Катастрофы и живучесть

B HHlPopMaUHoHHoH pa60Te [1.17) npHBo):(HTC5I amlJIH3 npH'IHH 3apemcTpHpoBaHHbix B 2000 ro):(y aBapHH Ha CTP05lIUHXC5I H 3KCnJIya­ THpyeMblx 3):(aHHH Ha TeppHTopHH POCCHH. npHBO):(HTC5I HX KJIaCCH­ IPHKaUH5I no BOCbMH xapaKTepHblM npH3HaKaM, CB5I3aHHbIM C HH3KHM Ka'leCTBOM npOeKTHpOBaHH.H H CTpOHTeJIbCTBa. C yqeToM pa60Tbi [1.13) MO)l(HO rpynnHpoBaTb npH'IHHbl aBapHH B CJIe):(YJOIUHe 3Tanbl CTpOH­ TeJIbCTBa H 3KCnJIyaTaUHH:

1.060cHoBaHHe HopMaTHBHblX npO'lHOCTHblX xapaKTepHCTHK;

2.060cHoBaHHe paC'IeTHbiX cxeM H npoeKTHblX peweHHH;

3.H3rOTOBJIeHHe CTpOHTeJIbHbIX MaTepHaJIOB, H3):(eJIHH H 3JIeMeHTOB

KOHCTpYKUHH;

4.TeXHOJIOm51 B03Be):(eHH5I 3):(aHHH H coop~eHHH;

5.TeXHH'IeCKa5l3KCTIJIyaTaUH5I3):(aHHH, B nepBYJO O'lepe):(b CB5I3aH­ HblX C nepeYBJIa)I(HeHHeM rpYHTOBoro OCHOBaHH5I H KaMeHHblX KOHCT­ PYKUHH TeXHoreHHblMH Bo):(aMH.

H3 npe):(cTaBJIeHHOH rpa):(aUHH eCTeCTBeHHO BblTeKaeT, 'ITO OCHOB­

Ha5I npH'IHHa 60JIbWHHCTBa aBapHH - '1eJIOBe'leCKHH lPaKTOp. K 3TOMY

CJIe):(yeT ):(06aBHTb H opraHH3aUHOHHbie npH'IHHbI [1.18), OTCYTCTBHe aOJI)l(HOH CHCTeMbl KOHTpOJI5I H ynpaBJIeHH.H Ka'leCTBOM H MeTO):(OJIOmH

He3aBHCHMOH HayqHo-TexHH'IecKoH 3KcnepTH3bl, oc06eHHo 3a YHH­ KaJIbHblMH COOp~eHH.HMH.OIPHUHaJIbHO 3apemCTpHpOBaHo (nHcbMo nE-19-20/16 OT 28.04.95 «06 aBapH5IX 3aaHHH H coop~eHHH Ha TeppHTopHH P<I»» [1.19), 'ITO npaKTH'IeCKH 80 %

CJIyqaeB aBapHH aonYIUeHbl yqacTHHKaMH cTpOHTeJIbCTBa (T. e. HaeT CCblJIKa Ha '1eJIOBe'leCKHH lPaKTOp B 0606IUeHHoM BMe). npH aHaJIH3e npH'IHH aBapHH H KaTaCTpOIP npowe Bcero CCblJIaTbC5I Ha '1eJIOBe'leCKHH lPaKTOp. OaHaKO '1eJIOBe'leCKHH lPaKTOp TaIOKe MO)l(HO nOaBeprHYTb aHaJIH3Y H KJIaCCHIPHKaUHH (CM. fJI. 2, Ta6JI. 2.1). npH pa3pa60TKe KJIaCCHIPHKaUHH KaTaCTpOIP aBTOp HaCT05lIUeH MOHOrpalPHH CTOJIKHyJI­ C5I C TpyaHoCT5IMH KaK MeTOaH'IeCKOrO, TaK H COUHaJIbHOro xapaKTepa. nepBa51 3a):(a'la, KOTOpyIO nOCTaBHJI nepea C060H aBTOp, - OTpa3HTb oc06eHHOCTH np05lBJIeHH5I KaTaCTpOIP H yTO'lHHTb CYIUecTByIOIUHe TepMHHbl H onpeaeJIeHH5I, OTHOC5IWHeC5I K 3TOH np06JIeMe.

Hcxo!J.51 H3 onHcaHHH H HCCJIe):(oBaHHH npHpOaHblX KaTaCTpolP Tex­ HoreHHble CTpOHTeJIbHble KaTacTpolPbl no npH3HaKY npeaCKa3yeMocTH B caMOM 06IUeM BMe MO)I(HO pa3aeJIHTb Ha 6blcTpble H MeMeHHbie [1.5).

K 6blCTpblM OTHOC5IT KaTaCTpOlPbl cpblBa (HaBoaHeHH5I, WTOpMbl, 3eMJIeTp5lCeHH5I, OnOJI3HH, nO)l{apbl, B3pbIBbi H T.a.), xapaKTepH3yIO­

IUHeC5I CJIa60H npeacKa3yeMocTbIO MJIH ee OTCYTCTBHeM. B 3TOH reo­ JIOm'leCKOH KJIaCCHIPHKaUHH, K npH5ITHoMy yaHBJIeHHIO, HMeIOTC5I HaMeKH H aa)l{e YTBep)l{):(eHH5I Ha ee npHMeHHMOCTb K TeXHoreHHblM KaTaCTpOlPaM C mnOTeTH'IeCKHM HenpeacKa3yeMbiM xapaKTepoM HX np05lBJIeHH.H. KpoMe TOro, cTpeMJIeHHe aBTopOB YHHBepCaJIbHblX reOJIO­ m'leCKHX KJIaCCHIPHKaUHH CfJIaaHTb pa3JIH'IHe B npHpo):(e, xapaKTepe, npH'IHHaX H aeTaJI5IX KaTaCTpOlPbl He npHMeHHMO K aHaJIH3Y TeXHoreH­ HblX KaTaCTpOIP (CM. rJI. 2).

K MeMeHHblM OTHOC5ITC5I KaTaCTpOlPbl THna «TpeH):(» (H3MeHeHH5I KJIHMaTa, YPOBH5I MOp5l, a6pa3H.H 6eperoB) H KaTaCTpOlPbl THna «3KCTpe­ MYM» (3acyxH, 3aMop03KH, HaBOaHeHH5I). 11 «TpeH):(», H «3KCTpeMYM» xapaKTepH3YJOTC5I 60JIbWOH HJIH CJIa60H npeacKa3yeMoCTbIO. nblTOBOe BOCnpH.HTHe KaTaCTpOlPbl (npHpo):(HOH, TeXHoreHHoH) CB5I3aHO C JIIO):(­ CKHMH nOTep5lMH - HMeeTC5I B BMY O'leHb 6blCTPblH npouecc (3eMJIe­ Tp5lCeHH.H, yparaH), a He MeMeHHoe, T. e. He6JIaronpH.HTHOe npHpOaHoe 51BJIeHHe (3acyxa, a6pa3H.H 6eperOB H T. n.).

feOJIOm'leCKOe nOH5ITHe «KaTaCTpOlPa» HCXO):(HT H3 KJIaCCHIPHKa­ UHH, B KOTOPOH He aeJIaeTC5I TepMHHOJIOm'leCKoro pa3JIH'IH5I Me)l{):(y 6blCTpOH H MeMeHHOI1 KaTaCTpOlPaMH [1.5). Ho 3TH Pa3JIH'IH5I 06yCJIOB­ JIeHbl IPH3H'IeCKHMH npoueccaMH H 51BJIeHH.HMH KaK BO BHewHeH cpeae, TaK H BO BHYTPeHHeH npHpOae cOnpOTHBJIeHH.H MaTepHaJIa COOp~eHH.H.

PeaJIbHa51 MaCCHBHa51 YHHKaJIbHa51 KOHCTpyKUH5I (HJIH coop~eHHe)

H ropHblH TIJIaCT pa3pywaIOTc5I OT HHor):(a HeH3BecTHOH MJIH MaJIOH3y­ '1eHHOH npH'IHHbl, He HMeIOIUeH npeaBeCTHHKa pa3pyweHH5I.

OCHOBHa51 oc06eHHOCTb lPeHOMeHa KaTaCTpOlPbl )I{eJIe306eTOHHbiX H 6eTOHHbiX KOHCTpyKUHI1 - OTCYTCTBHe Ha):(e)l{HOrO npeaBeCTHHKa M5I 06Hap~eHH5InpHTaHBWerOC5I O'lara, MeMeHHO HapacTaIOIUero BHe3anHoro 51BJIeHH5I. BeJIH'IHHbl «BpeM5I» H «aeIPOpMauH.H», HCnOJIb­ 3yeMbie B H3BeCTHbiX TeOpH5IX Haae)l{HOCTH M5I yCTaHOBJIeHH5I cpOKa

CJI~6bl,aaIOT 60JIbWee pacceHBaHHe, '1eM BeJIH'IHHa npO'lHOCTH HJIH CTeneHb nOBpe)l{):(eHH5I [1.23). nOcTeneHHoe HaKOnJIeHHe nOBpe)l{­ aeHHH H HepapXH'IeCKa51 CTpyKTypa B TpeIUHHo06pa30BaHHH CJI~aT nepBoOCHOBOI1 aJI5I nOHCKa 60JIee Haae)l(HOrO npeaweCTBeHHHKa KaTacTpolPbI.

