Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018

CTBa, H eyp~cKHif Bonpoc HBJULJIOI HeoneMJieMoif ee qacTbIO. Cp~H np~­

JIO)l(eHHH no pa3perneHHIO KOHcpJIHKTa 6hvm:

•OTMeHa CMepTHOH Ka3HH 3a cenapaTH3M;

•H3MeHeHHe «3aKOHa 0 TeppopH3Me»;

•11eraJIH3au;HH eyp~cKoro H3hIKa B qacTHhIX CMl1, a TaK)l(e B03MO)l(- HOCTh o6yqeHHH Ha HeM B Herocy~apCTBeHHbIX lliKOJiax (o~HaKO npeMO- )l(eHHe o np~aHHH eMy cTaryca BToporo rocy~apcTBeHHoro H3hIKa 6hmo

oTBeprHYTO. KpoMe 3Toro, y eyp~OB He 6hmo pecypcoB ~ cpHHaHcHpoBa-

HHH qacTHhIX TeJieKaHaJIOB, a HcnoJib30BaHHe eyp~cKoro H3hIKa Ha rocy~ap­ CTBeHHhIX KaHaJiax He np~cMaTpHBaJIOCh);

•cMJirqeHHe 3aKOHOB 0 ~eMOHCTpa:u;HHX (B ~eHCTBHTeJibHOCTH HCnOJIHeHO He 6bIJIO, TaK KaK nonbITKH 03B)"IHTb aHTHnpaBHTeJihCTBeHHbie JI03yHrH KapaJIHCb pa3rOHOM MaHHcpecTaQHH, KaK npOH30IJ1JIO B 2008 r. Br. BaH);

•o6'bHBJieHHeaMHHCTHH 6oeBHKaM PIIK (He 6bmo BhIIlOJIHeHo). TaKHM o6pa30M, H3 MHoroo6em;arom;eif nporpaMMhI no ypery11Hp0Ba-

HHIO KOHcpJIHKTa 6oJihlliHHCTBO nyttKTOB JIH6o 6bmH qacTHqHo BbIIlOJIHeHbI, JIH6o He BbIIlOJIHeHbI B006m;e, JIH6o BbIIlOJIHeHhI, HO OK333JIHCb KpaifHe He3cpcpeKTHBHbIMH. EBponeifCKaH KOMHCCHH, npH3B3HHaH KOHTpOJIHpOBaTh npou;ecc ~eMoKpaTH3aQHH, 3aMeqa11a He~opa6oTKH TYPeu;Koro npaBHTeJih-

CTBa. TeM He MeHee B CBOHX oTqeTax OHa B QeJIOM OTMeqaJia n03HTHBHYIO ~HHaMHKY KOHcpJIHKTa, HO B TO )Ke BpeMH npe~11ara11a pH~ Mep no ycoBeprneHCTBOBaHHIO CHCTeMhI ~eMOKpaTH3aQHH (B qacTHOCTH, C03~3HHe

KYP~CKOro KOMHTeTa) H ~a)l(e ~eJiaJia HaMeKH 0 Heo6xo~HMOCTH BHeCeHHH nonpaBOK B KOHCTHTYQHIO, KOTOpa5I npH3HaJia 6bI MHOroHaQHOH3JlbHbIH

CTaryc rocy~apcTBa.

O~HaKo Typu;HH He cnernHJia BhmOJIHHTh Tpe6oBaHHH EBpOKOMHCCHH, a npOTHBOpeqHBOCTb TaKOH noJIHTHKH TOJibKO npo~eMOHCTpHpOBaJia ee 6ecnepcneKTHBHOCTh1.

B03MO)l(HO, CaMa H~e.H TaKHX pecpopMaQHH CTaJia OIJ1H6KOH Ilapnm cnpaBeMHBOCTH H pa3BHTHH, KOTOpaH, cy~ no BCeMy, XOTeJia npo~OJl)l(HTb

TY )Ke Hau;HoHaJihHYIO noJIHTHKY no~ B~OM MHHHMaJibHhIX ~eMoKpaTHqe­

CKHX H3MeHeHHH, qTo6hI yqeCTb 3aMeqaHH5l EBpOCOI03a.

O~HaKo Tor~a npaBHI:QHH pe)l(IIM em;e He no~o3peBaJI, qTo EC TaK)l(e Be~eT IIrpy II BOBCe He )l(~eT BCTyn11eHII5l Typ:QIIII B COI03, a Heo6xo~II­

MOCTb II3MeHeHIIH npIIHQIInOB BHelliHeH noJIIITIIKII - TOJibKO npe~Jior ~JIH Toro, qT06bI XOTb KaK-TO 060.HCHIITb 33THrIIBaHIIe neperoBopoB

0 BcrynJieHIIII.

11MeHHO no3TOMY 11~epb1 IICP, noo6em;aB npaBa II CBo6o~hI, HO He c~ep­ )l(aB o6em;aHHH, C3MII o6peKJIII ce6.H Ha ~aJihHeifrnyro KOHcppoHTaQIIIO c Kyp-

~aMII, KOTOpbie Tenepb Ha BnOJIHe 33KOHHbIX OCHOBaHHHX MOrJIII 3aHBAATb 0 HeCOCTOHTeJibHOCTII noJIIITIIKII npIIlli~llieH K BJiaCTII IICP. no CYTII, rpoM-

KIIe 3aHBJieHIIH npaBHI:Qeif napTIIII B caMOM HaqaJie npaBJieHIIH pa3BH3aJIII pyKII npe~cTaBIITeJIHM Kyp~cKoif HaQIIII, KOTOphre aKTIIBHO BKJiroqaJIIICh

1 AsamKoB B. A. Kyp,11cKaH rrpo6JieMa ...

181

B nomnHqecKHH: npou;ecc, a cyiu;ecTBeHHoro nporpecca B perneHHH Hau;HoHaJihHoro Bonpoca TaK H He 6bmO ,ll;OCTHrIIyro.

