljbbª dhlhjh_ kdhjh ihy\blky \ iylhf ba^Zgbb ]eh[Zevgh_ ih ]em[bg_ b rbjhl_ ho\ZlZ gh kh\k_f g_ lZdh_ ihjlZlb\gh_ dZd wlZ dgb]Z H[_ wlb dgb]b bf_xl iml_\h^bl_ev d ^Zgghfm jmdh\h^kl\m qlh iha\hey_l klm^_glm bamqblv ex[hc ij_^f_l [he__ ]em[hdh hibjZykv gZ hibkZgb_ k^_eZggh_ ki_pbZebklhf \ ^Zgghc h[eZklb AZdexqbl_evgZy qZklv ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ©Iml_\h^bl_evª ^ey bamq_gby b kZfhklhyl_evgh]h ZgZebaZ h[ahjZ ©KbghikbkZ ih ikbobZljbbª dhlhjuc khklhbl ba ijh[e_f kh fgh`_kl\_gguf \u[hjhf j_r_gbc b hl\_lh\ dhlhju_ fh`gh ^Zlv hibjZykv gZ bf_xsb_ky dexqb d l_dms_fm ba^Zgbx ©KbghikbkZ ih ikbobZljbbª Dgb]Z \hijhkh\ kh fgh`_kl\_gguf \u[hjhf ^Z_l \hafh`ghklv hp_gblv \Z`ghklv b \deZ^ GZpbhgZevgh]h Kh\_lZ mq_guo jZ[hlZxsbo

\ h[eZklb f_^bpbgu b :f_jbdZgkdh]h Kh\_lZ ih ikbobZljbb b g_\jheh]bb kha^Z\rbo dmjk h[mq_gby gZ dhlhjhf hkgh\Zgu \k_ gZrb dgb]b Bo bkke_^h\Zgby ijb\_^_gu \ nhjf_ ijh[e_fu kh fgh`_kl\_gguf \u[hjhf j_r_gbc y\eyxs_cky lbihf \hijhkZ b f_lh^hf ij_ih^Z\Zgby bkihevam_fufb \ Iml_\h^bl_e_ ^ey bamq_gby dhlhjuc j_dhf_g^m_lky dZd khijh\h^bl_evgh_ ba^Zgb_ ^ey h^gh\j_f_ggh]h bkihevah\Zgby k

©Kbghikbkhf ih ikbobZljbbª < lh \j_fy dZd Z\lhju ijbagZxl h]jhfgmx \Z`ghklv b ihablb\guc \deZ^ wlbo Kh\_lh\ hlghkbl_evgh bo \ebygby b kbeu \ha^_ckl\by ohly b ihablb\gh]h gZ gZrm kbkl_fm h[jZah\Zgby kms_kl\mxl hij_^_e_ggu_ ijhlb\hj_qby Lhqgh lZd `_ ghaheh]by bkihevah\ZggZy \ wlhf jmdh\h^kl\_ hkgh\u\Z_lky gZ i_j_kfhlj_gghf lj_lv_f ba^Zgbb :f_jbdZgkdhc IkbobZljbq_kdhc :kkhpbZpbb ©>bZ]ghklbq_kdh_ b klZlbklbq_kdh_ jmdh\h^kl\h ih ikbobq_kdbf aZ[he_\Zgbyfª '60

,,, 5 dhlhjh_ y\ey_lky aZdhghf \ Zf_jbdZgkdhc ikbobZljbb Lh]^Z dZd Z\lhju bf_xl h]h\hjdb hlghkbl_evgh ihe_aghklb b h[hkgh\Zgghklb '60 ,,, 5 dhlhjZy kh^_j`bl gh\h\\_^_gby \uau\Zxsb_ bgh]^Z khfg_gby \ hlghr_gbb __ ij_bfms_kl\ i_j_^ '60

,,, klm^_glu ^he`gu bamqblv '60 ,,, 5 ^h l_o ihj ihdZ hgZ g_ baf_gblky hij_^_e_gguf h[jZahf b dh]^Z [m^_l him[ebdh\ZgZ \_jkby '60 ,9

=eZ\Z

DEBGBQ?KDH? H;KE?>H<:GB? IKBOBQ?KDB ;HEVGH=H

;?K?>: K ;HEVGUF < IKBOB:LJBQ?KDHC DEBGBD? <<?>?GB?

< khhl\_lkl\bb k iheh`_gbyfb kh\j_f_gghc ikbobZljbb [_k_^Z k ikbobq_kdb [hevguf hkgh\ZgZ gZ lhqghf ihgbfZgbb \jZqhf oZjZdl_jZ ikbohiZlheh]bb b ^bgZfbdb l_q_gby [he_agb ;_k_^Z g_ ^he`gZ ijhbkoh^blv [_a ij_^\Zjbl_evghc ih^]hlh\db \h \j_fy kemqZcghc \klj_qb \jZqZ b [hevgh]h ;_k_^Z k [hevguf \ ikbobZljbq_kdhc debgbd_ hkgh\ZgZ gZ lhf qlh ikbobZlj ² wlh ki_pbZebkl \ h[eZklb bkke_^h\Zgby ^_yl_evghklb fha]Z b f_`ebqghklguo hlghr_gbc b ke_^h\Zl_evgh y\ey_lky ^ey [hevgh]h g_ ijhklh khqm\kl\mxsbf kemrZl_e_f Bkdmkkl\h \jZqZ ikbobZljZ \ ijh\_^_gbb [_k_^u khklhbl \ lhf qlh[u aZ^Z\Zlv [hevghfm h^gb \hijhku b g_ dZkZlvky ^jm]bo wlh bkdmkkl\h bf__l _s_ p_euc jy^ hkh[_gghkl_c h dhlhjuo [m^_l kdZaZgh gb`_ \ wlhc `_ ]eZ\_