TaKHM 06pa30M, pe'lb MeT He 06 YTO'lHeHHH, a 0 caMOCT05lTeJIbHOM aOnOJIHeHHH K cywecTByIOIUHM TeOpH5IM Ha):(e)l{HOCTH, T. e. 0 pa3­ pa60TKe HOBOI1 napaaHrMbI B HayKe: pe3epB )I{HBy'lecTH Ha OCHOBe 3HTponHHHoro npouecca.

32 I CM. CKopo6oraTOB IKaTaCTpoq,bllo1 >Klo1BY4eCTb ...

BTopa51 oc06eHHOCTb 06b5lCH5IeTC5I B03MO)l(HOCTblO 6H<pypKaUHH rrpouecca HaKOIIJIeHH5I rrOBpe)K)],eHHH: rrpouecc MO)l(eT rrOHTH B CTa,rJ,HH rrpe,lJ,pa3pyIIIeHH5I rro pa3HbIM rrYT5IM H 06yCJIOBHTb CpbIB, CrrOJI3aHHe C IIJIaBHOH KpHBOH HaKOIIJIeHH5I rrOBpe)K)],eHHH, qTO CTporo orrHCbIBaeTCH O,lJ,HHM H3 BH):(OB 3JIeMeHTapHbIX MaTeMamqeCKJiX KaTaCTpO<p [1.24-1.26].

AKa,rJ,eMHK B. A. ApHOJIb,lJ, rrHCaJI: «KaTacTpo<paMH Ha3bIBalOTCH CKaqK006pa3HbIe H3MeHeHHH, B03HHKalOIUHe B BH,lJ,e BHe3arrHoro OT­ BeTa CHCTeMbI Ha IIJIaBHOe H3MeHeHHe BHeIIIHHX yCJIOBHH» [1.24]. 3TO orrpe,lJ,eJIeHHe He rrpOTHBOpeqHT 06IUerrpHHHToMy 6bITOBOMy, O,lJ,Ha­ KO 3,lJ,eCb He yqTeHbI COUHaJIbHOe 6e,lJ,CTBHe H MaTepHaJIbHbIH ymep6. MaTeMaTWleCKoe orrpe,lJ,eJIeHHe TepMHHa «KaTaCTpO<pa» xapaKTepH3y­ eT, CKopee Bcero, Me)J,JIeHHOe rrpe,lJ,CKa3yeMoe C06bITHe.

KpaHHe Ba)l(HO OTMeTHTb, qTO aBapHH H KaTaCTpO<pbI B rrepBylO Oqepe,lJ,b CBH3aHbI C MaCCHBHbIMH KOHCTPYKUH5IMH H 06beKTaMH, T. e. C 60JIbIIIHMH OTKJIOHeHH5IMH rrpOqHOCTHbIX xapaKTepHCTHK MaTepHa­ JIOB H rpYHTOB B He6JIarOrrpH5ITHYJO CTOpOHy BCJIe,lJ,CTBHe BbICOKOH He­ O,lJ,HOpO,lJ,HOCTH CBOHCTB MaTepHaJIa. ABTOp ,lJ,aHHOH pa60TbI rrOJIara­ eT, qTO HarrpaBJIeHHe pa3pa60TKH rro 3HTpOrrHHHOH TeopHH Ha OCHOBe rrpHHUHrra HaKOIIJIeHH5I rrOBpe)K)],eHHH - pe3epBa )l(HByqecTH HaH60­ JIee IIJIO,lJ,OTBOpHO. IIpHHUHrr HaKOIIJIeHHH rrOBpe)K)],eHHH MaKCHMaJIb­ HO COOTBeTcTByeT rrOCTerreHHoMy HepapXHqeCKoMy rrpoueccy pa3BHTH5I KapTHHbI TpeIUHHo06pa30BaHH5I B COOTBeTCTBHH C rJIaBHbIM CBOHCT­ BOM )I(eJIe306eTOHHbIX H 6eTOHHbIX KOHCTpyKUHH - HeO,lJ,HOpO,lJ,HOCTH CBOHCTB Ha <poHe HX MaCIIITa6HOCTH. ComaCHO BTOpOMy HaqaJIY Tep­ MO,lJ,HHaMHKH [1.27], 3TOT rrpouecc COOTBeTcTByeT 3HTporrHHHoH rro­ CTaHOBKe Borrpoca H MO)l(eT 6bITb orrHcaH MeTO,lJ,aMH HH<popMaUHoHHoH 3HTporrHH [1.28-1.31]. ):LrrHTeJIbHbIH rrpouecc HaKOIIJIeHH5I rrOBpe)K)],e­ HHH, rrpe,lJ,IIIecTBYJOIUHH pa3pyrneHHIO, 3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHO rrO,lJ,TBep­ )K)],eH 0.51. EeprOM [1.32].

CMeHa HayqHoH rrapa,rJ,HrMbI B cTpOHTeJIbHOH HayKe rrpe,lJ,ycMoT­ peHa fOCT 27751-88 [1.2]. HHOf,lJ,a paCqeTHbIe MO,lJ,eJIH (KKOTOpbIM OTHOC5ITC5I paCqeTHbIe cxeMbI, OCHOBHbIe rrpe,lJ,rrOCbillKH paCqeTa) KOH­ CTpYKUHH He OTpIDKalOT HX ,lJ,eHCTBHTeJIbHOH pa60TbI. 3TO rrpe,lJ,rrOJIO­ )I(eHHe, B rrepBYJO Oqepe,lJ,b, OTHOCHTCH K MaCCHBHbIM KOHCTPYKUHHM. IIpH 3TOM peKOMeH,lJ,yeTc5I rrpOH3BO,lJ,HTb CrreUHaJIbHbIe TeOpeTHqeCKHe HJIH 3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHbIe HCCJIe,lJ,OBaHHH, B TOM qHCJIe Ha HaTypHbIX KOHCTPYKUH5IX. ECJIH BeJIHqHHbI, xapaKTepH3YJOIUHe CBOHcTBa MaTe­ pHaJIOB H rpyHToB, 51BJIHIOTCH <PYHKUH5IMH ,lJ,pyrHx BeJIHqHH HJIH Ha­

XO,lJ,HTC5I B KOppeJIHUHOHHOH 3aBHCHMOCTH OT HHX, TO HopMaTHBHbIe 3HaqeHHH xapaKTepHbIX MaTepHaJIOB H rpYHTOB MOfYT 6bITb rrOJIyqeHbI paCqeTHbIM HJIH rHrrOTeTHqeCKHM rrYTeM, qTO OqeHb Ba)I(HO )J,JIH Mac­ CHBHbIX coop~eHHHH ropHbIX IIJIaCTOB.

B 3TOH rrp06JIeMe YTOqHeHHH paCqeTHOH cxeMbI aBTop HacToHIUeH pa60TbI rrOrrbITaJIC5I COqeTaTb BepoHTHOCTHbIH rro,lJ,xo,lJ, Ha OCHOBe HH­ <popMaUHOHHOH 3HTporrHH H HepapxwH TpeIIIHHo06paJoBaHH5I C ,lJ,eTep­ MHHHpOBaHHoH MeTO,lJ,HKOH pacqeTa Harrp5l)l(eHHO-,lJ,e<popMHpoBaHHoro COCTOHHHH H pe3epBa )l(HByqecTH (rrpo,lJ,OJIbHa51 TpeIUHHoCTOHKOCTb) MaCCHBHbIX KOHCTpYKUHH C yqeToM MacIIITa6HocTH.

PaCqeT Ha )I(HByqeCTb, rrpO,lJ,OJIbHylO TpeIUHHocTOHKOCTb B,lJ,OJIb O)l(H):(aeMbIX Harrp5l)l(eHHH B C)I(aTOH 30He H3m6aeMoro 3JIeMeHTa rrpe,lJ,­ JIaraeTC5I BrrepBbIe. OH oc06eHHo He06xo,lJ,HM )J,JI5I )I(eJIe306eToHHbIX MaCCHBHbIX KOHCTpYKUHH CO Cpe,lJ,HHM H MaKCHMaJIbHbIM rrpoueHToM apMHpOBaHH5I H B rropMKe 06Cy)K)],eHH5I MO)l(eT 6bITb HCrrOJIb30BaH rrpH orrpe,lJ,eJIeHHH rrpe,lJ,eJIbHOrO COCTOHHH5I ropHOro IIJIaCTa B6JIH3H pa3JI0Ma )J,JIH rrpe,lJ,CKa3aHHH ceHcMoorracHoro pemoHa.

1.3.0 HeTpaAH4HOHHOM nOAxOAe K H3y~eHHIO HaAe>KHOCTH

(>KHBy~ecTH)>KeJle306eTOHHbIX KOHCTpyK4 HM

BeCb ,lJ,Ba,rJ,uaTbIH BeK OTMeqeH BCIIJIeCKOM HOBbIX 6JIeCTHIIIHX Hayq­ HbIX H):(eH H TeXHmeCKJiX ,lJ,OCTH)I(eHHH H O,lJ,HOBpeMeHHO - CTpaIIIHbIMH TeXHOJIOmqeCKHMH KaTaCTpo<paMH H rrpHpO,lJ,HbIMH KaTaKJIH3MaMH. OH ,lJ,aJI B,lJ,OXHOBJIHIOIUHe rrpHMepbI B3JIeTa HaYKH, B TOM qHCJIe H CTpOH­ TeJIbHOH, oc06eHHO Ha OCHOBe KOMrrbIOTepH3aUHH. MO)I(HO OTMeTHTb rrpopbIBHble HCCJIe,lJ,OBaHH5I B 06JIaCTH CTpOHTeJIbHOH MexaHHKH (Teo­ pHH Ha,rJ,e)I(HOCTH), aBTOMaTH3aUHH CTpOHTeJIbHOfO rrpOeKTHpOBaHHH (MeTO,lJ, KOHeqHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB), TeopHH )I(eJIe306eTOHHbIX KOHCTpYKUHH (MexaHHKa pa3pyrneHH5I).

