Добавил:
kiopkiopkiop18@yandex.ru Вовсе не секретарь, но почту проверяю Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Скачиваний:
3
Добавлен:
24.03.2024
Размер:
991.14 Кб
Скачать

< ³j_Zevghc´ `bagb fh`gh lZd`_ gZclb iZjm khhl\_lkl\bc k h^ghc

klhjhgu \u g_hkhagZggh ij_^iheZ]Z_l_ qlh h[t_dlb\gh \hkijbgbfZ_l_

j_Zevghklv < khhl\_lkl\bb

k lZdhc

lhqdhc aj_gby

\hkijbylb_ _klv

ijhp_kk h[udgh\_ggh]h gZ[ex^_gby aZ hdjm`Zxsbf fbjhf k ihfhsvx

hj]Zgh\ qm\kl\ Gh wlhl ljZ^bpbhgguc \a]ey^ hkgh\Zgguc gZ³a^jZ\hf

kfuke_´ gjZ\blky gZf lh beb g_l iehoh kh]eZkm_lky kh a^jZ\uf

kfukehf \hh[s_ Z lZd`_ b k kh\j_f_ggufb hldjulbyfb \ ikboheh]bb b

g_cjhnbabheh]bb Fu \b^bf b qm\kl\m_f \h\k_ g_ lh ³qlh gZoh^blky

kgZjm`b´Lh qlh³kgZjm`b´fu dZd jZa g_ \hkijbgbfZ_f

 

 

 

Lh qlh fu \hkijbgbfZ_f b kqblZ_f³\g_rgbf´ ²ebrv mfkl\_ggZy

fh^_ev dhgkljmdpby ihkljh_ggZy gZrbf khagZgb_f B m`_ ihwlhfm hgZ

gZoh^blky \gmljb gZk LZdh_ ihgbfZgb_ ijbjh^u \hkijbylby ijbkms__

[hevrbgkl\m ljZ^bpbhgguo dmevlmj ih^l\_j`^Z_lky b kh\j_f_ggufb

^Zggufb h jZ[hl_ fha]Z <_kvfZ ihe_agh \hh[s_ Z ^ey gZrbo p_e_c

hqbs_gby ^Z`_ g _ h [ o h ^ b f h \ujZ[hlZlv \ k_[_ bf_ggh lZdhc ih^oh^

d ihgbfZgbx ijhp_kkZ \hkijbylby G_h[oh^bfh ihklhyggh ihfgblv qlh

\k_ i_j_`b\Zgby \k_]^Z km[t_dlb\gu b

y\eyxlky j_amevlZlhf gZrbo

kh[kl\_gguo ihkljh_gbc hkgh\Zgguo dZd gZ ihemq_gbb kb]gZeh\ hl

j_Zevghklb lZd b gZ kbxfbgmlghc fhlb\Zpbb Kb]gZeu ihklmiZxsb_ hl

j_Zevghklb fh]ml bkdZ`Zlvky lZd`_ gZrbfb kh[kl\_ggufb h`b^Zgbyfb

beb wfhpbyfb Lh _klv d dZjlbg_ \hkijbylby wg_j]bb ihklmiZxs_c ba

³\g_rg_]h´ j_Zevgh]h

fbjZ ijbf_rb\Z_lky \hkijbylb_ gZrbo

kh[kl\_gguo ² Z

qZs_

 

\k_]h \g_^j_gguo \

gZk g_hj]Zgbq_kdbfb

kms_kl\Zfb²wg_j]bc

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ihwlhfm ijZ\bevguf hlghr_gb_f

d gZr_fm g_hqbs_gghfm

\hkijbylbx fh`gh gZa\Zlv lh dhlhjh_ g_ ij_l_g^m_l gZ ijyfh_

i_j_`b\Zgb_ j_Zevghklb Z \k_]^Z ih^jZamf_\Z_l gZebqb_ __ \gmlj_gg_c

kbevgh bkdZ`_gghc fh^_eb Ij_`^_ q_f fu hdZau\Z_fky \ khklhygbb

\hkijbgylv wg_j]bx ihklmiZxsmx ba j_Zevghklb Z gbq_]h djhf_

wg_j]bb kZfh kh[hc jZamf__lky \hkijbgylv g_\hafh`gh hgZ ijhoh^bl

q_j_a fgh`_kl\h \kljh_gguo \ gZr_ kms_kl\h

³nbevljh\´ Ihwlhfm

\hkijbgbfZ_fZy gZfb dZjlbgZ fbjZ qj_a\uqZcgh h]jZgbq_ggZ

 

 

BlZd

\

khklhygbb

[h^jkl\h\Zgby

nbabq_kdh]h

l_eZ

fu

\hkijbgbfZ_f ² lhqgh lZd `_ dZd b \ khklhygbb h[uqgh]h kgZ ²

lhevdh lh qlh gZoh^blky m gZk³\ ]heh\_´B ijb wlhf fu lhqgh lZd `_

iheZ]Z_f qlh fu g_ kibf M`_ ba h^gh]h wlh]h \b^gh qlh khklhygb_

h[uqgh]h ³[h^jkl\h\Zgby´ b h[uqgh]h kgZ kh\_jr_ggh ZgZeh]bqgu k

lhqdb aj_gby hkhagZgghklb

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

?s_ h^bg ijbf_j <h \j_fy h[uqgh]h kgh\b^_gby q_eh\_d kdehg_g

iZkkb\gh hlghkblvky d

kh[ulbyf Hg

iheZ]Z_l qlh hgb ³ijhklh

ijhbkoh^yl´ b

gbdZd hl

g_]h g_ aZ\bkyl

< hkhagZgghf

kgh\b^_gbb

gZijhlb\ kgh\b^ysbc ihgbfZ_l qlh hg y\ey_lky Zdlb\guf l\hjphf beb

dZd fbgbfmf hl\_lkl\_g_g aZ \k_ ijhbkoh^ys__ b

fh`_l gZ g_]h

wnn_dlb\gh \ebylv <hl qlh ibr_l Klb\_g EZ[_j` ih wlhfm ih\h^m

©<ke_^kl\b_ kh[kl\_gghc iZkkb\ghklb \u fh`_l_ kqblZlv qlh ijZ\beZ

\Zr_c kgh\b^q_kdhc b]ju iheghklvx ij_^hij_^_e_gu ijbgpbiZfb

\g_rg_c j_Zevghklb H[uqguc kgh\b^_p fh`_l hklZ\Zlvky ijbdh\Zgguf

d a_fe_

lhevdh ba aZ lh]h qlh ^Z`_

\h kg_ kqblZ_l ]jZ\blZpbx

mgb\_jkZevguf

aZdhghf

 

nbabdb

H^gZdh

_keb

\Zf o\ZlZ_l

h k h a g Z g g h k l b

qlh[u

m\b^_lv

\

 

kgh\b^q_kdhc ]jZ\blZpbb

mkeh\ghklv lh \u k\h[h^gh kfh`_l_ ba[Z\blvky hl g__ \ae_l_\ ih k\h_c

\he_ Ih^h[guf h[jZahf hkhagZggh kgh\b^ysb_

hlghkylky

b

d

hklZevguf³aZdhgZf´fbjZ kgh\b^_gbc wlh ebrv ijZ\beZ hij_^_e_ggu_

kZfbf kgh\b^p_f ihwlhfm bo fh`gh baf_gblv dZd lhevdh gZ lh

ihy\blky \_kdZy ijbqbgZ Wlh dZq_kl\h h^gZdh g_\hafh`gh i_j_g_klb

g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh \

khklhygb_ [h^jkl\h\Zgby Y

iheZ]Zx

qlh \

wlhf

kemqZ_ khhl\_lkl\mxs__

g_hkhagZggh_

hlghr_gb_

aZdexqZ_lky

\

i_j_`b\Zgbb kblmZpbb dZd hij_^_ey_fhc b h[mkeh\e_gghc \g_rgbfb nZdlhjZfb kms_kl\_ggh \ebylv gZ dhlhju_ m \Zk h[uqgh g_l kbe ?keb \u ijb^_j`b\Z_l_kv lZdh]h \a]ey^Z gZ \Zrm `bagv h[uqgh \ebyxl

^jm]b_ ex^b beb ij_\jZlghklb km^v[u GZijhlb\ hkhagZggh_ hlghr_gb_ khklhbl \ ihgbfZgbb qlh bf_ggh \Zfb hij_^_eyxlky h[klhyl_evkl\Z \Zr_c `bagb Lhevdh hl \Zk aZ\bkbl hdZ`_lky eb dhgdj_lguc khg dhrfZjhf beb \hafh`ghklvx kZfhbgl_]jZpbb Z dhgdj_lgZy `bag_ggZy kblmZpby²djZohf beb \uah\hfª > @