;_k_^Z k [hevguf fh`_l hkeh`gylvky l_f h[klhyl_evkl\hf qlh g_ \k_ ikbobq_kdb [hevgu_ ^h[jh\hevgh h[jZsZxlky aZ ihfhsvx d \jZqm b m gbo fh]ml \hh[s_ hlkmlkl\h\Zlv `_eZgb_ b beb kihkh[ghklv \klmiZlv k \jZqhf \ dhglZdl H^gbo [hevguo m^Z_lky m]h\hjblv [ulv hldjh\_gguf k \jZqhf qlh[u h[e_]qblv k\hb kljZ^Zgby ^jm]b_ `_ kdehggu kdju\Zlv k\hb kZfu_ khdjh\_ggu_ qm\kl\Z b ijbqbgu k\hbo ^mr_\guo ihljyk_gbc

Bgh]^Z [hevgu_ ihgbfZy qlh [he_agv ijhy\ey_l \ gbo g_ kZfu_ emqrb_ ebqghklgu_ dZq_kl\Z g_ ohlyl ]h\hjblv h k_[_ ihdZ g_ m[_^ylky qlh jZkkdZaZ\ g_ ihl_jyxl m\Z`_gby \jZqZ Ih wlhc ijbqbg_ keh`b\rb_ky f_`^m [hevguf b \jZqhf hlghr_gby hdZau\Zxl agZqbl_evgh_ \ebygb_ gZ lh qlh [hevghc ]h\hjbl \jZqm b qlh hg kdju\Z_l

N:DLHJU <EBYXSB? G: ;?K?>M

Kh^_j`Zgb_ b oh^ [_k_^u aZ\bkyl hl fgh`_kl\Z nZdlhjh\ g_dhlhju_ ba gbo fu ijb\h^bf gb`_

AgZqbl_evgh_ \ebygb_ gZ nhjfm khh[s_gby [hevguf k\_^_gbc h k_[_ b gZ oh^

jZa\blby [_k_^u hdZau\Zxl oZjZdl_j kbfilhfh\ [he_agb b ebqghklgu_ hkh[_gghklb [hevgh]h

LZdb_ oZjZdl_jgu_ ^ey debgbdb kblmZpbb dZd gZijbf_j ke_^mxsb_ [hevghc gZoh^blky ih^ gZ[ex^_gb_f f_^bpbgkdh]h i_jkhgZeZ \ [hevgbqghc iZeZl_ [hevghc k ikbohkhfZlbq_kdbfb kbfilhfZfb [hevghc dhlhjuc g_ fh`_l kijZ\blvky k ^mr_\gufb i_j_`b\Zgbyfb beb [hevghc dhlhjuc gm`^Z_lky \ g_hleh`ghc ihfhsb ² kha^Zxl hkh[u_ jZfdb \ dhlhjuo nhjfbjm_lky [_k_^Z

GZ oh^ [_k_^u fh]ml hdZau\Zlv \ebygb_ b g_ lhevdh lZdb_ l_ogbq_kdb_ nZdlhju dZd l_e_nhggu_ a\hgdb bkihevah\Zgb_ ^bdlhnhgZ gh b h[t_f b dhfnhjlghklv dhfgZlu \ dhlhjhc hgZ ijhoh^bl

<u[hj \j_f_gb ^ey ijh\_^_gby [_k_^u b hkh[_gghklb wlh]h i_jbh^Z \ ijhp_kk_ jZa\blby [he_agb fh]ml bf_lv agZq_gb_ \ kh^_j`Zgbb b oh^_ [_k_^u

Kms_kl\_ggufb nZdlhjZfb hdZau\Zxsbfb \ebygb_ gZ oh^ [_k_^u y\eyxlky b fZg_jZ \_^_gby mf_gb_ hjb_glbjh\Zlvky b hiul \jZqZ Ijb wlhf ^Z`_ hl \u[hjZ ih^oh^ys_]h fhf_glZ ^ey lZdbo \hkdebpZgbc dZd ©hoª b ©Zoª aZ\bkbl qlh [hevgu_ khh[sZxl lZd dZd hgb g_hkhagZggh hibjZxlky gZ kZfu_ g_agZqbl_evgu_ ih^kdZadb kh klhjhgu bgl_j\vxbjmxs_]h ebpZ

JHEV <J:Q: IJH<H>YS?=H ;?K?>M

KZfh_ ]eZ\gh_ ^ey bgl_j\vxbjmxs_]h ebpZ²\gbfZl_evgh kemrZlv b ihgbfZlv [hevgh]h qlh \ ^Zevg_cr_f bkihevam_lky ^ey mklZgh\e_gby \aZbfhihgbfZgby b \u[hjZ ko_fu e_q_gby gZijZ\e_gghc h^gh\j_f_ggh gZ dmibjh\Zgb_ kbfilhfh\ [he_agb b gZ jZaj_r_gb_ ebqguo ijh[e_f [hevgh]h EbpZ ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m bkihevamxl k\hb kh[kl\_ggu_ wfiZlbq_kdb_ j_Zdpbb ^ey lh]h qlh[u h[e_]qblv ijhp_kk mklZgh\e_gby \aZbfhihgbfZgby < p_ehf ebpZ ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m g_ ^he`gu hkm`^Zlv [hevgh]h bf ke_^m_l ijhy\eylv aZbgl_j_kh\Zgghklv khi_j_`b\Zgb_ b ^h[jhlm <h \j_fy [_k_^u hgb qZklh aZ^Zxl \hijhku qlh[u ihemqblv g_h[oh^bfmx bgnhjfZpbx beb `_ mlhqgblv ijZ\bevgh eb hgb ihgyeb [hevgh]h beb ijZ\bevgh eb [hevghc ihgbfZ_l lh h q_f b^_l j_qv < \hijhk_ fh`_l [ulv bkdmkgh aZfZkdbjh\Zg kh\_l beb `_ bglhgZpby dhlhjhc aZ^Z_lky \hijhk fh`_l ihdZaZlv qlh [hevghfm jZaj_rZ_lky k^_eZlv lh h q_f hg ]h\hjbl GZijbf_j bgl_j\vxbjmxs__ ebph fh`_l kijhkblv ©=h\hjbeb eb \u dh]^Z gb[m^v k\h_fm fm`m h lhf qlh \u qm\kl\m_l_ ih wlhfm ih\h^m"ª

Ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m fh]ml ijyfh beb dhk\_ggh ^Z\Zlv k\hbf [hevguf kh\_lu Hgb fh]ml gZijbf_j ihkh\_lh\Zlv [hevghfm h[km^blv k d_f gb[m^v p_e_khh[jZaghklv k\h_]h ^_ckl\by dhlhjh_ hg gZf_j_g hkms_kl\blv beb `_ qlh [ueh [u `_eZl_evgh beb gZh[hjhl g_`_eZl_evgh jZkkdZaZlv h k\hbo qm\kl\Zo ebpZf b]jZxsbf \Z`gmx jhev \ _]h beb __ `bagb Bgh]^Z ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m \jZqb fh]ml ^Z\Zlv k\hbf [hevguf kh\_lu beb ijZdlbq_kdb_ j_dhf_g^Zpbb dZkZxsb_ky bo `bagb

QZklh ^_yl_evghklv bgl_j\vxbjmxsbo kem`bl m^h\e_l\hj_gbx wfhpbhgZevghc ihlj_[ghklb [hevgh]h qm\kl\h\Zlv k_[y aZsbs_gguf beb ex[bfuf H^gZdh kemqZ_lky qlh bo ^_yl_evghklv [u\Z_l ls_lghc²hgZ g_ fh`_l m^h\e_l\hjblv wfhpbhgZevguo ihlj_[ghkl_c [hevguo lZd dZd hgb g_ fh]ml ih \her_[kl\m jZaj_rblv j_Zevgu_ ijh[e_fu [hevguo beb gZclb bf emqrmx jZ[hlm beb emqr_]h kmijm]Z

Ijh\h^ysbc [_k_^m fh`_l \gmrblv [hevghfm qlh[u hg g_ [hyeky Z lZd`_ ih^[h^jblv _]h gZijbf_j lZdbfb keh\Zfb ©Ih`ZemcklZ ijh^he`Zcl_ m \Zk ohjhrh ihemqZ_lkyª

EbpZ ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m ^he`gu ijb hij_^_e_gguo h[klhyl_evkl\Zo ij_k_dZlv ihklmidb k\hbo [hevguo _keb l_ g_ fh]ml k_[y dhgljhebjh\Zlv beb _keb hgb iulZxlky gZiZklv gZ ^jm]bo [hevguo gZoh^ysboky \ ih^Z\e_gghf khklhygbb

Bgl_j\vxbjmxsb_ ebpZ ihfh]Zxl lZd`_ kha^Zlv m [hevgh]h Z^_d\Zlgmx kZfhhp_gdm _keb hgb dhgp_gljbjmxl \gbfZgb_ gZ _]h mki_oZo b lZeZglZo wlh fh`_l hkeZ[blv bf_xs__ky m [hevgh]h qm\kl\h \bgh\ghklb b kfy]qblv `_klhdh_©kmi_j W]hª

Ijh\h^ysb_ [_k_^m \u^\b]Zxl k\h_ h[tykg_gb_ gZ[ex^Zxsbfky m [hevgh]h y\e_gbyf dhlhju_ \uau\Zxl m g_]h ly`_eu_ i_j_`b\Zgby k p_evx jZajmrblv [he_ag_gguc ijhp_kk Wlh kihkh[kl\m_l lZd`_ lhfm qlh [hevghc gZqbgZ_l hkhagZ\Zlv k\hb [_kkhagZl_evgu_ fukeb b qm\kl\Z b \ j_amevlZl_ wlh]h kijZ\ey_lky k kh[kl\_ggufb dhgnebdlZfb [_a \hagbdgh\_gby gh\uo [he_ag_gguo kbfilhfh\

>\mfy hkgh\gufb ih^]hlh\bl_evgufb klZ^byfb nhjfbjh\Zgby \jZqhf k\h_]h h[tykg_gby kbfilhfh\ [hevgh]h y\eyxlky dhgnjhglZpby beb nbdkZpby qlh [hevghc q_]h lh ba[_]Z_l b deZjbnbdZpby beb \u^_e_gb_ h[eZklb \ jZfdZo dhlhjhc \jZqm ke_^m_l kdhgp_gljbjh\Zlv k\hb \hijhku

IJ:DLBQ?KDB? A:F?Q:GBY

NZdlhj \j_f_gb

;_k_^u \ ikbobZljbq_kdhc debgbd_ bf_xl jZaebqgmx ijh^he`bl_evghklv DhgkmevlZpby g_h[oh^bfZy ^ey gZagZq_gby e_q_gby ijh^he`Z_lky \ kj_^g_f hl ^hfbg ;_k_^Z k [hevguf gZoh^ysbfky \ ikbohlbq_kdhf khklhygbb beb \ khklhygbb bglhdkbdZpbb qZklh [u\Z_l g_ijh^he`bl_evghc lZd dZd bgh]^Z m gbo m`_ q_j_a fbg gZqbgZxlky ijhy\e_gby klj_kkZ H^gZdh \ ihf_s_gbb \ dhlhjhf hdZau\Z_lky g_hleh`gZy ihfhsv fh`_l ihlj_[h\Zlvky [he__ ^ebl_evgZy [_k_^Z < [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ [hevghc ^he`_g agZlv aZjZg__ kdhevdh ijb[ebabl_evgh \j_f_gb [m^_l ijh^he`Zlvky [_k_^Z