HeCMOTpH Ha Tpa,rJ,HUHOHHYJO rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTb B HaYKe, pe3YJIbTa­ TbI H ,lJ,OCTH)I(eHH5I HayqHbIx HCCJIe,lJ,OBaHHH 6e3yCJIOBHO 6y,lJ,YT rrO,lJ,TBep­ )K)],aTbCH HOBbIMH OCMbICJIeHHeM, oueHKaMH H KpHTepH51MH KaqeCTBa CTpOHTeJIbCTBa, oco6eHHO B YCJIOBH5IX HCqeprraHH5I rrpHpO,lJ,HbIX 3Hep­ reTHqeCKHX pecypcoB H 3KOJIOmqeCKOrO YXY,lJ,IIIeHH5I rrpO)l(HBaHHH.

EOJIbIIIoe KOJIHqeCTBO 3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHbIX pa60T (oco6eHHO B 60-e H 70-e rO,lJ,bI rrpOIIIJIoro BeKa) B )I(eJIe306eTOHe BblIIOJIH5IJIOCb C 3apaHee

YKa3aHHbIM pe3YJIbTaTOM H He rrOLJ,BepraJIOCb LJ,OCTaTOqHOMY HayqHoMy OCMbICJIeHHIO C rr03HUHH <pYHLJ,aMeHTaJIbHbIX HaYK. llccJIeLJ,oBaTeJIH H36eraJIH 06CYiK,UeHHH «OTBJIeqeHHbIX», HO LJ,eHcTBHTeJIbHO HayqHbIx <paKToB H HayqHbIx TeM, He LJ,alOmHX CHIOMHHYTHOrO rrpaKTHqeCKOrO pe3YJIbTaTa. XOTH pe3YJIbTaTOB HayqHbIx H3bICKaHHH BrrOJIHe XBaTaJIO H LJ,JIH BHeLJ,peHHH, H LJ,JIH 3amHT LJ,HCCepTaUHH. TaKHM 06pa30M, Ha ceroLJ,HH cymecTByeT KaK 33L\eJI orpOMHoe 3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHOe rrOJIe LJ,JIH OCMbICJIeHHH rrOJIyqeHHbIx pe3YJIbTaTOB C HeTpaLJ,HUHOHHbIX, HO <pYHLJ,aMeHTaJIbHbIX rr03HUHH.

IloJIo)l(eHHe co CJJO)l(HbIMH H HeyLJ,06HbIMH HayqHbIMH <paKTaMH MJI­ JIIOCTpHpyeT OTHomeHHe HCCJIeLJ,OBaTeJIeH K TaKHM rrapaMeTpaM TpemH­ Ho06pa30BaHHH, KaK mHpHHa paCKpbITHH H rny6HHa pacrrpOCTpaHeHHH TpemHHbI rro BbICOTe rrOrrepeqHoro CeqeHHH H3rH6aeMoro 3JIeMeHTa.

Ha mHpHJIY paCKPbITHH TpemHHbI, rrpeLJ,CKa3bIBalOmeH KOHKpeTHbIH pe3YJIbTaT rro CTerreHH KOPP03HH apMaTYpbI, BcerLJ,a 06pamaJIH rrpH­ CTaJIbHOe BHHMaHHe. fJIy6HHa TpemHHbI OCTaBaJIaCb BHe HHTepeCOB HCCJIeLJ,OBaTeJIeH, T. K. H3-3a 60JIbIIIOrO pa36poca He LJ,aBaJIa LJ,OCTaTOq­ HO yLJ,OBJIeTBOpHTeJIbHbIX H KpaCHBbIX CTaTHCTHK (MaTeMaTHqeCKOe O)l(HLJ,aHHe, LJ,HCrrepCHH, BHLJ, pacrrpeLJ,eJIeHHH) LJ,JIH HCrrOJIb30BaHHH B pa3pa6aTbIBaeMbIX TeopHHX HaLJ,e)l(HOCTH. «HeLJ,HCCepTa6eJIbHOCTb» <paKTopa rJIy6HHbI TpemHHbI 06'bHCHHJIaCb 6ecrrepcrreKTHBHOCTbIO rrOJIyqeHHH CKoporo rrpaKTHqeCKoro pe3YJIbTaTa. OLJ,HaKO rJIy6HHa TpemHHbI BMeCTe C IIIHpHHOH ee paCKpbITHH H C yqeToM KOHKpeTHbIX CBOHCTB 6eTOHa H apMarypbI - y6eLJ,HTeJIbHbIe xapaKTepHCTHKH, qT06bI CyLJ,HTb 0 HarrpH)l(eHHOM COCTOHHHH H 06 OCTaTOqHOM pe3epBe HeCYIIIeH crroc06HoCTH KOHCTpyKUHH. HayqHoe )I(e 3HaqeHHe HCCJIeLJ,OBaHHH rny6HHbI TpemHHbI TpyLJ,HO rrepeoueHHTb HeCMOTpH Ha TeOpeTHqecKYJO CJIO)I(HOCTb aHaJIH3a H OTLJ,aJIeHHbIH rrpaKTHqeCKHH pe3YJIbTaT.

ECJIH CTaBHTb rrp06JIeMy HaLJ,e)l(HOCTH ()I(HByqecTH) OTLJ,eJIbHbIX (HJIH eLJ,HHCTBeHHbIx) )I(eJIe306eToHHbIX KOHCTpyKUHH (MOCTbI, 6aIII­ HH, rrJIOTHHbI, rrJIaT<p0pMbI Ha IIIeJIb<pe H T. rr.), TO CJIeLJ,yeT rrpHHHTb, qTO LlJIH HHX TpyLJ,HO HJIH HeB03MO)l(HO Ha6paTb CTaTHCTHKH KaK LJ,JIH MaCCOBbIX H3LJ,eJIHH. To eCTb TP3L\HUHOHHoe (ycToHBIIIeecH) HayqHoe HCCJIeLJ,OBaHHe 3LJ,eCb He OqeHb rrOLJ,XOLJ,HT. Il03TOMY MeTOLJ,HKa HaLJ,e)l(­ HOCTH LlJIH TaKHX COOpy)l(eHHH LJ,OJI)l(Ha OCHOBbIBaTbCH Ha <pH3HqeCKHX rrpoueccax HaKOrrJIeHHH rrOBpe)l()J,eHHH BHYTpH CJIO)I(HOH H 06'beMHOH KOHCTPYKUHH, LJ,pyrHMH CJIOBaMH pa3pa6aTbIBaTbcH HeTp3L\HUHOHHbIM crroc060M.

IlepexoLJ, OT JIHHeHHOH MOLJ,eJIH LJ,e<popMHpoBaHHH K HeJIHHeHHOH CqHTaJICH B rrOCJIeLJ,Hee BpeMH KpyrrHbIM C06bITHeM B TeopHH pacqeTa cOOpy)l(eHHH H B CAIlPe. OLJ,HaKO HeJIHHeHHaH MOLJ,eJIb LJ,e<pOPMHPO­ BaHHH rrpHrOLJ,Ha LlJIH 6eToHa H )I(eJIe306eToHa C He60JIbIIIHM rrorrepeq­ HbIM CeqeHHeM, KOrLJ,a rrpHMeHHMa TeopHH rrOLJ,06HH KOHCTpyKUHH. D,JIH )I(eJIe306eTOHHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB C pa3MepoM B rrOrrepeqHOM CeqeHHH OT TpHLJ,uaTH caHTHMeTpoB H LJ,O LJ,eCHTKa MeTpOB xapaKTepHo MHoro­ KpaTHoe qepeLJ,OBaHHe rrCeBLJ,OIIJIaCTHqeCKOrO H xpyrrKoro COCTOHHHH C rrOCTerreHHbIM B03paCTaHHeM pa3Mepa TpemHH. B rrpouecce pa60­ TbI KOHCTpyKUHH rrpOHBJIHeTCH HepapXHH B TpemHHo06pa30BaHHH (MHKpoTpemHHbI, Me30TpemHHbI, MaKpoTpemHHbI H MamcTpaJIbHbIe «CKB03HbIe» TpemHHbI). 3Ta HepapXHH LJ,OJI)I(Ha rrOBJIHHTb Ha <pOPMbI H pa3MepbI KOHeqHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B CAIlPe. IlpH 3TOM ceTKa KOHeqHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB H HX )I(eCTKOCTHbIe xapaKTepHcTHKH B rrpouecce paCqeTa LJ,OJI)l(HbI MeHHTbCH HeCKOJIbKO pa3. ECJIH He yqHTbIBaTb 3TY HepapXHIO B TpemHHo06pa30BaHHH B cyrrep3JIeMeHTapHbIX MOLJ,eJIHX paMHbIX KOH­ CTpYKUHH, TO 3TO 6yLJ,eT 03HaqaTb, qTO HeTOqHOCTb MJIH He3L\eKBaTHOCTb paCqeTHbIX rrpeLJ,rrOCbillOK «3arHaHa» BHYTpb KaK MeTOLJ,lfqeCKaH 60JIe3Hb.