< wlhc pblZl_ \k_ \_jgh djhf_ h^gh]h ² ij_^iheh`_gby h g_\hafh`ghklb i_j_g_klb k\h_ fbjhhsms_gb_ ba h[eZklb hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc \ khklhygb_ [h^jkl\h\Zgby KZf EZ[_j` g_ \_^Zy lh]h hl\_qZ_l gZ \hijhk h lhf dZd wlh k^_eZlv k\hbfb `_ keh\Zfb´H^gZdh _keb \Zf o\ZlZ_l hkhagZgghklb´ ² b ^Ze__ Lhevdh \f_klh kgh\b^q_kdhc ]jZ\blZpbb gZ^h ih^klZ\blv³\ nbabq_kdhc ]jZ\blZpbb´b lh]^Z \k_ \klZg_l gZ k\hb f_klZ Ijhklh ^ey lh]h qlh[u bf_lv hkhagZgghklv \ l_o³kgh\b^_gbyo´dhlhju_ fu \b^bf ^g_f gZ^h bf_lv agZqbl_evgh [hevr_ wg_j]bb q_f ^hklZlhqgh ^ey lh]h qlh[u bf_lv hkhagZgghklv \ gZrbo ghqguo kgh\b^_gbyo

BlZd \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb \u klZgh\bl_kv L\hjphf B bf_ggh hlkx^Z ijhbkl_dZ_l ihljykZxs__ qm\kl\h k\h[h^u b dZd ke_^kl\b_ ² [_a]jZgbqgZy jZ^hklv b [eZ`_gkl\h ?keb g_kdhevdh ^_lZebabjh\Zlv lh fh`gh gZa\Zlv g_dhlhju_ dhfihg_glu wlbo qm\kl\ <u hkhagZ_l_ qlh \Zf gbqlh g_ m]jh`Z_l \u fh`_l_ ^_eZlv Z[khexlgh \k_ qlh lhevdh ohlbl_ <u fh`_l_ gZiZklv gZ qm^h\bs_ beb obsgh]h a\_jy fh`_l_ iju]gmlv k djurb g_[hkdj_[Z beb kh kdZeu \ ijhiZklv \u fh`_l_ ³mlhiblv´ k_[y gZ ^g_ fhjkdhf beb \klmiblv \ [hc k ij_\hkoh^ysbfb kbeZfb \jZ]h\ <u a g Z _ l _ qlh wlh khg b ihwlhfm gbq_]h g_ [hbl_kv² \_^v \Zf gbqlh g_ fh`_l ih\j_^blv

>jm]hc Zki_dl wlh]h i_j_`b\Zgby² \Zrb \hafh`ghklb <u fh`_l_ ^_eZlv Z[khexlgh \k_ Ih djZcg_c f_j_ \ ijbgpbi_ ?^bgkl\_gguf h]jZgbq_gb_f a^_kv kem`bl \ZrZ nZglZaby GZijbf_j qlh dZkZ_lky ebqgh f_gy ba ³g_h[uqguo´ ^_ckl\bc f_gy ijb\e_dZeb \ hkgh\ghf ihe_lu ijhoh`^_gb_ kd\hav ³l\_j^u_´ ij_iylkl\by b i_j_f_s_gby ij_^f_lh\ kbehc \heb GjZ\blky fg_ b kh\f_sZlv wlb ^_ckl\by Qj_a\uqZcgh wnn_dlguf fg_ dZaZehkv \ k\h_ \j_fy gZijbf_j ijhe_l_lv \ fgh]hwlZ`ghf a^Zgbb jy^ wlZ`_c ³ijhgaZy´ i_j_djulby b gZ[ex^Zy [ukljh ijhghkysb_ky fbfh bgl_jv_ju ijhe_lZ_fuo dhfgZl

>he`_g h^gZdh aZf_lblv qlh ih^h[gu_ aZ[Z\u lj_[mxl hij_^_e_gghc kl_i_gb lj_gbjh\Zgghklb KdZ`_f \ i_j\u_ ]h^u y \k_]^Z ³aZklj_\Ze´ \ kl_g_ _keb iulZeky ijhclb kd\hav g__ >ey hljZ[hldb ³l_e_dbg_aZ´ ij_^f_lh\ y ihfgblky \hh[s_ ki_pbZevgh lj_gbjh\Zeky ² gZqbgZe k [mfZ`_d b f_edbo ij_^f_lh\ Z aZdhgqbe rdZnZfb b ^b\ZgZfb k kb^ysbfb gZ gbo ex^vfb Gh ^Z`_ wlh²g_ gZqZevguc m`_ wlZi Dh]^Z \u i_j\u_ jZau \oh^bl_ \ khklhygb_ hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby \Zr_c _^bgkl\_gghc aZ^Zq_c y\ey_lky g_ ^Zlv wlhfm khklhygbx bkq_agmlv b g_ ijhkgmlvky²gb gZ qlh ^jm]h_ wg_j]bb m \Zk kdhj__ \k_]h g_ o\Zlbl <k_ ihke_^mxs__ \_ebdhe_ib_ ijb^_l k hiulhf ih f_j_ lj_gbjh\hd

Lj_lbc Zki_dl ² qm\kl\h e_]dhklb g_\_khfhklb b \ha^mrghklb Bf_ggh ihwlhfm \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb fu hq_gv j_^dh oh^bf Z ihqlb \k_]^Z²e_lZ_f Beb ^\b]Z_fky ^ebggufb ieZ\gufb iju`dZfb ?klv b ^jm]b_ Zki_dlu gh wlh ih`Zemc \Z`g_crb_

Gh qlh g_ ihgye K EZ[_j` ² lZd wlh lh qlh \k_ wlb dZq_kl\Z hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby fu g_ lhevdh fh`_f gh b ^he`gu i_j_g_klb \ lZd gZau\Z_fh_³[h^jkl\mxs__´khklhygb_ : g_ ihgye hg wlh]h ihlhfm qlh _fm g_ba\_klgZ dhgp_ipby wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h kljh_gby q_eh\_dZ < ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ [u hg ihgbfZe qlh hkhagZggh_ kgh\b^_gb_ ² g_ g_dh_ aZdhgq_ggh_ khklhygb_ khagZgby Z ebrv i_j_oh^gZy klmi_gv d _s_ [he__ m^b\bl_evguf _]h khklhygbyf

< kZfhf ^_e_ <_^v j_qv ihdZ b^_l ebrv h ³i_j\uo \jZlZo´ kgh\b^_gby GZr_c `_ aZ^Zq_c fbgbfmf y\ey_lky ^hklb`_gb_ ³lj_lvbo

: lZd`_ \hafh`ghklv ijhkgmlvky hl qj_af_jgh]h ikbobq_kdh]h \ha[m`^_gby

\jZl´ kgh\b^_gby ² lh _klv lZdh]h hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby ^_ckl\b_ dhlhjh]h ijhbkoh^bl m`_ g_ \ \hh[jZ`Z_fhf fbj_ kgZ Z \ j_Zevghf ³^g_\ghf´ fbj_ lZdhf dhlhjuc kms_kl\m_l \ gZr_f ³[h^jkl\h\Zgbb´ B ^hklb`_gb_ \hafh`ghklb \ha^_ckl\h\Zlv gZ wlhl³gZklhysbc´fbj ba k\h_]h khklhygby kgh\b^_gby

Gh \_jg_fky d fh_c bklhjbb DZd m`_ ykgh qblZl_ex k lh]h \j_f_gb dZd y ³ijbkljZklbeky´ d hkhagZgguf kgh\b^_gbyf bglbfgZy kmijm`_kdZy `bagv klZeZ fg_ qj_a\uqZcgh ^hkZ`^Zlv Keh\h ³ijbkljZklbeky´ y _kl_kl\_ggh mihlj_[eyx \ i_j_ghkghf agZq_gbb <_^v _]h dhjg_f y\ey_lky ³kljZklv´ ² keh\h y\gh p_jdh\gh]h ijhbkoh`^_gby bf_xs__ \ \b^m ijb\yaZgghklv d dZdhc eb[h ]j_oh\ghc kljZklb lh _klv d q_fm lh wg_j]haZljZlghfm b hkd\_jgyxs_fm < ^Zgghf `_ kemqZ_ ij_^f_l ³ijbkljZklby´ [ue qbkl b [eZ]h^Zl_g Gb d q_fm bghfm dZd d `_eZgbx ^Zevg_cr_]h hqbs_gby lZdh_ ³ijbkljZklb_´ ijb\_klb g_ fh]eh