Lh dZd [hevgu_ jZkihjy`Zxlky k\hbf \j_f_g_f lZd`_ ijbhldju\Z_l hij_^_e_ggu_ ]jZgb bo oZjZdl_jZ < [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ [hevgu_ ijboh^yl gZ [_k_^m aZ g_kdhevdh fbgml ^h __ gZqZeZ Lj_\h`guc [hevghc fh`_l y\blvky b gZ iheqZkZ jZgvr_ < lhf kemqZ_ _keb [hevghc ijbr_e kebrdhf jZgh b m g_]h g_l kbfilhfh\ lj_\h`ghklb \hafh`gh ke_^m_l \uykgblv ijbqbgm wlh]h ?keb [hevghc hiZa^u\Z_l qlh aZljm^gy_l jZ[hlm k gbf g_h[oh^bfh kgZqZeZ \ukemrZlv _]h h[tykg_gb_ b ijb wlhf ^Z`_ ihkhqm\kl\h\Zlv _keb hiha^Zgb_ \ua\Zgh g_ aZ\bkysbfb hl [hevgh]h h[klhyl_evkl\Zfb H^gZdh gZ^h ba[_]Zlv lZdbo dhff_glZjbc dZd©G_ [_kihdhcl_kv \k_ \ ihjy^d_ª ?keb [hevghc y\gh e`_l iulZykv kdjulv g_`_eZgb_ [_k_^h\Zlv k \jZqhf gZijbf_j ©Y kh\k_f aZ[ue h[ wlhc \klj_q_ª fh`gh kijhkblv _]h ©<u g_ ohl_eb ijboh^blv"ª ?keb [hevghc q_klgh hl\_lbl ©^Zª ikbobZlj fh`_l ijh^he`Zlv h[ke_^h\Zgb_ Gh _keb ihke_^m_l hl\_l ©g_lª emqr_ [_k_^m i_j_g_klb gZ [m^ms__ < kemqZ_ hiha^Zgby bgh]^Z i_j_^ [_k_^hc fh`gh kdZaZlv ©Gm eZ^gh fu ihklZjZ_fky k^_eZlv dZd fh`gh [hevr_ aZ lh \j_fy qlh m gZk hklZehkvª

Hq_gv \Z`gh dZd kZf ikbobZlj bkihevam_l \j_fy \ ijhp_kk_ [_k_^u G_jZpbhgZevgh_ bkihevah\Zgb_ \j_f_gb mdZau\Z_l gZ jZ\gh^mrb_ \jZqZ d bgl_j_kZf [hevgh]h ?keb \jZqm ijboh^blky ij_j\Zlv [_k_^m ba aZ k\hbo g_hleh`guo ^_e g_h[oh^bfh ba\bgblvky aZ lh qlh [hevghfm ijbrehkv `^Zlv

NZdlhj ihf_s_gby

< [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ [hevgu_ g_ fh]ml ]h\hjblv hldjh\_ggh ^h l_o ihj ihdZ g_ m[_^ylky qlh gZoh^ylky \ m_^bg_gbb b gbdlh g_ ih^kemrb\Z_l bo [_k_^m < kihdhcghc h[klZgh\d_ h[_ klhjhgu f_gvr_ hl\e_dZxlky q_f \ rmfghc `_eZl_evgh qlh[u [_k_^Z g_ ij_ju\ZeZkv dZd bkdexq_gb_ fh`gh ^himklblv ebrv dhjhldbc l_e_nhgguc a\hghd g_ [hevr_ q_f h^bg aZ \kx [_k_^m

H[_ki_q_gb_ m^h[guo f_kl gZ dhlhjuo \h \j_fy [_k_^u jZkiheZ]Zxlky __ mqZklgbdb lZd`_ kihkh[kl\m_l __ mki_om H[Z klmeZ ^he`gu [ulv ijb[ebabl_evgh h^bgZdh\hc \ukhlu qlh[u gb h^bg ba kh[_k_^gbdh\ g_ kfhlj_e gZ ^jm]h]h k\_jom djhf_ lh]h `_eZl_evgh bo jZkklZ\blv lZdbf h[jZahf qlh[u f_`^m \jZqhf b [hevguf g_ [ueh gbdZdhc f_[_eb ?keb \ dhfgZl_ g_kdhevdh klmev_\ \jZq ihdZau\Z_l dm^Z ky^_l hghgZ Z aZl_f ij_^eZ]Z_l iZpb_glm kZfhfm \u[jZlv k_[_ klme dhlhjuc _fm _c dZ`_lky gZb[he__ m^h[guf ;hevgu_ kdehggu_ d ih^qbg_gbx h[uqgh ij_^ihqblZxl klme dhlhjuc klhbl [eb`_ d ^\_jb [hevgu_ gZkljh_ggu_ \jZ`^_[gh beb kdehggu_ d i_j_ghkm \u[bjZxl klme klhysbc hq_gv ^Ze_dh ijbq_f qZklh kZ^ylky ijyfh gZijhlb\ \jZqZ