B TeopHH paCqeTa COOpy)l(eHHH 06bJqHO rrOJIb3Y1OTCH rrOHHTHeM «)I(e­ CTKOCTb KOHCTpYKUHH», KYLJ,a BXOLJ,HT B KaqeCTBe MHO)l(lfTeJIH MOLJ,YJIb yrrpyrocTH MaTepHaJIa (CTaJIH H 6eTOHa). Ho rrOHHTHe «MOLJ,yJIb yrrpy­ rOCTH» LJ,eHCTBHTeJIbHO TOJIbKO LlJIH MeTaJIJIa (Ha yqacTKe 1/50 H 1/100

OT rrpOTH)I(eHHOCTH LJ,HarpaMMbI paCTH)I(eHHH CTaJIH). D,JIH 6eToHa, CTporo rOBopH, MOLJ,yJIH yrrpyrocTH Bo06me He CYIIIeCTByeT, a HMeeTCH rrepeMeHHbIH MOLJ,yJIb LJ,e<popMaUHH C HHCXOLJ,HmeH BeTBblO. QT06bI HCrrOJIb30BaTb HeJIHHeHHbIe MOLJ,eJIH LJ,e<pOpMHpOBaHHH B TpaLJ,HUHOH­ HbIX rrpOqHOCTHbIX paCqeTaX K BeJIHqHHe HaqaJIbHOrO MOLJ,yJIH yrrpyro­ CTH, rrpHMeHHIOT K03<P<PHUHeHTbI yrrpyrocTH v HJIH rrJIaCTHqHOCTH A.

OLJ,HaKO 3TH K03<P<PHUHeHTbI yrrpomalOT paCqeTbI CJIHIIIKOM LJ,OpOrOH ueHOH, T. K. OHH He yqHTbIBalOT KJIaCC 6eTOHa H HHCXOLJ,HmylO BeTBb LJ,e<pOpMHpOBaHHH 6eTOHa. KOHeqHble 3JIeMeHTbI B KapTHHe )I(eJIe30­ 6eTOHHOH KOHCTPYKUHH Tpe6Y1OT H3MeHeHHH BeJIHqHHbI LJ,e<popMaUHH rro Mepe rrpOXO)l()J,eHHH HepapXHH B TpemHHo06pa30BaHHH H 6JIOqHOH rrpOqHOCTHOH CTpyKTYpe. KCTaTH, 3TH yrrYIIIeHHH HHBeJIHpylOTCH rrpH HCrrOJIb30BaHHH rrOHHTHH «HHTerpaJIbHbIH MOLJ,YJIb yrrpyrocTH». ECJIH He rrpOBeLJ,eHbI CrreUHaJIbHbIe 3KcrrepHMeHTbI, TO pe3YJIbTaTbI rny60KHx H CJIO)I(HbIX paCqeTOB B paMKax MeTOLJ,a KOHeqHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB He HMelOT KpHTepHH oueHKH COOTBeTCTBHH peaJIbHOH pa60Te KOHCTpyKI..l,HH.

36 I CM. CKopo6oraTOB IKaTaCTpoepbl101 )f{Io1BY'leCTb...

TaIillM 06pa30M, rrpliMeHeHlie TOJIhKO ~eTepMliHlipOBaHHhIXHJIH Tpa~HUliOHHhIXMeTO~OB K paCqeTy )KeJIe306eTOHHhIX YHHKaJIhHhIX

KOHCTpYKUliM KaK MOHOJIliTHhIX, CIIJIOIIIHhIX He rrpHeMJIeMO. OCMOTp <pparMeHTOB KOHCTpYKUHM, OCTaBIIIliXCH rrOCJIe KaTaCTpo<phI Ha CTaH­

UHli CBep,lLJIOBCK-CopmpOBOqHhIM (1988 r.), rrOKa3aJI, qTO 60JIhIIIepaJ­ MepHhle KOHCTpYKUliH 06pa3yroT OCKOJIIill H 06JIOMIill orrpe~eJIeHHhIX

CooTHoIIIeHliM B pa3Mepax, COOTBeTcTByIOIIIHX HepapXHH ropHhIX

rropo~rrOCJIe liX pa3pyIIIeHliH, orrHcaHHoM B CTpYKTYPHOM reo<pH3HKe. CJIe~OBaTeJIhHO,He06xo~liMO06paTHThcH K oc06eHHocTHM <pH3Hqe­

CKOro rrpouecca HaKOrrJIeHHH rrOBpe)l()leHHM B 6eToHe, rrpHBOMlliero K BHe3arrHOMY pa3pyIIIeHHIO HJIH KaTaCTpo<pe.

B rrOCJIe~HHe ~eCHTHJIeTHH rrpOH30IIIJIH ~eCHTIillpa3pyIIIHTeJIhHhIX 3eMJIeTpHCeHHM, ~erpMlipyeT030HOBhIM CJIOM, paJBHBaeTCH fJI06aJIhHOe rrOTeIIJIeHHe. Bce 3TO - Ha <poHe YXY~IIIeHHH3KOJIOmqeCKoro COCTOH­ HHH HallieM IIJIaHeThI li 060cTpeHliH 3HepreTHqeCKOM CHTYaUHH. TYT

COBepIIIeHHO yMecTHo BcrrOMHHTh CJIOBa B. 3axapoBa H <1>. <1>opToBa, aKMeMliKOB PAR: «IIaccHBHoe o~aHHe 6Y~YIIIHXKaTaCTpo<p 6hI­

JIO 6hI,lLJIH qeJIOBeqeCTBa caMoM 6JIH30PYKOM CTpaTemeM». IIoBhlIIIeHlie 6e30rracHocTH YHliKaJIhHhIX 06beKToB CBH3aHO C pa3­

pa60TKoM KOMIIJIeKCHhlX li CliCTeMHhlX rrO~O~OB,BKJIIOqaIOIIIHX Bepo­ HTHOCTHhle H ~eTepMliHlipoBaHHhle MeTO~hI rrpe~CKa3aHHH KaTaCTpo<p.

BepOHTHOCTh He HBJIHeTCH MaTeMaTHqeCKHM rrOHHTHeM, KaK YTBep­ )I()laeTCH B HayqHoM JIliTepaTYPe [1.33]. OHa COqeTaeT B ce6e 60JIhIIIyro KOHKpeTHOCTh H 60JIhIIIee 60raTcTBo, qeM rrOHHTHH qHCTOM MaTeMaTHIill

(A. R. KOJIMOroPOB). BepoHTHoCTh rrpliMeHliMa K caMhIM pa3Ho06pa3­ HhIM 06JIaCTHM peaJIhHhIX HBJIeHHM. OCHoBHhle rrOTpe6HTeJIH pa3HO­ 06pa3Hhlx BepOHTHOCTHhIX MeTO~OB- 3TO pa3JIHqHhle pa3~eJIhI CTa­

THCTliIill. O~HaKo BepOHTHOCTHhle MeTO~hI He Bcerna COOTBeTcTByIOT CTaTliCTliqeCKliM oc06eHHOCTHM. CKa)KeM, rrpe~rrOJIO)KeHlie0 HOP­ MaJIhHOM pacrrpe~eJIeHHHBepOHTHOCTeM B reHepaJIhHOM COBOKYrrHOCTH He Bcer~a Y~OBJIeTBOpHeT3KcrrepliMeHTaM H He Bcer~a rrpOBepHeTCH. BhlpaBHHBaHHe CTaTHCTHqeCKliX ~aHHhIX C rroMOllihIO HOpMaJIhHOro pacrrpe~eJIeHHHHe Bcer~aOTBeqaeT pOJIH HJIH Becy OT~eJIhHoro3Kcrre­ pHMeHTa. 060CHOBaHHeM,lLJIH rrpHMeHeHHH KaKoro-JIH60 BepOHTHoro

MeTo~a qaCTO CJIy)KHT HeKOTopaH CTerreHh pa3yMHoM yBepeHHOCTH,

rrpliHliMaeMaH KaK BepOHTHOCTh.

BepOHTHOCTh He Bcer~aBhlp~aeTCHqepe3 CTaTliCTflqeCIille CBOMCTBa 06beKTOB, HarrpliMep, qepe3liX OTHOCHTeJIhHyro qaCTOTY. BepOHTHOCTh

B pa3JIHqHhIX HeCTaTHqeCIillX rrpHMeHeHHHX MO)KeT Bhlp~aThcHqepe3 pa3JIHqHhle CBoMcTBa 06beKToB (rroBe~eHlie,rrOJIe3HOCTh, ueHHocTh, CTerreHh rrO~TBep)l()leHHH).

ITepBhle HCCJIe~OBaHHHrro BepoHTHoCTli C rrpHMeHeHHeM CTaTHCTH­

qeCKHX MeTO~OBCTHMYJIliPOBaJIHCh He CTaTHCTHKOM, a JIOrHKoM.

B HaCTOHIIIeM pa60Te Ha OCHOBe JIOrHIill C~eJIaHa rrOrrhITKa 06be­

~HHHTh BepOHTHOCTHhIM 3HTporrHMHhIM rro~xo~ K HaKOrrJIeHHIO rro­ Bpe)l()leHHM, xapaKTepH3yIOIIIHM CTerreHh pa3BHTHH H rrpH6JIH)KeHHH K KaTaCTpO<pe C HH<popMaUHOHHhIM rro~o~oMK orrpe~eJIeHHIO pe3epBa )KHByqecTH (rrpO~OJIhHOMTpeIIIHHOCTOMKOCTH) KOHCTpYKUlili.