Gh ih nhjf_ wlh [ueh dhg_qgh ihoh`_ gZ ijbkljZklb_ Ij_[u\Zgb_ \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb ^Zjm_l kgh\b^ys_fm lZdh_ [eZ`_gkl\h ihke_ dhlhjh]h \k_ lh qlh fh`_l ij_^eh`blv gZf gZrZ h[uqgZy a_fgZy `bagv \u]ey^bl `Zedbf ]jyaguf m[h]bf b gbdq_fguf G_ ih[hxkv ]jm[h]h kjZ\g_gby ² ihke_ hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby h[uqgZy `bagv \ nbabq_kdhf fbj_ ² wlh ijhklh dhiZgb_ \ ^_jvf_ B jZ^b ;h]Z g_ ih^mfZcl_ qlh y \_^m a^_kv j_qv h k_jhc b mguehc `bagb ³jy^h\uo´ ]jZ`^Zg Z \hl fhe _keb [u [ueb ^_gv`ZlZ < lhf b ^_eh qlh gbq_]h ih^h[gh]h KZfZ fZl_jby fbjZ kgh\b^_gby bf__l kh\_jr_ggh ^jm]mx ijbjh^m GZr nbabq_kdbc fbj ih kjZ\g_gbx k l_f fbjhf ij_^klZ\ey_lky ijhklh ]gmkghc ]jyaghc ^ujhc < g_dhlhjhf kfuke_ wlh kZfuc gZklhysbc Z^

Y dhg_qgh ihgbfZx qlh k j_eb]bhaghc lhqdb aj_gby gZr fbj Z^hf kqblZlv fh`_l [ulv b g_ kh\k_f dhjj_dlgh Gh \_^v \k_ ihagZ_lky \ kjZ\g_gbb g_ lZd eb" <kihfgbf ³;h`_kl\_ggmx dhf_^bx´ >Zgl_ LZf \_^v m Z^Z k_fv djm]h\ B gZ\_jgh_ k lhqdb aj_gby h[blZl_e_c k_^vfh]h djm]Z `bagv l_o dlh hdZaZeky kdZ`_f gZ q_l\_jlhf²wlh ijhklh jZc : \hl l_ dlh ihiZe gZ i_j\uc beb \lhjhc y\gh lZd g_ ^mfZxl Ohlv b bo `bagv g_ keZ^dZ gh m` emqr_ gZ i_j\hf q_f gZ q_l\_jlhf ² lZf ³Z^ djhf_rguc´ Gm Z l_f dlh ³kb^bl´ \ jZx ij_[u\Zgb_ m`_ gZ i_j\hf djm]_ Z^Z dZ`_lky qm^h\bsghc iuldhc ² b hgb ih k\h_fm kh\_jr_ggh ijZ\u

LZd qlh \k_ aZ\bkbl hl lhqdb aj_gby Dh]^Z y ³[h^jkl\mx´ \ nbabq_kdhf fbj_ ^ey f_gy fbj hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc ² wlh jZc Dh]^Z y ij_[u\Zx \ khklhygbb hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby b _kl_kl\_ggh iheZ]Zx qlh \k_ lZd b ^he`gh [ulv²\hkihfbgZgb_ h nbabq_kdhf fbj_ y\ey_lky ^ey f_gy \hkihfbgZgb_f h[ Z^_

Ih wlhc ijbqbg_ b g_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \ lhf qlh y ³qbklhlm \haex[be Z kd\_jgm \hag_gZ\b^_e´ ³DZd b gZibkZgh BZdh\Z Y \haex[be Z BkZ\Z \hag_gZ\b^_e´ Jbf Lml ijyfh dZd \ ?\Zg]_ebb©_keb dlh ijboh^bl dh Fg_ b g_ \hag_gZ\b^bl hlpZ k\h_]h b fZl_jb b `_gu b ^_l_c b [jZlv_\ b k_kl_j Z ijblhf b kZfhc `bagb k\h_c lhl g_ fh`_l [ulv Fhbf mq_gbdhfªEd B y \hag_gZ\b^_e \k_ lh qlh lhevdh fh]eh ihf_rZlv fg_ gZkeZ`^Zlvky g_\hh[jZabfh ij_djZkguf fbjhf hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc

Y iheZ]Zx wlh g_ljm^gh ihgylv ba ZgZeh]bb k q_eh\_dhf ijbkljZklb\rbfky d gZjdhlbdm Djhf_ gZjdhlbdZ b lh]h ]^_ _]h ^h[ulv _]h m`_ [hevr_ gbq_]h g_ bgl_j_km_l \ wlhf fbj_ Lh `_ kZfh_

?keb `_ ]h\hjblv g_ klhevdh h j_eb]bhaghc kdhevdh h ijZ\bevghc lhqd_ aj_gby lh gZ^h dhgklZlbjh\Zlv ijhklhc nZdl b jZc b Z^² kh \k_fb k\hbfb ]jZ^Zpbyfb² _klv gb qlh bgh_ dZd khklhygby gZr_]h khagZgby B \ wlhf kfuke_ fu dhg_qgh kf_eh fh`_f ml\_j`^Zlv qlh \ h[uqghf k\h_f©[h^jkl\mxs_fªkhklhygbb ij_[u\Z_f gZ h^ghf ba djm]h\ Z^Z : gZ dZdhf©ih kq_lmª ²wlh m`_ ^jm]hc \hijhk

kemqbehkv b kh fghc gh lhevdh fhc ³gZjdhlbd´ [ue \ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv h[uqghfm ihe_a_g \h \k_o hlghr_gbyo

DZd g_ ljm^gh ^h]Z^Zlvky y klZe bkdZlv imlb ^ey m\_ebq_gby ijh^he`bl_evghklb k\h_]h ij_[u\Zgby \ hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbyo B a^_kv i_j_^h fghc klhyeb ^\_ ijh[e_fu I_j\Zy ² m\_ebq_gb_ ijh^he`bl_evghklb kZfh]h hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby lh _klv ij_^hl\jZs_gb_ ijh[m`^_gby <lhjZy ² g_\hafh`ghklv ih k\h_c \he_ \hclb \ wlh khklhygb_ \k_ f_lh^u \oh`^_gby \ hkhagZggh_ kgh\b^_gb_ [ueb dhk\_ggufb jZkkqblZggufb gZ lh qlh qlh lh ]^_ lh \gmljb kjZ[hlZ_l GbdZdh]h khagZl_evgh]h \ha^_ckl\by gZ ijhp_kk gZijbf_j \kihfbgZgby h g_h[oh^bfhklb ihkfhlj_lv gZ k\hb jmdb y hdZaZlv [ue g_ \ khklhygbb <k_ aZ\bk_eh hl ih^khagZgby Z dhgljhey ih^khagZgby m f_gy ykgh_ ^_eh g_ [ueh

< j_amevlZl_ qZklhlZ hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc dhe_[ZeZkv m f_gy hl h^gh]h ^\mo \ g_^_ex ^h h^gh]h \ h^bg ^\Z f_kypZ : y ohl_e \b^_lv bo dZ`^uc ^_gv b dZd fh`gh [hevr_ KdZ`m [_a ij_m\_ebq_gby _keb [u fg_ lh]^Z ij_^eh`beb [_a\ha\jZlgh i_j_k_eblvky \ lhl fbj y [u kh]eZkbeky [_a dhe_[Zgbc

KZfh kh[hc wlh [ueh g_\hafh`gh lhevdh ba aZ fh_]h wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h khklhygby ?keb [u hgh wlh iha\heyeh²b \hijhkh\ [u g_ \hagbdZeh lZdbo Fh`gh [ueh [u gZoh^blvky \ ex[hf fbj_ kdhevdh gm`gh \ aZ\bkbfhklb hl kh[kl\_ggh]h `_eZgby

LZd qlh \ky ijh[e_fZ lh [ueZ dhg_qgh `_ \h fg_ kZfhf \_jg__²\ fh_c g_qbklhl_ Y [ue ijhklh g_ ]hlh\ d ^ebl_evghfm ij_[u\Zgbx \ l_e_ kgh\b^_gby ^Z`_ gZ mjh\g_³i_j\uo \jZl´