<_^_gb_ aZibk_c \h \j_fy [_k_^u

Ihkdhevdm \jZq g_k_l xjb^bq_kdmx b fhjZevgmx hl\_lkl\_gghklv aZ d\Zebnbpbjh\Zggmx j_]bkljZpbx ^bZ]ghaZ b e_q_gby dZ`^h]h [hevgh]h ykgh qlh gZebqb_ ibkvf_gguo ijhlhdheh\ kh\_jr_ggh g_h[oh^bfh GZb[he__ qZklh ^_eZxlky ^hklZlhqgh ih^jh[gu_ aZibkb \h \j_fy g_kdhevdbo i_j\uo [_k_^ dh]^Z kh[bjZxlky ^Zggu_ bklhjbb [he_agb < ^Zevg_cr_f [hevrbgkl\h ikbobZljh\ aZibku\Zxl lhevdh gh\u_ ^Zggu_ \dexqZy gZb[he__ \Z`gu_ kh[ulby gZagZq_gb_ e_dZjkl\_gguo ij_iZjZlh\ bo wnn_dlb\ghklv l_g^_gpbb d i_j_ghkm beb ijhlb\hi_j_ghkm khg Z lZd`_ k\h_ fg_gb_ h oZjZdl_j_ jZa\blby [he_agb

G_dhlhju_ [hevgu_ \hafmsZxlky _keb \jZq g_ aZibku\Z_l lh qlh hgb ]h\hjbeb \ wlhf kemqZ_ bf dZ`_lky qlh kdZaZggh_ g_ y\ey_lky \Z`guf b g_ ij_^klZ\ey_l bgl_j_kZ ^ey \jZqZ >jm]b_ [hevgu_ gZijhlb\ g_ i_j_ghkyl dh]^Z bo \ukdZau\Zgby aZibku\Zxlky \ wlhf kemqZ_ g_h[oh^bfh hldZaZlvky hl \_^_gby aZibk_c

>:GGU? IHEMQ?GGU? <H <J?FY ;?K?>U ;HEVGHC

<h \j_fy [_k_^u fh`gh ihemqblv ^Zggu_ h oZjZdl_j_ ikbohiZlheh]bb ikboh^bgZfbdb kbe_ ebqghklb fhlb\Zpbb i_j_ghk_ b khijhlb\e_gbb

QZklh [hevghc ijboh^y d ikbobZljm ^mfZ_l qlh \jZqZ [m^ml bgl_j_kh\Zlv ebrv kbfilhfu [he_agb b hldehg_gby \ oZjZdl_j_ GZ lZdh]h [hevgh]h fh`_l ih^_ckl\h\Zlv h[h^jyxs_ qlh \jZq bgl_j_km_lky _]h beb __ nbgZgkh\uf iheh`_gb_f kihkh[ghklyfb b ^jm]bfb ebqghklgufb hkh[_gghklyfb H^gb [hevgu_ kZfb jZkkdZau\Zxl h[ wlhf ^jm]bf qlh[u ihemqblv wlm bgnhjfZpbx ijboh^blky aZ^Z\Zlv hl^_evgu_ \hijhku gZijbf_j ©Fh`_l_ eb \u jZkkdZaZlv h lhf qlh \Zf \ k_[_ gjZ\blkyª Bkdj_gghklv b ijZ\bevguc \u[hj fhf_glZ ^ey wlh]h \hijhkZ² \hl ^\Z g_h[oh^bfuo nZdlhjZ ^ey wlh]h ?keb \jZq ihqm\kl\m_l qlh g_dhlhju_ \hijhku ijbqbgyxl [hev lh \ wlhf kemqZ_

ke_^m_l hl\e_qv [hevgh]h b i_j_clb d [he__ ijbylghc ^ey g_]h l_f_ b kijhkblv gZijbf_j ©KdZ`bl_ fg_ dZd \u jZa\e_dZ_l_kvª" @_eZl_evgh fy]dh m^_j`b\Zlv [hevgh]h hl jZa]h\hjh\ gZ l_fu jZkkljZb\Zxsb_ _]h qlh[u ^Zlv \hafh`ghklv jZa\blvky i_j_oh^ghfm i_jbh^m Z aZl_f hij_^_eblv gZkdhevdh hg kihkh[_g [ulv k_j^_qguf b eZkdh\uf

I_j_ghk ² wlh ijhp_kk ijb dhlhjhf [hevgu_ [_kkhagZl_evgh b g_khhl\_lkl\_ggh kblmZpbb i_j_ghkyl gZ hdjm`Zxsbo bo ebp l_ iZll_jgu ih\_^_gby beb wfhpbhgZevgu_ j_Zdpbb dhlhju_ [_jml gZqZeh hl agZqbfuo ^ey gbo k ^_lkl\Z h[jZah\ Hlghkbl_evgZy Zghgbfghklv \jZq_c ikbobZljh\ b jhev dhlhjmx hgb \uihegyxl dZd [u aZf_gyy jh^bl_e_c h[e_]qZ_l wlhl i_j_ghk J_ZevgZy Z^_d\ZlgZy j_Zdpby [hevgh]h gZ k\h_]h \jZqZ d i_j_ghkm g_ hlghkylky

D ihablb\ghfm i_j_ghkm hlghkylky b^_Zebabjh\Zggu_ j_Zdpbb gZ \ul_kg_ggu_ k ^_lkl\Z h[jZau l_i_jv m`_ g_ khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ `bag_gghc kblmZpbb Ijbf_jZfb fh]ml kem`blv kemqZb dh]^Z [hevghc ijbibku\Z_l \jZqm \k_fh]msmx kbem L_ `_ kZfu_ ijbgpbiu e_`Zl \ hkgh\_ hij_^_e_gby g_]Zlb\gh]h i_j_ghkZ bklhqgbdZfb dhlhjh]h y\eyxlky kljZo ]g_\ g_^h\_jb_ d jh^bl_eyf i_j_`blu_ \ ^_lkl\_ Hkgh\hc nhjfbjh\Zgby i_j_ghkZ fh]ml klZlv b j_Zevgu_ nZdlhju k\yaZggu_ k \jZqhf Ihe \hajZkl fZg_ju khpbZevguc b wlgbq_kdbc nhg lZd`_ \ebyxl gZ kdhjhklv b gZijZ\e_gb_ jZa\blby j_Zdpbc m [hevguo Ihlj_[ghklv \ ex[\b m\Z`_gbb beb m^h\e_l\hj_gb_ ihlj_[ghklb d ih^qbg_gbx²gZb[he__ rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_ggu_ nhjfu i_j_ghkZ