<1>H3HqeCKaH OCHOBa TeopHH KaTaCTpo<p - 3TO, KaK yrrOMHHaJIOCh BhlIIIe, HepapxHH, B03pacTaIOlliaH B TpeIIIHHo06pa30BaHHH B 3aBHCH­ MOCTH OT YBeJIHQeHHH pa3Mepa KOHCTpyKUHli. LJ:JIH 6eToHa rrepexo~ K 60JIee KpyrrHhIM TpeIIIHHaM - pe3YJIhTaT Qepe~OBaHHH~BYXOCHOBHhIX COCTOHHHM: rrCeB~OIIJIaCTHQeCKoroli xpyrrKoro.

BepOHTHOCTHaH OCHOBa TeopHH KaTaCTpo<p - 3TO rrpHMeHeHHe HH<popMaUHOHHOM 3HTporrHH ,lLJIH paCKphITHH CTpYKTYPHOM Heorrpe­

~eJIeHHOCTHB TpeIIIHHo06pa30BaHlili. ECJIli KOJIliQeCTBO pa3pyIIIHB­ IIIHXCH cBH3eM Me~CTpYKTYPHhIMH 06pa30BaHHHMH TpaKToBaTh KaK KOJIHQeCTBO CHrHaJIOB OT 3THX pa3pyIIIHBIIIliXCH CBH3eM, TO OTKphIBa­ eTCH rrpHHUHrrHaJIhHaH B03MOlICHOCTh HCrrOJIh30BaHHH HH<popMaUHOH­

HOM 3HTporrHH Hi rro K. :3 llIeHHoHY

MeTO~HQeCKaH OCHOBa TeopHH - 060cHoBaHHe rrOHHTHH «pe3epB )KHByqecTH» ,lLJIH OT~eJIhHhIX YHHKaJIhHhIX )KeJIe306eToHHhIX KOHCTpYK­ UHM KaK KOHKpeTHoro ~eTepMHHHpOBaHHoroOCTaTOQHOrO pecypca (B 6HTaX) B KOHCTPYKUliH B pe3YJIhTaTe HepapmQeCKOrO (Qepe~yroIIIe­ roCH rrOCTerreHHoro H BHe3arrHoro) HaKOIIJIeHHH rrOBpe)l()leHHM C BeCh­ Ma CHJIhHhIM CTOXaCTHQeCIillM xapaKTepOM rrpOHBJIeHHH. IIOJIyqaeMhIM B pe3YJIhTaTe paCQeTOB KpHTepHM )KHByqecTH ,lLJIH H3rli6aeMhIx )KeJIe­ 306eToHHhIX KOHCTpyKUHM CTaHOBHTCH OCHOBOM ~JIH orrpe~eJIeHHH ~OJIrOBeQHOCTH,oc06eHHo B arpeccHBHoM cpe~e.

IIpH rrpoeKTHpOBaHHli KarrHTaJIhHoro CTpOHTeJIhCTBa KpHTepHM )KHByqecTH He06xo~HM,lLJIH rrpe~CKa3aHHH COCTOHHHH KOHCTPYKUHH, ~JIH YTOQHeHliH K03<P<PHUHeHTa Ha~e)KHOCTli,yqHThIBaIOlliero CTe­

rreHh OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH, KarrHTaJIhHOCTH coopy)KeHliH H 3HaQHMOCTli rrOCJIe~CTBHMrrpH HaCTYrrJIeHliH rrpe~eJIhHhIX,KaTacTp0<pliQeCKHX COCTOHHliM. IIpe,lLJIaraeMaH MeTO~liKapaCQeTa oc06eHHo y~06Ha,lLJIH

aHaJIH3a OT~eJIhHhIXKOHCTpyKUliM, rrOBpe)l()leHHhIX OT HeH3BeCTHOM

BeJIHlfHHhI Harpy3KH (ceHCMHKa, B3phIB), lfT06hI OlIpe)l.eJIHTh B03MO)l(­ HOCTh H ueJIeC006pa3HOCTh yCHJIeHH5I B YCJIOBH5IX peKoHcTpyKUHH, BOCCTaHOBJIeHH5I H JIHKBH)l.aUHH 1I0CJIe)l.CTBHH KaTaCTpocP.

1.4.MeCTO ....HepopMa4....oHHoM 3HTpon........ BTeop....JlX HaAe>KHOCT........ np06/1eMe KaTacTpoep .... >K .... By~eCT....

TIpHHUHII HHcPopMaUHoHHoH 3HTponHH [1.28-1.31] IIpeLlJIaraeTC5I npHMeH5ITh )l.JI5I 0lIHCaHH5I MHorocTyneHlfaToro MexaHH3Ma nOBpe­ )I()l.eHH5I H pa3pyIIIeHH5I IIPOlfHOCTHOH CTpyKTyphI HeO)l.HOpOllHhIX, HeCIIJIOIIIHhIX TBepllhIX TeJI THlIa 6eToHa, rpaHHTa H T.)l.. TIocTelIeHHoe MHoroCTYIIeHlfaToe He3aMeTHoe HaKalIJIHBaHHe 1I0Bpe)l()l.eHHH IIPHBO­ llHT K BHe3alIHOMY 06PYIIIeHHIO, HJIH KOJIJIalIcy, )l.OKa3hIBaeT HaJIHlfHe KaTaCTp0cPHlfecKoro 51BJIeHH5I B cPH3HlfecKoM IIpouecce 1I0Bpe)l()l.eHH5I H pa3pYIIIeHH5I (CM. fJI. 3).

Cl>H3HlfecKoe OIIHcaHHe KaTaCTp0cPHlfecKoro 51BJIeHH5I B MaTepHaJIe CTapaIOTC5I 1I0lllfHHHTh CTporoMy HayqHoMy OlIpelleJleHHIO, IIIHpOKO onHcaHHoMy B MHpOBOH JIHTepaType [1.24-1.26]. B IIpHKJla)l.HOH Ma­ TeMaTHlfeCKOH TeopHH CYIUecTByeT KJIaCcHcPHKaUH5I 3JIeMeHTapHhIX KaTacTpocP H HaClfHThIBaeTC5I 60JIee )l.eC5ITKa HX BH)].OB. TIo CHMIITOMaM HCCJIellOBaHHIO cPYHKUHH Ha MaKCHMYM H C yqeToM HX 6HcPYPKaUHH OIIH­ caHHe 1I03BOJIHeT lIoll06paTh BH)]. 3JIeMeHTapHOH KaTaCTpocPhI. Ka)l()l.oMY BH)].y 3JIeMeHTapHoH KaTaCTpocPhI COOTBeTcTByeT O)l.HH HJIH HeCKOJIhKO cPH3HlfecKHx IIpoueCCOB HJIH 51BJIeHHH H3 IIpHpO)l.hI HJIH TeXHHKH.

H3-3a 60JIhIIIOrO pacceHBaHH5I IIPOlfHOCTH B OT)l.eJIhHOH KOHCTpyK­ UHH CJIa6hIe MeCTa B 6eTOHHOM MaCCHBe npe)l.CTaBJl5lIOT C060H aTTpaK­ TOPhI, HJIH OlfarH KaTaCTpOcPHlfeCKHX 51BJIeHHH. 3TH cneUHcPHlfeCKHe npHlfHHhI 1I0Bpe)l()l.eHHH JIOrHlfHO Tpe6YlOT 06paIUeHH5I K MaTeMaTH­ lfeCKOH TeopHH KaTaCTpOcP.

ECJIH Ha6JIIOllaeTC5I CKalfKo06pa3Hoe H3MeHeHHe B BH)].e BHe3anHoro OTBeTa CHCTeMhI Ha IIJIaBHOe H3MeHeHHe BHeIIIHHX yCJIOBHH, TO 3TO KaTaCTpOcPa cphIBa (eCJlH CJlellOBaTh reOJIOmlfeCKOH KJIaCCHcPHKaUHH). Ee mnOTeTHlfeCKHH HenpellcKa3yeMhIH xapaKTep MaKCHMaJIhHO COOT­ BeTcTByeT TexHoreHHOH KaTaCTp0cPe, pa3BHBaIOIIIeHC5I B pe3YJIhTaTe cPH3HlfecKoro npouecca. Ha OCHOBe cPYHllaMeHTaJIhHbIX HCCJIellOBaHHH

B. H. ApHOJIblla MaTeMaTHlfeCKa51 TeOpH5I KaTaCTpocP BKJIlOlfaeT llBe

OCHOBHhIe oc06eHHOCTH oT06p~eHH5IKpHBhIX 1I0BepXHOCTH Ha IIJIOC­ KOCTH (IIO OnpelleJIeHHIO X. YHTHH): «CKJla)l.Ka» H «c60pKa». J1aBHHHOMY IIpoueccy IIpe06pa30BaHH5I MHKpOTpeIUHH B MaKpOTpeIUHHhI B TBep)l.hIX TeJIax 60JIhIIIe COOTBeTcTByeT c60pKa KaK oc06eHHOCTh KaTaCTp0cPHlfe­ CKOro 51BJIeHIDI B 6eTOHe. He nOCJIellHlO1O POJIh HrpaeT 311eCb B3aHMOCB5I3h Harpy)l(eHH5I H TpeIUHHo06pa30BaHH5I B cTpOHTeJIhHOH KaTacTpocPe.