Gh \_jg_fky d wlbf ^\mf ijh[e_fZf GZqg_f k i_j\hc

G_ agZx ^ey dh]h dZd Z ^ey f_gy hkgh\guf ij_iylkl\b_f d m\_ebq_gbx ijh^he`bl_evghklb hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby klZe hj]Zaf Ijbq_f ykgh_ ^_eh hj]Zaf ij_^klZl_evghc `_e_au IhgZqZem wlh ijhba\h^beh kh\_jr_ggh m[bckl\_ggh_ \i_qZle_gb_ ² y g_ mf_e lh]^Z hklZgZ\eb\Zlv wydmeypbx \hh[s_ Z m` \h kg_ b ih^Z\gh < j_amevlZl_ ihqlb dZ`^h_ hkhagZggh_ kgh\b^_gb_ aZdZgqb\Zehkv ihl_j_c k_f_gb Bkdexq_gby khklZ\eyeb l_ kgh\b^_gby \ dhlhjuo ih dZdhc lh ijbqbg_ y mki_\Ze ijhkgmlvky jZgvr_ wlh]h kh[ulby beb `_ \iZ^Ze h[jZlgh \ h[uqguc khg Gh lZdbo kemqZ_\ [ueh fZeh KlZg^Zjlguf `_ \ZjbZglhf [ueh aZ\_jr_gb_ k_fyba\_j`_gb_f Ihke_ q_]h kZfh kh[hc ke_^h\Zeh ijh[m`^_gb_ Ijbq_f ih^_eZlv [ueh gbq_]h g_evay ?keb \u ih^mfZeb qlh wlb hkhagZggu_ kgh\b^_gby bf_eb wjhlbq_kdh_ kh^_j`Zgb_ lh wlh hrb[dZ Gbq_]h wjhlbq_kdh]h \ ih^Z\eyxs_f [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ \ gbo g_ [ueh K_dkmZevgh_ `_ \ha[m`^_gb_ y\eyehkv ke_^kl\b_f \ha[m`^_gby ^\b`_gby wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h ihlhdZ b gZdhie_gby _]h \ aZ[ehdbjh\Zgghf gb`g_f wg_j]_lbq_kdhf p_glj_ >Zevr_ kjZ[Zlu\Ze m`_ hibkZgguc fghx f_oZgbaf wydmeypbb

Ij_`^_ q_f ijh^he`blv wlhl jZkkdZa fg_ [u ohl_ehkv hagZdhfblv qblZl_ey k l_f dZdb_ bkke_^h\Zgby ijh\_e \ wlhc h[eZklb m`_ g_h^ghdjZlgh mihfbgZ\rbcky Klb\_g EZ[_j` <hl ^hklZlhqgh ^ebggZy pblZlZ ba _]h dgb]b

©K_dkmZevgZy Zdlb\ghklv y\ey_lky kms_kl\_gghc ^_lZevx hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc ^ey fgh]bo ex^_c \ hkh[_gghklb `_gsbg IZljbpby =Zjnbe^ khh[sZeZ qlh ^\_ lj_lb __ hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc bf_eb k_dkmZevguc oZjZdl_j b iheh\bgZ ba gbo aZdZgqb\ZeZkv hj]Zafhf < dgb]_ ³Imlv d wdklZam´ =Zjnbe^ jZkkdZau\Z_l qlh \k_ hj]Zafu \ __ kgZo hlebqZebkv ³]em[hqZcr_c´ gZkus_gghklvx ³HsmsZy

Ohly k h[uqghc ©fbjkdhcª lhqdb aj_gby q_eh\_d ijZdlbdmxsbc hqbs_gb_ l _ Zkd_lbaf b hkhagZggu_ kgh\b^_gby ² ih^h[gh h[uqghfm gZjdhfZgm ² y\ey_lky \ hij_^_e_gghf kfuke_ fZj]bgZehf <_^v ih f_j_ m]em[e_gby \ k\hb aZgylby hg ihkl_i_ggh \k_ \ [hevr_c f_j_ \udexqZ_lky ba khpbZevghc `bagb klZgh\blky ih kmlb hlr_evgbdhf ^Z`_ _keb l_e_kgh ijh^he`Z_l `blv kj_^b ^jm]bo ex^_c Ohly dhg_qgh `_ lZdhc q_eh\_d ij_^ihqblZ_l m_^bg_gguc h[jZa `bagb

g_h[uqZcgmx p_ehklghklv dhlhjmx j_^dh \klj_lbrv \ [h^jkl\h\Zgbb´ hgZ hdZau\ZeZkv³ho\Zq_gghc \aju\Zfb ihljykZ\rbfb ^mrm b l_eh´

G_ [m^_l ij_m\_ebq_gb_f kdZaZlv qlh wlh g_\_jhylgh \i_qZleyxsb_ i_j_`b\Zgby Hlq_lu g_kdhevdbo gZrbo hg_cjhgZ\lhd kh^_j`Zl ihoh`b_ k\b^_l_evkl\Z F_gy aZbgljb]h\ZeZ \hafh`ghklv ijh\_^_gby wdki_jbf_glZ k p_evx h[gZjm`blv khhl\_lkl\b_ nbabheh]bq_kdbo baf_g_gbc \h \j_fy k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb \h kg_ b \ [h^jkl\h\Zgbb

< g_kdhevdbo wdki_jbf_glZo fg_ ihfh]Ze Mhel_j =jbgebn \uimkdgbd Klwgnhj^Z aZgbfZ\rbcky bkke_^h\Zgbyfb k_dkmZevghklb q_eh\_dZ Fu j_rbeb gZqZlv k `_gsbg lZd dZd hgb khh[sZeb h[ hj]ZafZo \h kg_ ]hjZa^h qZs_ fm`qbg I_j\hc dlh kh]eZkbeky [ueZ FbjZg^Z bfy \ufure_ggh_ Dh]^Z hgZ kiZeZ \ gZr_c eZ[hjZlhjbb fu ih r_klgZ^pZlb dZgZeZf ke_^beb aZ jZagufb nbabheh]bq_kdbfb ^Zggufb \dexqZy WW= WH= WF= we_dljhfbh]jZffZ qZklhlm ^uoZgby imevk \Z]bgZevgmx WF= b Zfieblm^m \Z]bgZevguo khdjZs_gbc >\_ ihke_^gb_ \_ebqbgu baf_jyebkv k ihfhsvx ahg^Z \\h^bfh]h gZ \j_fy kgZ \h \eZ]Zebs_ Ahg^ j_]bkljbjh\Ze Zdlb\ghklv \Z]bgZevguo furp k ihfhsvx ^\mo we_dljh^h\ gZ _]h ih\_joghklb :fieblm^Z khdjZs_gbc b bgl_gkb\ghklv djh\hh[jZs_gby \ kl_gdZo \eZ]ZebsZ nbdkbjh\ZeZkv bgnjZdjZkguf bklhqgbdhf k\_lZ b nhlhwe_dljbq_kdbf ijb_fgbdhf lZd`_ mklZgh\e_ggufb gZ ih\_joghklb ahg^Z K\_l baemqZ_fuc ahg^hf \ha\jZsZeky d ijb_fgbdm q_j_a ijhf_`mlhd \j_f_gb ijhihjpbhgZevguc bgl_gkb\ghklb \Z]bgZevgh]h djh\hh[jZs_gby Wdki_jbf_glu ijh\_^_ggu_ \ [h^jkl\mxs_f khklhygbb ihdZaZeb qlh \ fhf_gl k_dkmZevgh]h \ha[m`^_gby `_gsbgu Zfieblm^Z \Z]bgZevguo khdjZs_gbc aZf_lgh \hajZklZ_l LZdh_ `_ \hajZklZgb_ fu h`b^Zeb h[gZjm`blv b \h \j_fy k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb \h kg_

Fu ihijhkbeb FbjZg^m ijhkb]gZeblv gZf ba hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby q_luj_ jZaZ bkihevamy klZg^Zjlgh_ ^\b`_gb_ ]eZa I_j\uc kb]gZe ^he`_g [ulv ih^Zg \ lhl fhf_gl dh]^Z hgZ ihcf_l qlh kibl \lhjhc²\ fhf_gl gZqZeZ k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb lj_lbc²\ fhf_gl hj]ZafZ b ihke_^gbc ² lhevdh lh]^Z dh]^Z hgZ ihqm\kl\m_l qlh iheghklvx ijh[m^beZkv