Khijhlb\e_gb_ Wlbf l_jfbghf hij_^_eyxl ih\_^_gb_ [hevgh]h ijb dhlhjhf hg khijhlb\ey_lky e_q_gbx Khijhlb\e_gb_ bgh]^Z ijhy\ey_lky \ fZg_j_ h[s_gby \h \j_fy [_k_^u FheqZeb\hklv beb gZh[hjhl [heleb\hklv hkm`^_gb_ b ihijZ\db kh[kl\_gguo fuke_c Z lZd`_ nbdkZpby gZ dZdhc eb[h h^ghc nZa_ `bagb²g_dhlhju_ ijbf_ju khijhlb\e_gby

KemqZb dh]^Z [hevghc hiZa^u\Z_l gZ [_k_^m k \jZqhf aZ[u\Z_l h gZagZq_gghc \klj_q_ iulZ_lky ba[_`Zlv __ kkueZykv gZ h[s__ g_^hfh]Zgb_ \uau\Zxs__ ih\_^_gb_ \h \j_fy [_k_^u lZd`_ ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc ijbf_ju khijhlb\e_gby

<jZq ijh\h^ysbc [_k_^m

=eZ\guf ^_ckl\mxsbf ebphf \ ikbobZljbq_kdhc [_k_^_ y\ey_lky \jZq dhlhjuc __ ijh\h^bl Ebqghklgu_ b ijhn_kkbhgZevgu_ dZq_kl\Z \jZqZ ijb^Zxl dZ`^hc [_k_^_ hkh[uc ijbkmsbc ebrv _c h^ghc nhg OZjZdl_j `bag_ggu_ p_gghklb b kihkh[ghklv \jZqZ j_Z]bjh\Zlv gZ i_j_`b\Zgb_ ^jm]bo ex^_c \ebyxl gZ _]h hlghr_gb_ d hdjm`Zxsbf ex^yf dZd [hevguf lZd b a^hjh\uf JZaebqby \ khpbZevghf iheh`_gbb h[jZah\Zgbb b bgl_ee_dl_ fh]ml ij_iylkl\h\Zlv jZa\blbx \aZbfhihgbfZgby f_`^m \jZqhf b [hevguf Bamq_gb_ b ihgbfZgb_ hkh[_gghkl_c dmevlmjgh]h jZa\blby [hevgh]h kihkh[kl\m_l gZb[he__ mki_rghc ^_yl_evghklb \jZqZ

E_q_[guc khxa <jZq b [hevghc h[t_^bgyxl mkbeby ^ey h[e_]q_gby khklhygby [hevgh]h Bo \aZbfhhlghr_gb_ \dexqZ_l ZgZeba \jZqhf _]h a^hjh\vy gZ[ex^_gb_ b jZpbhgZevguc dhfihg_gl ©W]hª [hevgh]h E_q_[guc khxa dhlhjuc bgh]^Z gZau\Zxl jZ[hqbf khxahf hkgh\Zg gZ ^h\_jbb khqm\kl\bb b \aZbfghf m\Z`_gbb

Ijhlb\hi_j_ghk Ih^ ijhlb\hi_j_ghkhf ihgbfZxl y\e_gb_ dh]^Z j_Zdpby \jZqZ gZ [hevgh]h lZdh\Z dZd [m^lh hg hgZ y\ey_lky agZqbl_evguf h[jZahf ba ijhreh]h \jZqZ Q_f [hevr_ [hevghc ^_ckl\bl_evgh gZihfbgZ_l h[jZau ba ijhreh]h \jZqZ l_f [hevr_ \_jhylghklv lZdbo j_Zdpbc Ijbf_jZfb y\eyxlky kemqZb dh]^Z \jZq

h[gZjm`b\Z_l aZ\bkbfhklv hl iho\Zeu beb h^h[j_gby [hevgh]h g_ fh`_l i_j_g_klb b \iZ^Z_l \ njmkljZpbx dh]^Z [hevghc k_j^blky ijhy\ey_l q_jlu wdk]b[bpbhgbafZ qlh[u m]h^blv [hevghfm g_ \b^bl ijhlb\hj_qbc \ g_dhlhjuo \ukdZau\Zgbyo [hevgh]h gZklZb\Zy gZ lhf qlh ihke_^gbc g_ih]j_rbf djblbq_kdb hlghkblky d fg_gbx ikbobZljh\ jZg__ e_qb\rbo [hevgh]h bkiulu\Z_l aZf_sZxs__ m^h\hevkl\b_ hl k_dkmZevgh]h b Z]j_kkb\gh]h ih\_^_gby [hevgh]h kihjbl k [hevguf b `_eZ_l [ulv j_[_gdhf beb jh^bl_e_f [hevgh]h KdmdZ beb g_kihkh[ghklv khkj_^hlhqblvky gZ lhf qlh ]h\hjbl [hevghc qZklh hljZ`Z_l ih^khagZl_evguc ]g_\ beb kljZo \jZqZ

I?J<:Y ;?K?>:

<jZq ihemqZ_l fgh]h bgnhjfZpbb ijb i_j\hc \klj_q_ k [hevguf >h gZqZeZ [_k_^u \jZq fh`_l ihgZ[ex^Zlv aZ [hevguf b hp_gblv _]h ih\_^_gb_ \h \j_fy h`b^Zgby [_k_^u ?keb dlh eb[h khijh\h`^Z_l [hevgh]h lh \jZqm ij_^hklZ\ey_lky \hafh`ghklv hp_gblv b _]h ih\_^_gb_ <jZq fh`_l iha^hjh\Zlvky k [hevguf gZa\Z\ _]h__ ih bf_gb Z aZl_f kZf kZfZ ij_^klZ\blvky [hevghfm Ex[_aghkl_c lbiZ©Ijbylgh k \Zfb ihagZdhfblvkyª]h\hjblv g_ gZ^h ?keb [hevghc kebrdhf lj_\h`_g \jZq fh`_l gZqZlv k dhjhldhc k\_lkdhc [_k_^u gZijbf_j kijhkblv [hevgh]h dZd hg hgZ ^h_oZe ^h f_klZ ^he]h eb bkdZe ?kl_kl\_ggu_ b ijbylgu_ fZg_ju \jZqZ ihfh]Zxl [hevghfm ihqm\kl\h\Zlv k_[y g_ijbgm`^_ggh

MklZgh\e_gb_ dhglZdlZ

GZqZeh \klj_qb ;hevghfm ke_^m_l ij_^eh`blv k_klv Z aZl_f kijhkblv ©Qlh ijb\_eh \Zk kx^Z"ª beb ©Fh`_l_ eb \u kdZaZlv fg_ qlh k \Zfb kemqbehkv"ª Fh`gh bkihevah\Zlv ih^oh^ kijhkb\ [hevgh]h ©K q_]h fu gZqg_f"ª beb ©K q_]h [u \Zf ohl_ehkv gZqZlv"ª

>ey g_ hq_gv jZa]h\hjqb\uo [hevguo e_]q_ _keb hgb ihqm\kl\mxl qlh \jZqm m`_ qlh lh ba\_klgh h gbo GZijbf_j \jZq fh`_l kdZaZlv©>hdlhj >`hgk kdZaZe fg_ qlh m \Zk b m \Zr_c `_gu [ueb g_ijbylghklbªbeb©Y ihgye qlh \u [ueb hq_gv ih^Z\e_guª H[uqgh ihke_ wlh]h [hevghc ijh^he`Z_l jZkkdZau\Zlv gh bgh]^Z hg fh`_l kijhkblv ©Hg jZkkdZaZe \Zf \k_ ih^jh[ghklb"ª <jZq fh`_l hl\_lblv ©Hg ijb\_e g_dhlhju_ ih^jh[ghklb gh y ohqm mkeurZlv h gbo hl <Zkª

IhgbfZgb_ [hevgh]h >ey lh]h qlh[u mklZgh\blv dhglZdl \jZq ^he`_g m\_jblv [hevgh]h \ lhf qlh hg _]h ihgbfZ_l G_ ke_^m_l kha^Z\Zlv m [hevgh]h \i_qZle_gb_ qlh \jZq qblZ_l _]h fukeb gh gZ^h qlh[u [hevghc ihgye qlh ij_`^_ hg e_qbe ^jm]bo ex^_c k ih^h[guf aZ[he_\Zgb_f b jZa[bjZ_lky \ gbo ijbq_f g_ lhevdh \ g_\jhlbq_kdbo b ikbohlbq_kdbo ijhy\e_gbyo gh b \ h[uqguo `bl_ckdbo \hijhkZo

JZkdjulb_ qm\kl\ >ey emqr_]h bamq_gby wfhpbc fh`gh ihijhkblv [hevgh]h ijb\_klb ijbf_ju beexkljbjmxsb_ lh qlh hg ]h\hjbl h k\h_c `bagb gZijbf_j ©Fhc fm` g_ ihgbfZ_l f_gyªbeb©Fhy fZfZ kebrdhf f_gy hi_dZ_lªDh]^Z ikbobZlj kijZrb\Z_l ©Fh`_l_ eb \u ijb\_klb ijbf_j"ª beb ©Qlh \u ihfgbl_ h[ wlhf"ª [hevghfm ijboh^blky khkj_^hlhqblvky gZ wlbo kh[ulbyo qZklbqgh i_j_`blv bo kgh\Z

QZklh [hevgu_ klZjZxlky k^_j`b\Zlv k\hb wfhpbb lZd dZd h`b\e_gb_ \ iZfylb g_ijbylguo hsms_gbc ijh[m`^Z_l b khhl\_lkl\mxsbc Znn_dl dh]^Z [hevghc[hevgZy i_j_klZ_l ]h\hjblv m g_]h m g__ ihy\eyxlky ke_au \jZq fh`_l kdZaZlv©<Zf [hevgh ]h\hjblv h[ wlhfª beb ©<u k^_j`b\Z_l_ ke_auª beb ©G_ [hcl_kv aZieZdZlvª

>jm]bf \b^hf wfhpbhgZevguo j_Zdpbc dhlhju_ ljm^gh jZkihagZlv y\ey_lky ]g_\ Dh]^Z wlZ j_Zdpby m [hevgh]h g_ ijhy\ey_lky \jZq fh`_l gZf_dgmlv qlh g_dhlhju_ i_j_`b\Zgby \uau\Zxl m [hevrbgkl\Z ex^_c ]g_\

<g_aZigh_ baf_g_gb_ l_fu Bgh]^Z ihke_ lh]h dZd [hevghc jZkkdZ`_l h k\h_f aZ[he_\Zgbb [u\Z_l ihe_agh j_adh kf_gblv l_fm >ey wlh]h fh`gh kdZaZlv ©GZf _s_ ij_^klhbl ih]h\hjblv h fgh]hf Z _keb lZd [m^_l ijh^he`Zlvky fu gbdh]^Z g_ mki__f wlh k^_eZlvªbeb©M gZk k_]h^gy \j_fy h]jZgbq_gh Z fu _s_ g_ mki_eb ih]h\hjblv h \Zr_f [jZd_ª