KOHKpeTHa51 H3Y'laeMa51 TeXHOreHHa51 KaTacTpocPa 06yCJIOBJIeHa cPaKToM pa3PYIIIeHH5I MaccHBHoH KOHCTpyKUHH KaK pe3YJIhTaTOM He­ npephIBalOIUeroC5I IIpouecca HaKOlIJIeHH5I 1I0Bpe)l()l.eHHH H TpeIUHH B MaTepHaJIe. TIp05lBJIeHHe HepapXHlfecKoH 1I0CJIellOBaTeJIhHOCTH B 06­ pa30BaHHH MHKpO-, Me30- H MaKpOTpeIUHH B MaCCHBHOH KOHCTpyKUHH HOCHT mlioTeTHlfecKHH xapaKTep. TIoBe)l.eHHe CHCTeM «MHKPOCTpyKTy­ pa B Me30CTpyKType» H «Me30CTpyKTypa B MaKpOCTpyKType» HCKJllOlfaeT H3 CBoero IIp06JleMHOrO 1I0JI5I B03MO)I(HOCTh HCIIOJIh30BaHH5I CYllieCT­ ByIOIUHX)l.eTepMHHHpOBaHHhIX TeopHH IIPOlfHOCTH H TeopHH Ha)l.e)I(HO­ CTH llJI5I CIIJIOIIIHOrO 1I0JI5I co CJIa6hIMH BKJIlOlfeHH5IMH.

Ll,aJlee paccMaTpHBalOTC5I BapHaHThI HeKoTophIX TeopHH Halle)l(­ HOCTH, IIpeTeHllYIOIUHX Ha yqeT KaTacTpocP HJIH KaTacTpocPHlfecKHx 51BJIeHHH B MaTepHaJIe.

ECJIH qeJIOBelfeCKHH cPaKTop yqHThIBaTh B BHlle OIIIH6KH IIpoeKTH­ pOBIUHKa, TO CJle)l.yeT 06paTHThC5I K 60JIee IIIHpOKOH nOCTaHOBKe IIPO­ 6JIeMhI 6e30lIacHocTH - TeopHH pHCKa [1.34]. OllHaKo TeOpH5I pHCKa CB5I3aHa He C YBeCHCThIMH ellHHH'lHhIMH KOHCTPyKUH5IMH, a C Macco­ BhIMH H3)l.eJIIDIMH. TeopIDI pHCKa BKJlIO'laeT B Ce6513JIeMeHThI Ha)l.e)I(HO­ CTH HJIH Bep05lTHOCTH )l.JI5I CIIJIOIIIHOro TeJIa CO CJIa6hIMH BKJlIO'leHH5IMH. Ll,n51 MaCCHBHhIX)I(e KOHCTpYKUHH TpeIUHH006pa30BaHHe IIpelllIOJIaraeT 6JIOlfHyIO CTpyKTypy MaTepHaJIa. CKopee Bcero, TeOpH5I pHCKa COOTBeT­ cTByeT MeLlJIeHHOH KaTacTp0cPe. B TeopHH pHCKa lleJIaeTC5I 1I0lIhITKa BBeCTH 1I0H5ITHe «06IUa51 Bep05lTHOCTh pa3pyIIIeHH5I» IIpH cJIa60 pa3­ pa60TaHHhIx KOMIIOHeHTax 3TOH TeopHH. TaK, MexaHH3M pa3pYIIIeHH5I CB5I3hIBaeTC5I C K03cPcPHUHeHTaMH HHTeHCHBHOCTH HalIp5l)l(eHHH H3 MexaHHKH pa3pyIIIeHH5I, a OH IIpHMeHHM JIHIIIh llJI5I MaJIhIX 06pa3uoB 6eTOHa (1l0 8CM).

EblcTpa51 KaTacTpocPa KaK cPH3H'leCKHH IIpouecc MO)l(eT 6hITh KOHKpeTH3HpOBaHa C nOMoIUblO TeopHH KOHcPJIHKTOB. HalIpHMep, KaTacTpocPY MO)I(HO npellCTaBHTh KaK KOHcPJlHKT Me)l()l.y IIp05lBJIeHHeM KaTaCTpocPhI H B03MO)l(HOCTbIO ee KOHTpOJl51 HJIH IIpellCKa3aHH5I ee BO BpeM5I npoeKTHpOBaHH5I.

PaJpa6aTbIBaeMaH Teopllil KOH<pJIHKTOB [1.34] CHIDKaeT HeOnpe,ll,eJIeH­ HOCTb B PaJMbITOH rpaHHqHOH nOJIoce Me)l()Jy TeopHeH Kamcrpo<p H Teo­ pHeH Ha)l,e)l(HOCTH H BBO,ll,HT pa3JIHqHe Me)l()Jy 6bICTpOH H Me)l,JIeHHOH KaTacrpo<paMH. 3'ra TeOpH5I OTHOCHTeJIbHO <pH3HqeCKHX $!.BJIeHHH BBO­ ,ll,HT nOH$!.TH$!.: (<IIpe,ll,CKa3yeMoCTb», «cJIa6a$!. npe,ll,CKa3yeMoCTb» H «He­ npe,ll,CKa3yeMoCTb». CHCTeMa «BHellIHee B03,11,eHCTBHe H npoeKTHbIH KOHrpOJIb» onHCbIBaeTC$!. <PYHKliHOHaJIbHOH CB$!.3blO

K(y) = H(x),

r,ll,e y H X - H3MeH$!.IOIIIHec$!. napaMeTpbI (apryMeHTbI) CHCTeMbI.

ECJIH CB$!.3b Me)l()l,y K(y) H H(x) ,ll,eTepMHHHpOBaHa, TO $!.BJIeHHe npe)l.­

cKa3yeMo, Hero MO)I(HO nepeBeCTH Ha $!.3bIK aJIre6paHqeCKHX <pOpMyJI. ECJIH HMeeTC$!. CTOXaCTHqeCKaH CB$!.3b, TO $!.BJIeHHe BepO$!.THO npe,ll,CKa­ 3yeMo, Hero MO)I(HO onHcaTb C nOMOIIIblO TeopHH Ha)l,e)I(HOCTH. IIpH OTCyrCTBHH KOppeJIHpOBaHHOH CB$!.3H Me)l()Jy K(y) H H(x) $!.BJIeHHe cJIa60 npe,ll,CKa3yeMo MJIH Henpe,ll,CKa3yeMO. IIocJIe,ll,HHH CJIyqaH OTHOCHTC$!. K 6bICrpOH KaracrpO<pe, crporo onHcaHHOH MHOfHMH BH,II,aMH (BapHaH­

TaMH) H3 TeopHH MaTeMaruqeCKHX Karacrpo<p. OHH HaH60JIee npHcno­ C06JIeHbI H npe,ll,HaJHaqeHbI)l,JI$I. OTP~eHlliI<pH3lfqeCKHX $l.BJIeHHH H npo­

ueCCOB B TBep,ll,bIX TeJIax, B TOM qHCJIe H )l,JI$!. TeXHoreHHbIX KaTacrpo<p.

I1cnoJIb30BaHHe TepMHHa «KaTacTpo<pa» KaK HayqHoro )l,JI$!. yHH­ KaJIbHOrO crpoHTeJIbHoro coopy)l(eHH$!. He npOTHBOpeqHT, TaKHM 06­ pa30M, HH MaTeMaTHqeCKOMY, HH 06bI,ll,eHHoMY npe,ll,CTaBJIeHH$!.M Ka­

TacTpo<pbI. 113yqaeMa$!. np06JIeMa Ha)l,e)I(HOCTH CB$!.3aHa, Bo-nepBbIX, C e,ll,HHCTBeHHbIM 061>eKTOM, )l,JI$!. KOToporo TeopHH BepO$!.THOCTH He npHeMJIeMbI, BO-BTOpbIX, pa3pyrneHHe MaCCHBHoro coopy)l(eHH$!. ac­ COUHHpyeTC$!. C qeJIOBeqeCKHMH )l(epTBaMH H 60JIbllIHM MaTepHaJIbHbIM YIIIep60M B HapO,ll,HOM X03$!.HCTBe.

B03BpaIIIaHCb K crporoMy MaTeMaTHqeCKOMY onHcaHHIO KaTacrpo­ <pHqeCKHX $!.BJIeHHH, OTMeTHM, qTO CBOHCTBO Henpe,ll,CKa3yeMocTH 061>­

$!.CH$!.eTC$!. B03MO)I(HOCTblO 6H<pYPKaUHH XO,ll,a <pH3HqeCKOrO npouecca BCJIe,ll,CTBHe pa36poca B CBOHCTBax MaTepmlJIa. IIpouecc 6H<pYPKaUHH

MO)I(HO npOCJIe,ll,HTb Ha KpHBbIX ,ll,e<p0pMaum1 6eToHa (pHC. 1.1);

B cnyqae HeO,ll,HOpO,ll,HOCrn npouecc ,ll,e<popMaUHH C KpHBOH 60JIee BbICO­ KOnpOqHoro 6eTOHa COCKaJIb3bIBaeT Ha KpHBYJO MeHee npOqHoro 6eToHa.

O,ll,HaKO B MaTeMaTHqeCKOH TeopHH KaTaCTpo<p He yqHTbIBaeTCH <peHOMeH HenpepbIBHO MeH$!.lOIIIeroc$!. H npepbIBalOIIIeroc$!. npouecca

nCeB,II,OnJIaCTHqeCKOrO H xpynKoro COCTO$!.HHH. 3JIeMeHTapHbIH BH,II, KaTacrpO<pHqeCKoro $!.BJIeHH$!. «c60pKa» He nOJIHOCTblO y,ll,OBJIeTBop$!.eT MHorocTyneHqaToMy H nOCJIe,ll,OBaTeJIbHOMY npoueccy paCKpbITH$!. 6JIOqHOH CrpYKTYPbI HeCIIJIOIIIHOrO TBep,ll,oro TeJIa MJIH KOHCrpYKIIHH.