Ijbf_jgh q_j_a iylv fbgml ihke_ gZqZeZ ;>= kgZ FbjZg^Z \hreZ \ hkhagZggh_ kgh\b^_gb_ ]^_ mki_rgh \uihegbeZ ihklZ\e_ggmx aZ^Zqm < k\h_f hlq_l_ hgZ ibr_l qlh hsmsZeZ k_[y [h^jkl\mxs_c HgZ e_`ZeZ \ djh\Zlb Z qvb lh jmdb ]eZ^beb __ r_x HkhagZ\ g_\hafh`ghklv lh]h qlh[u dlh lh hdZaZeky \ __ dhfgZl_ hgZ ij_^iheh`beZ qlh kibl b j_rbeZ ijh\_jblv k\hx ^h]Z^dm ihijh[h\Z\ \ae_l_lv Ih^gy\rbkv \ \ha^mo hgZ hdhgqZl_evgh m\_jbeZkv \ lhf qlh \b^bl kgh\b^_gb_ b iZjy ih dhfgZl_ ih^ZeZ mkeh\e_gguc kb]gZe G_ h[gZjm`b\ gbdh]h \ dhfgZl_ k iheb]jZnhf FbjZg^Z kd\hav aZi_jlh_ hdgh \ue_l_eZ gZjm`m Ijh^he`Zy e_lZlv hgZ hdZaZeZkv \ klm^_gq_kdhf ]hjh^d_ gZihfbgZ\r_f h^gh\j_f_ggh b Hdknhj^ b Klwgnhj^ Ih^h[gh h[eZdm FbjZg^Z k\h[h^gh iZjbeZ \ oheh^ghf \_q_jg_f \ha^mo_ lh b ^_eh hklZgZ\eb\Zykv qlh[u ihex[h\Zlvky ij_djZkgufb dZf_ggufb ba]b[Zfb kl_g Q_j_a g_kdhevdh fbgml hgZ \kihfgbeZ h[ wdki_jbf_gl_ Ijhe_l_\ ih^ Zjdhc FbjZg^Z h[gZjm`beZ ]jmiim ex^_c ² lmjbklh\ hkfZljb\Zxsbo ]hjh^hd Himklb\rbkv \gba hgZ \u[jZeZ k_[_ \ wlhc ]jmii_ fm`qbgm Dh]^Z FbjZg^Z h[gyeZ _]h aZ ie_qb hg ih\_jgmeky d g_c k \b^hf q_eh\_dZ lhqgh agZxs_]h qlh gZ^h ^_eZlv < wlhl fhf_gl FbjZg^Z ih^ZeZ _s_ h^bg kb]gZe hlf_qZxsbc gZqZeh k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb <ihke_^kl\bb hgZ jZkkdZaZeZ qlh m`_ [ueZ \ha[m`^_gZ ihe_lhf ihwlhfm dmevfbgZpby gZklmibeZ q_j_a iylgZ^pZlv k_dmg^ Dh]^Z ihke_^gb_ \hegu klZeb m]ZkZlv hgZ ijhkb]gZebeZ \ lj_lbc jZa hlf_qZy i_j_`b\Zgb_ hj]ZafZ <kdhj_ FbjZg^Z iha\hebeZ k_[_

;>=²[ukljh_ ^\b`_gb_ ]eZa nZaZ kgZ \ dhlhjhc fu \b^bf kgu ex[u_ >_ckl\bl_evgh ihe_l \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb \uau\Z_l mkbe_gb_

wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h ihlhdZ Ij :\l

ijhkgmlvky b ijhkb]gZebeZ \ ihke_^gbc jZa dZd lhevdh h[gZjm`beZ qlh e_`bl \ djh\Zlb HgZ kdZaZeZ qlh hj]Zaf \ kgh\b^_gbb g_ hlebqZeky hkh[hc ijh^he`bl_evghklvx beb bgl_gkb\ghklvx h^gZdh hij_^_e_ggh [ue gZklhysbf

=jZnbd baf_g_gbc \Z]bgZevgh]h djh\hh[jZs_gby \ l_q_gb_ g_kdhevdbo fbgml hkhagZggh]h kgZ ohjhrh kh]eZkh\u\Zeky k hlq_lhf FbjZg^u <h \j_fy k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb \h kg_ f_`^m \lhjuf b lj_lvbf kb]gZeZfb ]eZa qZklhlZ ^uoZgby Zdlb\ghklv \Z]bgZevguo furp b \Z]bgZevgh_ djh\hh[jZs_gb_ ^hklb]Zeb gZb\ukr_]h mjh\gy QZklhlZ k_j^_qguo khdjZs_gbc \hajhkeZ ebrv g_agZqbl_evgh Mkbe_gb_ ^uoZgby b \Z]bgZevgh]h djh\hh[jZs_gby iheghklvx kh]eZkh\u\Zehkv k j_amevlZlZfb gZ[ex^Z_fufb \h \j_fy hj]ZafZ \ [h^jkl\mxs_f khklhygbb Wlhl wdki_jbf_gl hdZaZeky i_j\uf ih^l\_j`^_gb_f \hafh`ghklb i_j_`b\Zlv `b\hc j_Zebklbqguc k_dk \ hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbyo

I_j_^ l_f dZd hklZ\blv wdki_jbf_gl k FbjZg^hc y ohl_e [u hlf_lblv qlh wlhl khg ih djZcg_c f_j_ hlqZklb ijhba\_e [u [eZ]hklgh_ \i_qZle_gb_ gZ Nj_c^Z hdZ`bkv lhl gZrbf kh\j_f_ggbdhf Y ]h\hjx h ihe_l_ dhlhjuc _keb mqblu\Zlv dhjhldbc bgl_j\Ze f_`^m gZqZehf k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb b hj]Zafhf ku]jZe jhev hq_gv wnn_dlb\ghc ih^]hlh\db < q_f `_ kfuke kgh\b^_gbc k ihe_lZfb"Kh]eZkgh ^hdljbg_ Nj_c^Z wlh g_ qlh bgh_ dZd \ujZ`_gb_ k_dkmZevgh]h `_eZgby < ^Zgghf kemqZ_ lZdZy bgl_jij_lZpby fh`_l [ulv ijbgylZ [_ah \kydbo gZly`_d

Bamqb\ \i_qZleyxsmx k_dkmZevgmx Zdlb\ghklv `_gsbg fu aZbgl_j_kh\Zebkv \hafh`ghklyfb fm`qbg G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh fm`qbgu j_`_ khh[sZxl h[ hj]Zafbq_kdbo hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbyo fu \k_ lZdb j_rbebkv gZ ijh\_^_gb_ ih^h[gh]h wdki_jbf_glZ Jwg^b mkeh\gh i_j\hdeZkkguc hg_cjhgZ\l \ua\Zeky ^h[jh\hevp_f gZ wlh jbkdh\Zggh_ aZ^Zgb_

<h \j_fy kgZ Jwg^b fu ijh\h^beb l_ `_ baf_j_gby qlh b \ kemqZ_ k FbjZg^hc Bkdexq_gb_f kem`beh lhevdh lh qlh fu wdbibjh\Zeb _]h wj_dljhf_ljhf dhevphf ba ]b[dhc ljm[db ^bZf_ljhf \ ^xcf gZiheg_gguf jlmlvx ² ijb[hjhf h[uqgh bkihevam_fuf ^ey baf_j_gby k_dkmZevghc j_Zdpbb I_j_^ l_f dZd mkgmlv Jwg^b gZ^_e wlh dhevph gZ hkgh\Zgb_ i_gbkZ < fhf_gl wj_dpbb dhevph jZkly]b\Zehkv qlh ijb\h^beh d \hajZklZgbx we_dljbq_kdh]h khijhlb\e_gby jlmlb b iha\heyeh ke_^blv aZ m\_ebq_gb_f i_gbkZ k ihfhsvx iheb]jZnZ G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh \oh`^_gb_ \ ;>= khklhygb_ g_j_^dh khijh\h`^Z_lky kihglZgghc wj_dpb_c fu gZ^_yebkv aZf_lblv __ ^Zevg_cr__ \hajZklZgb_ \h \j_fy k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb \h kg_

Jwg^b kh]eZkbeky ih^Zlv l_ `_ kb]gZeu dhlhju_ ih^Z\ZeZ FbjZg^Z Ihke_ g_kdhevdbo ghq_c ijZdlbdb _fm wlh m^Zehkv H^gZ`^u ijhkgm\rbkv ihke_ ;>= i_jbh^Z hg gZibkZe ke_^mxsbc hlq_l

©Ijbqm^eb\hklv h[klZgh\db ihfh]eZ fg_ ihgylv qlh y kiex Y ih^Ze kb]gZe ]eZaZfb b ih^h[gh Kmi_jf_gm ijhe_l_e kd\hav djurm Ijba_feb\rbkv gZ aZ^g_f ^\hj_ y aZohl_e `_gsbgm Ijb\e_dZl_evgZy xgZy ^_\mrdZ \ khijh\h`^_gbb fZl_jb \ureZ ba ^hfZ HdZaZehkv qlh fZlv agZ_l f_gy Ih^fb]gm\ hgZ hlijZ\beZ k\hx ^hqv ihb]jZlv kh fghc Fu \ureb \h ^\hj b y ijhkb]gZebabjh\Ze h gZqZe_ k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb Q_j_a f]gh\_gb_ [emadZ ^_\mrdb hdZaZeZkv gZ a_fe_ b y m\b^_e khkdb __ jZkp\_lZxs_c ]jm^b HgZ himklbeZkv gZ dhe_gb b klZeZ p_eh\Zlv f_gy g_\_jhylgh \ha[m`^Zxsbf h[jZahf Y ihqm\kl\h\Ze qlh ijb[eb`Zxkv d dmevfbgZpbb b aZdjue \ wdklZa_ ]eZaZ BkiulZ\ hj]Zaf y ih^Ze kb]gZe Dh]^Z y hldjue ]eZaZ lh h[gZjm`be qlh ijhkgmeky ihke_ ³fhdjh]h´kgZ Y [ue hq_gv h[jZ^h\Zg qlh wdki_jbf_gl m^Zeky h^gZdh \kdhj_ ihgye qlh wlh ebrv eh`gh_ ijh[m`^_gb_ < wlhl fhf_gl y