Bamq_gb_ ijhreh]h =em[bgZ ZgZebaZ ijhreh]h aZ\bkbl hl lh]h kdhevdh \j_f_gb bf__lky \ jZkihjy`_gbb kdhevdh [_k_^ [m^_l ijh\_^_gh k [hevguf <hijhk h lhf dZdb_ kh[ulby ba ijhrehc `bagb [hevgh]h gZb[he__ \Z`gu l_kgh k\yaZg k gZ[ex^Zxsbfbky m g_]h gZjmr_gbyfb b p_evx dhgkmevlZpbc

Bkihevah\Zgb_ keh\ kdZaZgguo kZfbf [hevguf Bkihevah\Zgb_ keh\ kdZaZgguo kZfbf [hevguf g_ lhevdh h[e_]qZ_l jZa\blb_ dhglZdlZ gh b ihfh]Z_l ba[_`Zlv khijhlb\e_gby [hevgh]h dhlhjuc kihjbl ih ih\h^m l_jfbgh\ b jZaebqguo hll_gdh\ bo agZq_gby WlZ f_lh^bdZ hkh[_ggh \Z`gZ dh]^Z \jZq ohq_l \_jgmlvky d keh\Zf kdZaZgguf [hevguf jZgvr_ < lZdbo kemqZyo \_^msbc [_k_^m ^Z_l \hafh`ghklv [hevghfm ]h\hjblv h lhf h q_f lhl ohq_l b g_ ij_ju\Z_l _]h gZ\yau\Zy ^jm]mx l_fm ij_^klZ\eyxsmx bgl_j_k ^ey g_]h Z g_ ^ey [hevgh]h Bgh]^Z m^Z_lky ijh\_klb \kx [_k_^m [_a \f_rZl_evkl\Z \jZqZ [_a ij_^eh`_gby gh\hc l_fu \jZq ijhklh kemrZ_l lh qlh ]h\hjbl [hevghc

<hijhku lj_[mxsb_ b g_ lj_[mxsb_ dZl_]hjbq_kdh]h hl\_lZ < [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ \hijhku lj_[mxsb_ hdhgqZl_evgh]h hl\_lZ l _ hl\_lZ ©^Zª beb ©g_lª y\eyxlky h[j_f_gbl_evgufb ^ey \jZqZ b iha\heyxl [hevghfm ihqlb g_ [jZlv gZ k_[y ljm^Z \ ih^^_j`Zgbb [_k_^u H^gZdh bgh]^Z _keb [hevghc mdehgy_lky hl hl\_lZ _fm ke_^m_l aZ^Zlv g_kdhevdh \hijhkh\ dhlhju_ lj_[mxl hl\_lZ lbiZ©^Zªbeb©g_lª?keb ijh\h^ysbc [_k_^m ohq_l dhkgmlvky dZdhc eb[h hij_^_e_gghc l_fu hg fh`_l aZ^Z\Zlv \hijhku g_ lj_[mxsb_ dZl_]hjbq_kdh]h hl\_lZ lZd qlh[u ^Zlv \hafh`ghklv [hevghfm hl\_lblv gZ gbo dZd fh`gh [he__ h[klhyl_evgh GZijbf_j [helZy fh`_l kdZaZlv qlh __ fm` hl g__ hl^Zebeky b \k_p_eh ih]ehs_g k\h_c jZ[hlhc <jZq fh`_l kijhkblv©Qlh \u ij_^ijbgbfZ_l_ qlh[u dZd lh jZa\e_qvky \f_kl_ k gbf"ª beb ©<k_]^Z eb hg [ue lZdbf"ªWlb \hijhku ihfh]Zxl ihemqblv \Z`gmx bgnhjfZpbx gh bgh]^Z \jZq fh`_l mkeurZlv ^Z`_ [hevr_ ijhklh kdZaZ\ [hevghfm ©Ijh^he`Zcl_ ih`ZemcklZª beb ©JZkkdZ`bl_ h k\h_f [jZd_ª

<ha^_ckl\b_ gZ [hevgh]h k ihfhsvx klj_kkZ Bgh]^Z \h \j_fy [_k_^u ihe_agh \ha^_ckl\h\Zlv gZ [hevgh]h k ihfhsvx klj_kkZ wlh ihfh]Z_l \jZqm ihklZ\blv ijZ\bevguc ^bZ]gha GZijbf_j lZdbf kihkh[hf fh`gh \uy\blv kdjulu_ ^_n_dlu iZfylb < jy^_ kemqZ_\ \jZq fh`_l lZd`_ \ua\Zlv m [hevgh]h b^bhkbgdjZabx qlh[u \uy\blv [j_^h\u_ b^_b beb hij_^_eblv kl_i_gv ijhly`_gghklb gZjmr_gbc fure_gby

<hijhku [hevgh]h < dhgp_ i_j\hc [_k_^u ke_^m_l m^_eblv beb fbg hij_^_e_gguf fhf_glZf ?keb [hevghc ieZdZe _fm gm`gh ijb\_klb k_[y \ ihjy^hd i_j_^ l_f dZd mclb ?keb [hevghc ijboh^y gZ [_k_^m k \jZqhf kh[bjZeky aZ^Zlv _fm g_kdhevdh \hijhkh\ dhlhju_ hg ijbg_k k kh[hc \ ibkvf_gghf \b^_ beb ^_j`bl \ mf_ ikbobZlj ^he`_g gZclb \j_fy ^ey lh]h qlh[u \ukemrZlv bo

Ih f_j_ ijb[eb`_gby dhgpZ [_k_^u \jZq fh`_l kdZaZlv ©M gZk hklZehkv hdheh ^_kylb fbgml Fh`_l [ulv \u ohlbl_ aZ^Zlv fg_ g_kdhevdh \hijhkh\ª;hevghc fh`_l ijb wlhf ^Zlv jy^ k\_^_gbc kms_kl\_ggh \Z`guo ^ey [_k_^u hlf_q_gh qlh lZdh_