EOJIbllIaH HeO,ll,HOp0,ll,HOCTb MaTepHaJIa, Onpe,ll,eAAeMaH npOqHOCTblO H ,ll,e<popMaTHBHOCTblO MaTepHaJIa, Tpe6yeT CTaTHCTHqeCKOrO nO,ll,XO,ll,a H BbI60pa 60JIee Ha)l,e)l(HOrO npe,ll,llIeCTBeHHHKa KaTacrp0<pHqeCKoro $!.BJIeHH$!.. Ha <pOHe npepbIBHCToro npouecca aKKYMyJIHpOBaHH$!. Tpe­ IIIHH ,ll,Ba <paKTopa - HepapXH$!. B TpeIIIHHo06pa30BaHHH H KapTHHa TpeIIIHH - MOryr 6bITb 60JIee Ha)l,e)I(HbIM npe,ll,BeCTHHKOM KaTaKJIH3Ma, qeM napaMeTpbI npOqHOCTH H ,ll,e<popMaTHBHOCTH 6eTOHa.

Eb

Puc. I. I. B03MO)I(HaH 6H<pypKaUllil npouecca ,ll,e<p0pMHpoBaHH$!. 6eToHa Ha KpHBbIX 0-£

)LTrn onHcaHllil npepbIBHcTOro H MHoroCTYIIe~aTOronpouecca nOBpe­ )I()l,eHlliI, npe,ll,CTaBJI$l.IOIIIero KaTacrp0<pHqeCKOe $!.BJIeHHe, aBTOp ,ll,aHHOH pa60TbI HCnOJIb30BaJI Bep0$!.THOCTHbIH no)l,XO,ll, B BH,II,e HH<pOpMauHOHHOH 3HTPQIIHH, BbITeKaIOIIIeH H3 BTOPOro JaKOHa TepMO)l,HHaMHKH

IIpH 3TOM HOBbIH BH,II, KaTacTpo<pHqeCKOrO $!.BJIeHH$!. ,ll,OCTaTOqHO y,ll,OBJIeTBOpHTeJIbHO onHCbIBaeTC$!. <pOpMyJIOH K.3. lIIeHHoHa npH MHorocryneHqaTOM nOCTYIIJIeHHH CHrHaJIOB:

Hi = -P1log2Pl - P2 10g2h - ... - pnlognpn.

D,BIDKeHHe no cPopMYJIe K. 3. llIeHHoHa cooTBeTcTByeT paCKpbITHIO HeOnpeLleJIeHHOCTH B KapTHHe TpeIUHHoo6pa30BaHH5I BCJIeLlCTBHe Harp)')KeHH5I KOHCTpyKUI1H. TaKHM o6pa30M, npouecc 6HcPYPKaUHH MO)l(eT 6bITb npeLlCTaBJIeH B BHLle CKOJIb)l(eHI1Sl K KPI1BbIM C 60JIbllIOH HeOnpeneJIeHHOCTblO (pHC. 1.2), qTO 06YCJIOBJIHBaeTC5I HeOLlHopOLlHO­ CTblO MaTepHaJIa.

o

A~ ~

Puc. 1.2. B03MO)l(Ha51 6HcPYPKaUH5I npouecca paCKpbITI151 HeOnpeLleJIeHHOCTI1 Hi 113 HHcPopMaUHOHHOH 3HTpOnHI1

1.5.np0611eMbi npeACKa3aH"'.R MacwTa6Horo 3<!><!>eKTa BnpO"'HocT'" peallbHblx TBepAblx HecnllOWHblX Tell

Cepbe3Ha51 nOnblTKa YTBep)i()leHI151 HOBOro B(l)KHOrO HayqHoro Ha­ npaBJIeHH5I, yql1TbIBalOIUero cPpaKTaJIbHbIH aHaJIH3 C HeTpanHUl10HHbIX n03I1UI1H, CLleJIaHa B LlOKJIaLle P. B. rOJIbLlIlITeHHa H A. E. MOCOJIO­ Ba [1.35]. OpeLlcKa3aHI1e npOqHOCTH I1MeeT KOJIOCCaJIbHOe 3HaqeHI1e

)J,JI5I ropHbIX nJIaCTOB B6JIH311 pa3JIOMOB)J,JI5I onpeLleJIeHH5I HX npeLleJIb­ HOro COCT05lHI151 H BbISlCHeHH5I ceHcMoonacHbIx paHoHoB. 06IUHe nOJIO)l(eHI151, YTBep)i()leHH5I H cPOpMyJIbI )J,JI5I pacqeTa, nO-BHLlHMOMy, pacnpOCTpaH5IIOTC5I aBTOpaMI1 Ha Bce BMb! TBepLlbIx TeJI - MeTaJIJIbI, ropHbIe nopOLlbI, 6eToH, KOMn03HTbI H T. Ll. B CBSl311 C 3THM Tpe6Y1OTC5I HeKOTopbIe YTOqHeHH5I 11 LlOnOJIHeHI151.

HOBa51 MeTOLlI1Ka cPpaKTaJIbHOrO aHaJII13a [I. 36] H pa3BI1TbIe, B oc­ HOBHOM, )J,JI5I MeTaJIJIOB H KOMn03HTOB KJIaCTepHbIH H nepKOJI5IUI10H­ HbIH aHaJII13bI [1.37], nO-BI1)J,HMOMy, MOfYT CMeHI1Tb napanl1rMY B HaYKe o npOqHOCTH. MHome I1HTepeCHbIe nonbITKH npl1MeHeHHSl 3THX Me­ TOLlHK K 06b5lCHeHHIO npHpOLlbI npOqHOCTH peaJIbHbIX TeJI MOfYT LlaTb llIHPOKl1H cPPOHT HanpaBJIeHHH, C KOTOpbIX MO)l(HO nJIaHHpOBaTb rJIy­ 60Kl1H aHaJIH3 I1CCJIeLlyeMbIx npOqHOCTHbIX CTpyKTYP H conYTCTBylO­ IUI1X cPI13HKo-MeXaHHqeCKI1X 51BJIeHHH.

B03HHKHoBeHHe TeOpl1H cPpaKTaJIOB CB5I3aHO C HMeHeM cPpaHUY3­ Koro MaTeMaTHKa EeHya MaHLleJIb6poTa. OH OnpeLleJIHJI cPpaKTaJIbI (fractal- Llp06b) KaK caMonoLl06Hoe MHO)l(eCTBO, 06JIanalOIUee LlP06­ HOH HeueJIeBOH pa3MepHocTblO.

ECJIH HeOLlHopOLlHoe TBepLloe TeJIO nOpI1CTOe, TO OHO He 06JIanaeT pa3MepHocTblO 3 KaK CnJIOlliHOe, MOHOJIHTHOe TeJIO, a I1MeeT pa3Mep­ HOCTb OT 2 LlO 3, T. e. B Lll1ana30He Me)l()J,y nJIOCKOCTblO H 06beMoM. TBepLloe TeJIO C HapYIIIeHHOH CnJIOlliHOCTblO, T. e. C TpeIUI1HaMH, HMeeT pa3MepHOCTb MeHee 3. YCJIOBH5IMI1 cPOpMHpOBaHH5I cPpaKTanOB 51BJI51IOT­ C5I LlI1CKpeTHocTb CI1CTeMbI 11 aBTOMOLleJIbHOCTb (caMonOBTOp5leMOcTb). TaKl1M 06pa30M, BCJIeLlCTBl1e nOJII1LlI1CnepCHH cTpyKTYpa TeJIa LlOJI)l(Ha 6bITb caMonoLl06Ha Ha pa3JIHQHbIX MacllITa6HbIx YCJIOBI151X. ECJIH B 3aBHCI1MOCTH OT MaCIIITa6a MexaHH3M pa3pYIlIeHH5I MeH5IeTC5I npl1 H3MeHeHHH pa3MepHOCTI1 D, TO pa3pYIIIeHI1e CJIeLlyeT paCCMaTpHBaTb KaK MHoroypoBHeBbIH (MYJIbTl1cPaKTopHbIH) npouecc [1.38].

BHeLlpeHl1e cPpaKTaJIbHOrO aHaJIH3a B Hanp5l)l(eHHOe COCT05lHHe B6JIH311 TpeIUI1H MO)l(eT LlaTb cPyHLlaMeHTaJIbHbIe pe3YJIbTaTbI B MeXaHI1Ke pa3pyIlIeHH5I, BHeCTH COBceM LlpYrHe npeLlnOCbIJIKI1 H cP0PMYJII1POBKI1 K JIHHeHHOH 11 HeJIHHeHHOH MexaHHKe pa3PYIIIeHH5I. B npeLlnOCbIJIKaX ,llOCTaTOQHO pa3BHToH HaYKI1 0 MeXaHI1Ke pa3pyllIeHH5I npHHI1MaeTC5I l1)J,eaJIbHOe OQepTaHl1e TpeIUI1HbI C rJIanKl1MI1 6eperaMH, OQeHb YLlo6Hoe LlJI5I npl1MeHeHI151 MaTeMaTHQeCKHX MeTOLlOB 113 TeOp1111 ynpyroCTH. Me)i()ly TeM, KaK YKa3bIBaeTC5I B LlpyroM ,llOKJIa,lle P. B. rOJIb,llIlITeHHa 11 A. E. MOCOJIOBa [1.38], nOBepXHOCTb TpeIUI1H, cP0PMI1PYIOIUHXC5I npl1

pa3pyrneHHH peaJIhHhIX MaTepHaJIOB, B qaCTHOCTH, MeTaJUlOB, xapmcre­ pH3yeTcSI HaJIHqHeM HepOBHOCTeH (nHKOB H Bna,Il,HH). OKa3aJIOCh, qTO nOBepXHOCTh TpeIUHHhI 06JIa,Il,aeT <ppaKTaJIhHhIMH CBOHCTBaMH H MO)l(eT 6hITh onHcaHa CJIO)I(HOH 3y6qaTOH JIHHHeH C reOMeTpHeH KpHBOH <pOH Koxa, BKJIIOqaIOIUeH CBOHCTBa aBTOMo,UeJIhHOCTH.