OhjhrZy beexkljZpby ]emihklb lZd gZau\Z_fh]h nj_c^bafZ Ihe_lu \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb g_ bf_xl d k_dkmZevghklb gbdZdh]h hlghr_gby K_dkmZevgh_ `_ \ha[m`^_gb_ \hagbdeh \ j_amevlZl_ i_j_iheg_gby gb`g_]h wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h p_gljZ²\ kbem g_^hklZlhqghc ijhoh^bfhklb dZgZeh\ Ij :\l

ijhkgmeky hdhgqZl_evgh G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh wydmeypbb \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb g_ [ueh y hsmsZe ihdZeu\Zgb_ \ iha\hghqgbd_ b m^b\eyeky gZkdhevdh j_ZevgZ [ueZ dZjlbgZ khl\hj_ggZy jZamfhfª

DZd b \ kemqZ_ k FbjZg^hc aZibkb iheb]jZnZ m Jwg^b iheghklvx kh]eZkh\u\Zebkv k hibkZgb_f hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby <h \j_fy ljb^pZlbk_dmg^gh]h ijhf_`mldZ k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb hlf_q_ggh]h \lhjuf b lj_lvbf kb]gZeZfb gZ[ex^Zehkv m\_ebq_gb_ l_fiZ ^uoZgby Baf_jbl_evgh_ dhevph aZnbdkbjh\Zeh qlh \ wlhl i_jbh^ wj_dpby gZqZ\rZyky h^gh\j_f_ggh k ;>= nZahc ^hklb]eZ fZdkbfZevgh]h mjh\gy Bgl_j_kgh aZf_lblv qlh f_^e_ggh_ mf_gvr_gb_ i_gbkZ gZqZehkv kjZam ihke_ hj]ZafZ

<h \j_fy hj]ZafZ m Jwg^b lZd `_ dZd b m FbjZg^u g_ gZ[ex^Zehkv agZqbl_evghc Zdlb\baZpbb k_j^_qghc ^_yl_evghklb Ih^\h^y blh] fh`gh kdZaZlv qlh h[Z wdki_jbf_glZ ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb koh`_klv nbabheh]bq_kdbo j_Zdpbc hj]ZgbafZ \h \j_fy hj]ZafZ \h kg_ Hkh[_ggh ohjhrh wlh ijhy\eyehkv \ \hajZklZgbb l_fiZ ^uoZgby m h[hbo bkiulm_fuo KZfuf ]eZ\guf \u\h^hf fh`_l klZlv ml\_j`^_gb_ h lhf qlh hj]Zaf \h kg_ hdZau\Z_l lZdh_ `_ kbevgh_ \ebygb_ gZ l_eh kiys_]h dZd b j_Zevguc

KijZ\_^eb\hklv wlh]h ml\_j`^_gby \hafh`gh hlghkbl_evgZ _keb mqblu\Zlv jZaebqgu_ lbiu kgh\b^p_\ b jZaebqgu_ ijhy\e_gby k_dkmZevghc Zdlb\ghklb H^gbf ba \Z`guo iheh\uo jZaebqbc fh`_l klZlv gZijbf_j lh qlh \h \j_fy k\h_]h hj]ZafZ FbjZg^Z bkiulu\ZeZ khdjZs_gb_ \Z]bgZevguo furp lh]^Z dZd m Jwg^b g_ gZ[ex^Zehkv khhl\_lkl\mxs_]h khdjZs_gby furp lZaZ Hlkmlkl\b_ wydmeypbb m Jwg^b g_kfhljy gZ yjdh_ __ hsms_gb_ iheghklvx kh\iZ^Z_l k fhbfb i_j_`b\Zgbyfb ih^h[gh]h jh^Z Kj_^b ijb[ebabl_evgh ^_\ylbkhl aZibk_c fhbo ebqguo hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc fh`gh hlukdZlv hdheh ^x`bgu hibkZgbc hj]ZafZ \ gbo <k_ wlb i_j_`b\Zgby khijh\h`^Zeh yjdh_ hsms_gb_ wydmeypbb ² gZklhevdh yjdh_ qlh h[uqgh \e_deh aZ kh[hc eh`gh_ ijh[m`^_gb_ \ dhlhjhf y dZaZehkv ijhkuiZeky ihke_ ³fhdjh]h´ kgZ H^gZdh ijhkgm\rbkv j_Zevgh y h[gZjm`b\Ze qlh hrb[Zeky

«GZrb ^Zggu_ [ueb ihemq_gu \ j_amevlZl_ lhevdh h^gh]h bkke_^h\Zgby k ijb\e_q_gb_f ^\mo bkiulm_fuo ihwlhfm ijb ^Zevg_cr_c bo bgl_jij_lZpbb g_h[oh^bfZ hij_^_e_ggZy hklhjh`ghklv L_f g_ f_g__ y jbkdgm aZdexqblv qlh k_dkmZevgZy Zdlb\ghklv b i_j_`b\Zgb_ hj]ZafZ \h \j_fy hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby \uau\Zxl \ hj]Zgbaf_ nbabheh]bq_kdb_ baf_g_gby hq_gv koh`b_ k l_fb qlh ijhbkoh^yl \h \j_fy ih^h[ghc Zdlb\ghklb \ khklhygbb [h^jkl\h\Zgbyª > @DZd bgl_jij_lbjh\Zlv ^Zggh_ khh[s_gb_" Ijbau\ d hklhjh`ghklb \ \u\h^Zo \ ihke_^g_f Z[aZp_ \iheg_ mf_kl_g >\h_ ^Z`_ ljh_ bkiulm_fuo ² wlh _s_ g_ klZlbklbdZ H^gZdh [he__ ihoh`bf gZ j_Zevgh_ iheh`_gb_ \ wlhc h[eZklb ij_^klZ\ey_lky kh^_j`Zgb_ i_j\h]h Z[aZpZ pblZlu : lZd dZd ^ey `_gsbg i_j_iheg_gb_ gb`g_]h p_gljZ wg_j]b_c b ihke_^mxsbc __ hj]Zafbq_kdbc \u[jhk g_ y\eyxlky klhev ³nZlZevgufb´ dZd ^ey fm`qbg ² hgb l_jyxl ebrv e_]dh b [ukljh \hkklZgZ\eb\Z_fmx lhgdhwg_j]_lbq_kdmx dhfihg_glm Z g_ iehlghwg_j]_lbq_kdmx²iheh\u_ de_ldb lh \k_fm wlhfm bkke_^h\Zl_eb b g_ ijb^Zeb [hevrh]h agZq_gby

Ihq_fm `_ m EZ[_j`Z b g_dh_]h Jwg^b g_ \hagbdZeh wydmeypbb" Hl\_l gZ wlhl \hijhk fh`_l ihdZaZlvky g_ kh\k_f m[_^bl_evguf gh ^jm]h]h fg_ \ ]heh\m ihdZ g_ ijbreh H[jZlbl_ \gbfZgb_ qlh \k_ ³hg_cjhgZ\lu´dZd bo bf_gm_l K EZ[_j` ^ey lh]h qlh[u h[jZlblv gZ wlh \gbfZgb_ gZ^h ijhqblZlv dhg_qgh \kx _]h dgb]m gbdh]^Z g_ ijbf_gyeb gbdZdbo hqbklbl_evguo ijZdlbd ^ey ^hklb`_gby kihkh[ghklb d hkhagZgghfm kgh\b^_gbx Lh _klv wlh ex^b bagZqZevgh hl jh`^_gby bf_xsb_ g_h[uqgh qbklmx hlebqgmx hl klZg^Zjlgh \klj_qZxs_cky wg_j]_lbdm