ABTOPhI npe)])laraIOT yqHThIBaTh BJIHSlHHe pa3MepOB TeJIa Ha npoq­ HOCTh C nOMOIUhIO CTeneHHoro 3aKOHa [1.35]

<>v"" V- 1m ,

r,Ue V - xapaKTepHhIH pa3pYllIaeMhIH 06'heM; m =

He3aBHCHMO OT BH,Ua MaTepHaJIa.

O,UHaKO nOCJIe,UYIOlliHe paCqeThI nOKa3hIBaIOT, qTO TaKaSi 3aBH­ CHMOCTh HeKoppeKTHa. IlpH nepexo,Ue OT KOHTpOJIhHOrO Ky6HKa co CTOpOHOH 7,07 CM,UO ropHoro nJIaCTa co CTOpOHOH 1KM nOJIyqaeTcSI HenOMepHO 60JIhlliOe CHH)I(eHHe npOqHOCTH. )l;aJIee YKa3hIBaeTCSI, qTO )])lSi yqeTa TeJI C TpeIUHHaMH CJIe,UyeT yqHThIBaTh CBOHCTBa <ppaKTaJIh­ HOCTH, T. e. pa3MepHOCTh D = 2 - 3. TaKHM 06pa30M, npe,UJIaraeTCSI nOJIh30BaThCSI <pOpMyJIOH

8~_3-D

v-­

m'

r,Ue m = 6; D = 2-3, B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT HapyrneHIDI CllJIOlliHOCTH, Tpe­ llIHHo06pa30BaHHSI.

C nOBhIllIeHHeM HeO,UHopO,UHOCTH YBeJIHqHBaeTCSI KOJIHqeCTBO nop H TpeIUHH, CHIDKaeTCSI npOqHOCTh TBep,UhIX nopHCThIX TeJI. To eCTh Be­ JImHHa D = 3 6JIIDKe K D = 2. O,UHaKo npH TaKOM CHIDKeHHH D <popMyJIa

<>p He ,UaeT CHH)I(eHIDI npOqHOCTH.

B HaCTOSlIUee BpeMJI Ha OCHOBe HCCJIe,UOBaHHH, npOBO,UHBllIHXCSI BO MHOrnx oTpacJISIX <pYHJl:aMeHTaJIhHbIX H npHKJIa,Il,HhIX reXHmecKHX HaYK, MO)I(HO KOHKpeTH3HpOBaTh H YTOqHHTh HeKOTophIe nOJIO)l(eHIDI H YTBep­ )I(Jl:eHHSI, npe,UCTaBJIeHHhIe B ,UOKJIa,Il,e [1.35]. KOHKpeTH3aUHSI KacaeTCSI MexaHH3Ma pa3pyrneHHSI TBep,Uoro TeJIa B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT ero npOqHO­ CTHOH CTpYKTYPhI HJIH Mo,UeJIH. HanoMHHM, qTO BH,U MexaHH3Ma pa3py­ llIeHIDI - 3TO rJIaBHhIH <paKTop, pacKphIBaIOIUHH MacllITa6HhIH 3<p<peKT. Me)l(Jl:yTeM, KaK ~eYKa3hIBaJIOCh, B [1.35] ,UaIOTCSI <P0PMyJIhI)])ISI pacqe­ Ta MacllITa6Horo 3<p<peKTa BHe 3aBHCHMOCTH OT BH,Ua Mo,UeJIH npOqHOCTH.

MexaHH3MOB HJIH npOqHOCTHhIX Mo,UeJIeH )])lSi TBep,UhIx TeJI C pa3­ JIHqHOH npOqHOCTHOH CTpyKTypOH B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT npHpo,UHoro HJIH TeXHoreHHoro npOHCXO)l(Jl:eHH5I, HecoMHeHHo, cymecTByeT MHO­ roo O,UHaKo B HaCT05IIUee BpeM5I MO)I(HO Ha3BaTh ,UBe B3aHMOHCKJIIO­ qaIOIUHe npOqHOCTHhIe Mo,UeJIH, KOTophIe OTpa)l(aIOT HeCOBMeCTHMhIe

BH,UhI CTpYKTYPhI MaTepHaJIa.

Ilpe)l(Jl:e Bcero, CJIe.uyeT ynOMJIHYTh KaK nepBYIO «C,UBHroBYIO» npoq­ HOCTHYIO Mo,UeJIh paJpYllIeHIDI, xapaKTepHYIO)])ISI MeTaJUlHqeCKHX MaTe­ pHaJIOB. Pa3PYllIeHHe 06pa3uoB MeTaJUlOB cOnpOBO)l(Jl:aeTC5I pa3BHTHeM C,UBHrOBhIX llJIaCTHqeCKHX ,Ue<popMaUHH Me)l(Jl:y 3epHaMH MaTepHaJIa. C,UBHroBhIH BH,U pa3pYllIeHIDI, eCTecTBeHHo, OTHOCHTC5I H K 06paJuaM,

HcnhIThIBaeMhIM Ha paCT5I)I(eHHe.

)l;pyraSl, npoTHBOnOJIO)I(Ha5I nepBoH Mo,UeJIH - «oTphIBHa5I», npoq­ HOCTHaSi - xapaKTepHa ,UJI5I Heo,UHopo,UHhIX nopHcThIX TBep,UhIx TeJI THna rpaHHTa H 6eToHa. PeaJIhHhIH TBep,UhIH nopHcThIH Heo,UHopo,U­ HhIH MaTepHaJI pa3,UeJIeH MHKpOTpeIUHHaMH Ha 3epHa eIUe,Uo HcnhITa­ HHSI. Ilo,U Harpy3KoH OH ,UeJIHTC5I Me30TpeIUHHaMH Ha rpynnhI 3epeH, a MaKpoTpeIUHHaMH - Ha 6JIOKH. IlPH BTOPOH Mo,UeJIH peaJIhHhIH Ma­ TepHaJI Mo,UeJIHpyeTC5I HCXO,UHOH nCeB,U03epHHcToH cpe,UoH B BH,Ue co­ BOKynHOCTH cJIa60ynaKoBaHHhIX, HO OqeHh npOqHhIX 3epeH, coe,UHHeH­ HhIX TOHKHMH H n03ToMY CJIa6hIMH CB5I35IMH (CJIa6hIMH nepellIeHKaMH Me)l(Jl:y npOqHhIMH 3epHaMH CJIyqaHHhIx pa3MepoB). HaJIHqHe CJIa6hIX CB5I3eH Me)l(Jl:y npOqHhIMH 3epHaMH - OCHOBHaSI npHqHHa pe3Koro pa3­ JIHqH5I (Ha HeCKOJIhKO nOPMKoB) Me)l(Jl:y TeOpeTHqeCKOH npOqHOCThIO MaTepHaJIa 3epHa H peaJIhHOH HH3KOH npOqHOCThIO TBep,Uoro TeJIa. «OTphIBHa5I» npOqHOCTHaSI Mo,UeJIh xapaKTepHa)])l5I 3eMHoH KOphI, KO­ TOpa5I pa36HTa cHcTeMoH TpeIUHH H pa3JIOMoB. IlOqTH 0pTOrOHaJIhHhIe B llJIaHe TpeIUHHhI 06pa3YIOT 6JIOKH pa3JIHqHOrO pa3Mepa - OT caHTH­ MeTpoB,Uo COTeH H ThIC5J:q KHJIOMeTpoB, T. e. ,UO llJIaHeTapHOH TpeIUHHo­ BaTOCTH. EOJIee KpynHhIe 6JIOKH pa3BHBaIOTC5I npH 60JIhlliOH Harpy3Ke H BKJIIOqaIOT 60JIee MeJIKHe 6JIOKH. l1epapXH5I B TpeIUHH006pa30BaHHH H 6JIOqHa5I CHCTeMa, pa3BHBaIOIUa5IC5I no,U HarpY3KoH, OTJIHqHTeJIhHhIe

CBoHcTBa «OTphIBHOH» Mo,UeJIH.

EOJIee MeJIKHe 6JIOKH BXOMT B 6JIOKH 60JIhllIHX pa3MepoB. )l;pyroe OTJIWIHTeJIhHOe CBOHCTBO «BJIO)l(eHHOCTH» 6JIOKOB oTp~aeTHeO,UHO­

pO,UHOCTh B npOqHOCTHhIX H ,UpyrHX <pH3HqeCKHX CBoHcTBax nopHcThIX Heo,UHop0,UHhIX TBep,UhIX TeJI. «OTphIBHa5I» npOqHOCTHaSI Mo,UeJIh npH HaJImHH HepapXHH B TpeIUHHo06paJoBaHHH H CHCTeMhI «BJIO)l(eHHOCTH»