<kihfgbf lh]h `_ DZklZg_^m <_^v ^hg OmZg \aye \ mq_gbdb g_ i_j\h]h ihiZ\r_]hky _fm gZ mebp_ q_eh\_dZ >hg OmZg kZf h[tykgbe DZklZg_^_ qlh lhl ² _^bgkl\_gguc ba \k_o \klj_qZ\rboky _fm ex^_c ih^oh^ysbc ^ey mq_gbq_kl\Z \ kbem k\h_c wg_j]_lbq_kdhc dhgnb]mjZpbb B ih djZcg_c f_j_ km^y ih gZibkZgghfm bf \ dgb]Zo DZklZg_^Z lh`_ g_ bkiulu\Ze ijh[e_f k i_j_iheg_gb_f gb`g_]h wg_j]_lbq_kdh]h p_gljZ \h \j_fy hkhagZgguo kgh\b^_gbc ;he__ lh]h \k_ khjZlgbdb ^hgZ OmZgZ h[eZ^Z\rb_ ³\b^_gb_f´ ² ijyfuf \hkijbylb_f wg_j]bc \k_e_gghc qlh ZgZeh]bqgh hldjulhfm ³lj_lv_fm ]eZam´ beb ³lhgdhfm aj_gbx´ ² kqblZeb DZklZg_^m lh`_ ³\b^ysbf´ ijbq_f k kZfh]h gZqZeZ _]h mq_gbq_kl\Z Lh qlh hg \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb g_ ³\b^_e´ [ueh dZdbf lh kljZgguf ^_n_dlhf _]h ikbobdb Z g_ wg_j]_lbq_kdhc kbkl_fu hl\_qZxs_c aZ lZdh_ \hkijbylb_ H^gbf keh\hf DZklZg_^Z [ue mgbdZe_g G_ljm^gh ij_^iheh`blv qlh b agZdhfu_³hg_cjhgZ\lu´Klb\_gZ EZ[_j`Z b hg kZf²lh`_ ih k\h_fm mgbdZevgu >Z b \ kZfhf ^_e_ qZklh \u \klj_qZeb beb ohly [u keurZeb h ih^h[gh]h jh^Z ³hg_cjhgZ\lZo´" Hq_\b^gh lZdb_ ex^b \klj_qZxlky djZcg_ j_^dh Hgb m`_ ihqlb qlh ijhk\_le_ggu_ Bf ^h kly`Zgby K\ >moZ ² iZjZ rZ]h\ <ky [_^Z lhevdh \ lhf qlh hgb kZfb h[ wlhf g_ ^h]Z^u\Zxlky

Qlh[u m`_ kh\k_f ihdhgqblv k wlbf gZ^h khh[sblv ke_^mxs__ Y h[ wlhf kemqZ_ \_jg__ ² kemqZyo kh\_jr_ggh aZ[ue b lhevdh l_i_jv \kihfgbe dh]^Z kgh\Z i_j_qblZe wlb hlq_lu Ijb[ebabl_evgh m`_ ihke_e_l aZgylbc aZ^_j`dhc ^uoZgby m f_gy [md\Zevgh ih^jy^ k bgl_j\Zehf g_ [hevr_ f_kypZ ² lhqgh g_ ihfgx ² [ueh ^\Z kgZ h[uqguo \ dhlhjuo y wydmebjh\Ze Ih dZdhc lh ijbqbg_ g_ ihfgx gh kZf nZdl wydmeypbb [ue gZklhevdh yjhd b hq_\b^_g qlh y \ m`Zk_ f]gh\_ggh ijhkuiZeky ?keb g_ ykgh ihq_fm \ m`Zk_ ² ihykgyx ^ey f_gy m`_ fgh]h e_l wydmeypby \ ex[hf [h^jkl\mxs_f beb kiys_f khklhygbb y\ey_lky kh\_jr_ggh g_^himklbfuf b fh`gh kdZaZlv aZij_s_gguf kh[ulb_f QI lZd kdZaZlv dhkfbq_kdh]h fZkrlZ[Z Ihwlhfm h[Z jZaZ y ijhkuiZeky \ ³oheh^ghf ihlm´ b k m`Zkhf gZqbgZe hsmiu\Zlv k_[y b ihkl_ev \ ihbkdZo mljZq_gghc ^jZ]hp_gghc `b^dhklb H]h\hjxkv qlh ^_eZe y wlh g_ ba ijZa^gh]h ex[hiulkl\Z Z ih ijb\uqd_ hklZ\r_cky k l_o \j_f_g dh]^Z _s_ lZdb_ bklhjbb kemqZebkv >_eh \ lhf qlh _keb m` \u \k_ lZdb ihl_jyeb k_fy lh _]h gZ^h g_f_^e_ggh kh[jZlv b \l_j_lv k_[_ \ dh`m DklZlb ]h\hjy hgh ihqlb fhf_glZevgh \iblu\Z_lky LZdbf h[jZahf \u \_jg_l_ \ hj]Zgbaf ohly [u qZklv mljZq_gghc wg_j]bb

Gh ihbkdb aZ\_jrbebkv gbq_f Baebrg_ ]h\hjblv qlh bamfe_gbx fh_fm g_ [ueh ij_^_eZ

Y ^hklb] d lhfm \j_f_gb ^hklZlhqgh]h fZkl_jkl\Z qlh[u kmf_lv ij_^hl\jZlblv ex[hc hj]Zaf kemqZxsbcky dZd \ ijhklhf lZd b \ hkhagZgghf kgh\b^_gbb B y \k_]^Z hklZgZ\eb\Ze gZjZklZxs__ \ha[m`^_gb_ ohly wlh b \_eh ih djZcg_c f_j_ \ kemqZ_ hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby d ijh[m`^_gbx < ^Zgghf kemqZ_ hq_\b^gh wlh [ue lhl lbi djZcg_ j_^dh \klj_qZxs_]hky \h kg_ hj]ZafZ dhlhjuc gZklmiZ_l dZd [u kjZam f]gh\_ggh [_ah \kydh]h ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]h \ha[m`^_gby

LZdhc lbi hj]ZafZ fg_ lh`_ [ue ba\_kl_g jZg__ b hg ^_ckl\bl_evgh qj_a\uqZcgh dh\Zj_g Y iheZ]Zx qlh ij_^\Zjbl_evgh_ \ha[m`^_gb_ _klv \k_ lZdb b \ wlhf kemqZ_ gh ijhklh hgh ijhbkoh^bl g_ \ nZa_ ;>= kgZ Z \ nZa_ G;=> AZ\_jr_gb_ `_ \ha[m`^_gby ihiZ^Z_l \ gZqZ\rmxky nZam ;>= kgZ hlq_]h kha^Z_lky \i_qZle_gb_ qlh hj]Zaf ihy\beky³gbhldm^Z´ HklZgh\blv _]h iheghklvx _keb hg m`_ gZqZeky ijZdlbq_kdb g_\hafh`gh ?^bgkl\_ggh_ qlh _s_ fh`gh mki_lv k^_eZlv wlh fbgbfbabjh\Zlv ihl_jx k_f_gb gh ^ey wlh]h gZ^h f]gh\_ggh gZ mjh\g_ j_ne_dkZ gZqZlv ^_eZlv mijZ`g_gb_³[hevrh_ \uly]b\Zgb_´

>ey iheghlu b ³gZmqghklb´ dZjlbgu gZ^h m` b aZ\_jrblv wlm deZkkbnbdZpbx <klj_qZ_lky _s_ h^bg lbi hj]ZafZ iheghklvx g_

NZaZ kgZ [_a kgh\b^_gbc

ihiZ^Zxsbc \ nZam kgZ kh kgh\b^_gbyfb Hj]Zafhf _]h gZa\Zlv fh`gh ebrv mkeh\gh lZd dZd gbdZdbo hsms_gbc ijb wlhf kiysbc g_ bkiulu\Z_l b gbdZdbo \hkihfbgZgbc g_ bf__l Hg kihdhcgh kibl ^Zevr_ Z mljhf beb dh]^Z ijhkg_lky k m^b\e_gb_f h[gZjm`b\Z_l h[jZah\Z\rmxky em`m K wlbf lbihf iheexpbb gbdZdbfb ³hi_jZlb\gufb´ f_lh^Zfb [hjhlvky g_\hafh`gh D kqZklvx hg \klj_qZ_lky g_ qZs_ q_f ij_^u^msbc lbi

LZdbf h[jZahf \ha\jZsZykv d wlbf ^\mf kemqZyf y ijhklh g_ mki_e kj_Z]bjh\Zlv gZ gZqZ\rmxky wydmeypbx \h kg_ Gh y b ij_^klZ\blv k_[_ g_ fh] h kemqZyo ba dgb]b EZ[_j`Z y d lhfm \j_f_gb ^Z\gh aZ[ue qlh hj]Zaf b wydmeypby i_j_`blu_ \h kg_ fh]ml g_ ih\e_qv ZgZeh]bqguo kh[ulbc \ nbabq_kdhf l_e_ B l_f g_ f_g__ wlh nZdl

Ih\lhjyx _s_ jZa y \kihfgbe h[h \k_f wlhf lhevdh ijhqblZ\ _s_ jZa wibah^ ba gZa\Zgghc dgb]b B l_i_jv m`_ m f_gy ihy\bebkv g_dhlhju_ khfg_gby \hl dZdh]h jh^Z <_^v y \k_]^Z hklZgZ\eb\Ze wydmeypbx \h kg_ g_\Z`gh h[uqghf beb hkhagZgghf Gh _keb ih ^hklb`_gbb g_dhlhjhc kl_i_gb hqbs_gghklb ihkj_^kl\hf ijZdlbdb aZ^_j`db ^uoZgby hdZaZehkv \hafh`guf wydmebjh\Zlv \h kg_ g_ l_jyy ijb wlhf gb dZieb k_f_gb \ nbabq_kdhf fbj_ g_ hagZqZ_l eb wlh qlh y ijhklh ihgZijZkgm ij_ju\Ze k\hb hkhagZggu_ kgh\b^_gby hklZgZ\eb\Zy wydmeypbx" Ijhs_ ]h\hjy fh`_l [ulv y m`_ lh]^Z ^hklb] lhc `_ kihkh[ghklb dZdhc h[eZ^Ze EZ[_j` kh k\hbfb³hg_cjhgZ\lZfb´"

Hl\_l gZ wlhl \hijhk l_i_jv m`_ g_ magZlv ^Z \ dhgp_ dhgph\ wlh b g_ \Z`gh <_^v ^Z`_ [_a ihl_jb nbabq_kdhc dhfihg_glu ² iheh\uo de_lhd²]_gblZevguc hj]Zaf gbq_]h ohjhr_]h ba k_[y g_ ij_^klZ\ey_l < ex[hf kemqZ_ b fm`qbgZ b `_gsbgZ ijb ]_gblZevghf hj]Zaf_ l_jyxl lhgdhwg_j]_lbq_kdmx dhfihg_glm k\h_]h k_f_gb ² hgZ jZkoh^m_lky gZ kZfh hsms_gb_ b khdjZs_gb_ furp Kh\k_f ^jm]h_ ^_eh ² hj]Zaf \k_]h l_eZ beb ^hebgguc hj]Zaf dZd _]h bf_gm_l FZglZd >ay Wlh ² ^_ckl\bl_evgh ihe_aguc hj]Zaf Ihlhfm qlh b^_l [_a ml_qdb wg_j]bb Gh h[ wlhf j_qv \ ^jm]hf f_kl_

;he__ j_Zevghc kblmZpby \u]ey^bl k `_gsbgZfb Fu m`_ jZah[jZebkv dZd \u ihfgbl_ k l_f qlh h[uqghc `_gsbg_ gZdhiblv wg_j]bx e_]q_ q_f h[uqghfm fm`qbg_ Ihwlhfm _keb `_gsbgZ \_^_l qbkluc h[jZa `bagb g_ bf__l \j_^guo ijb\uq_d b `b\_l \ lbohc kihdhcghc h[klZgh\d_ ]^_ gb[m^v gZ ijbjh^_ g_ bkiulu\Zy hkh[uo nbabq_kdbo gZ]jmahd Z \ :f_jbd_ lZdbo \hafh`ghkl_c fgh]h wlh g_ lh qlh `bagv \ jhkkbckdhc ^_j_\g_ hgZ \iheg_ fh`_l gZdhiblv wg_j]bx ^hklZlhqgmx ^ey ijbh[j_l_gby hkhagZgghklb \h kg_ Ijb wlhf y\e_gbb dZd y m`_ ]h\hjbe gZqbgZ_lky ijhp_kk [mjgh]h \u^_e_gby wg_j]bb ba hkgh\gh]h j_a_j\mZjZ b _keb fbdjhdhkfbq_kdZy hj[blZ aZ[ehdbjh\ZgZ beb ^Z`_ ijhklh g_^hklZlhqgh ijhqbs_gZ hj]Zaf q_j_a [hevrbc beb f_gvrbc ijhf_`mlhd \j_f_gb ijZdlbq_kdb g_ba[_`_g Gh ^ey `_gsbgu lZdZy kblmZpby hkh[h gbq_f g_ ]jhabl ² wlh ebrv g_ [he__ q_f ijbylgh_ ijbdexq_gb_ Hlkx^Z lZd fgh]h ih keh\Zf EZ[_j`Z lZdbo gZ[ex^_gbc kj_^b `_gsbg kgh\b^ysbo >Z b \hh[s_ km^y ih \k_fm `_gsbg kj_^b kgh\b^ysbo ]hjZa^h [hevr_ q_f fm`qbg

Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky fh_c kdjhfghc ebqghklb lh kh\_jr_ggh hq_\b^gh qlh gb gZ dZdmx g_hj^bgZjghklv b mgbdZevghklv y ij_l_g^h\Zlv g_ fh]m < wg_j]_lbq_kdhf kfuke_ y kh\_jr_ggh aZmjy^_g dZd gZ\_jgh_ b \ ex[hf ^jm]hf Gh \ wlhf _klv b k\h_ ij_bfms_kl\h fhc hiul fh`_l hdZaZlvky ihe_aguf ^ey ^jm]bo ijhkluo b h[uqguo ex^_c Ex^b `_ mgbdZevgu_ eb[h \hh[s_ g_ gm`^Zxlky \ qm`hf hiul_ eb[h kZfb jZa[_jmlky \ k\hbo ijh[e_fZo Beb g_ jZa[_jmlky Gh wlh m`_ bo ljm^ghklb

BlZd fg_ ij_^klhyeh j_rblv ijh[e_fm k k_f_g_f DZd g_ ljm^gh aZf_lblv j_r_gb_ ^he`gh [ueh bf_lv ^\Z Zki_dlZ ijbgpbibZevguc

: kdhj__ ^Z`_ b j_`_²g_ qZs_ jZaZ \ ²]h^Z ih fhbf gZ[ex^_gbyf Gh wlb ^Zggu_ fh]ml \Zjvbjh\Zlvky \ aZ\bkbfhklb hl bg^b\b^mZevguo hkh[_gghkl_c b kl_i_gb hqbs_gghklb dZgZeh\

beb ^he]h\j_f_gguc b kbxfbgmlguc ² lZd kdZaZlv kjhqguc IjbgpbibZevgh j_rblv \hijhk fh`gh lhevdh aZ kq_l hqbs_gby fbdjhdhkfbq_kdhc hj[blu hl [ehdbjh\hd²gh y \ lh \j_fy ij_^klZ\eye k_[_ wlh [he__ q_f kfmlgh _keb \hh[s_ ij_^klZ\eye Kbxfbgmlgmx ijh[e_fm ba[Z\e_gby hl ihl_jv wg_j]bb \f_kl_ k k_f_g_f j_rblv fh`gh [ueh lhevdh gZmqb\rbkv dhgljhebjh\Zlv wydmeypbx

<hijhk h j_r_gbb aZ^Zqb \he_\h]h \oh`^_gby \ khklhygb_ hkhagZggh]h kgh\b^_gby \ wlhc kblmZpbb ^Z`_ g_ klhye ² ^h lZdbo eb \_jrbg lhfm dlh g_ fh`_l j_rblv [he__ kdjhfgu_ ijh[e_fu Gh _]h j_r_gb_ dZd fh`gh ^h]Z^Zlvky kh\iZ^Z_l k j_r_gb_f ijh[e_fu wydmeypbb \ ijbgpbibZevghf kfuke_²lhevdh hqbs_gb_f

K_cqZk fg_ \k_ wlh ykgh dZd [_euc ^_gv < lh \j_fy h[_ ijh[e_fu ij_^klZ\eyebkv fg_ g_jZaj_rbfufb Y ihgylby g_ bf_e qlh fh`gh k^_eZlv : lml _s_ b ³kmijm`_kdbc ^he]´KZfh kh[hc fghx h\eZ^_\Zeh lboh_ hlqZygb_

Gh g_jZaj_rbfuo kblmZpbc g_ [u\Z_l >Z b =hkih^v fbehklb\ Hkh[_ggh d l_f dlh aZ[hlblky h ^hklb`_gbb PZjkl\by G_[_kgh]h ³Bsbl_ `_ ij_`^_ PZjkl\Z ;h`by b ijZ\^u ?]h b wlh \k_ ijbeh`blky \Zf´Fn