KypACKMM sonpoc 1rt cospeMeHHOCTb

KaK }')Ke6bmo OTMeqeHO, B HaIIIH ,ll;HH MaJIO qTO H3MeHHJIOCb: zypeu;KoKJ'P,ll;CKHHKOH<l>JIHKT no-npe:>1rneMy He yperyJIHpoBaH, ,n;eHTeJibHOCTh Pa6oqeH: napTHH Kyp,n;HcTaHa 3anperu;eHa H ofrhHBJieHa TeppopHCTHqecKoH:, B Ka:>K,ll;OM COBeprneHHOM TeppopHCTHqecKOM aKTe npaBHTeJibCTBO o6BHHJieT Kyp,n;oB, a nepcneKTHBa MHpHoro COBMeCTHoro cocyru;ecTBOBaHHJI ,n;Byx Hapo,n;oB ,n;aJieKa OT peaJihHOCTH. KpoMe 3Toro, HeperneHHbIH KYPACKHH Bonpoc o6ocTpHeT He TOJibKO BHyrpHnOJIHTHqecKy10 o6cTaHoBKy, HO H n03HI.J;HH Typu;HH Ha MHpOBOH apeHe.

Cero,n;HJI KJ'P,ll;CKaJInpo6JieMa CTaJia KaMHeM npeTKHOBeHHJI B OTHOIIIeHHJIX Typu;mf c pJIAOM cTpaH. HanpHMep, HMeIOTCJI npoTHBopeqHJI c rJiaBHhIM COI03HHKOM Typu;HH no HATO - Coe,n;HHeHHhIMH IlITaTaMH AMepHKH, KOTOpbie OKa3bIBaIOT aKTHBHyIO BOeHHyIO nOMep:>Key I<yp,ll;aM H HCKpeHHe 3aHHTepecoBaHbI B o6pa3oBaHHH e,n;11Horo Kyp,n;11cTaHa, qTo o6ocTpHeT HX ,ll;BYCTOpOHHHe OTHOIIIeHHJI CTpaH. TiocJie KpH3HCa Me:>K,n;y MOCKBOH 11 A1IKapoH: B 2015 r. PoccHH TaK:>Ke HaqaJia coTpy,n;HHqecTBO c npe,n;cTaBHTeJIHMH Kyp,n;cKHx oTpJIAOB. B nocJie,n;Hee BpeMH o6ocTpIDIHCh OTHOIIIeHHH Typeu;KoH: Pecny6JIHKH He TOJihKO c zypeu;KHMH, Ho 11 c c11pHHCKHM11 KYP-

,n;aMH.

Typu;mi: Bcepbe3 o6ecnoKoeHa qpe3MepHoH: aKTHBHOCTbIO noCJieAHHX - OHH Be,n;yr 6oeBb1e ,n;eH:cTBHJI B paMKax rpa:>K,ll;aHCKOH BOHHhI B C11p11H:cKoH: Apa6cKoH: Pecny6JI11Ke. Tipe:>K,n;e Bcero Typeu;KaH Pecny6JIHKa onacaeTCH KOHCTHTYI.J;HOHHOro 3aKpenJieHHJI aBTOHOMHOro CTaTyca CHpHHCKOro Kyp,n;HcTaHa no aHaJiorHH c TeM, KaK 3TO npOH30IIIJIO B 11paKe B 2005 r. Ho caMoe nJioxoe, qTo MO:>KeT npOH30HTH .n;M Typu;HH B TaKHX ycJIOBHJIX, - co3,n;aHHe e,n;HHoro Kyp,n;HcTaHa, a 3HaqHT - HeMHHyeMaH noTepH qacTH rocy,n;apCTBeHHbIX npHrpaHHqHbIX TeppHTOpHH.

3TOT :>Ke BOnpoc 6ecnoKOHT H npaBHTeJibCTBa KaK CHpHH, TaK H 11paHa, Be,n;b OHH, KaK H Typu;HH, B paBHOH CTeneHH He 3aHHTepecoBaHbl B ofrbe,n;H- HeHHH 1<yp,n;cKHX Hapo,n;oB. Tipe3ffAeHT Typu;HH P. T. 3p,n;oraH oco3HaJI, qTo B CBJl3H c 60JibIIIHM KOJIHqecTBOM 11rpoKOB, 3aHHTepecoBaHHblX B KJ'P,ll;CKOM Bonpoce, 6e3 aKTHBHbIX ,n;eHCTBHH Typu;HH CHryau;HJI MO:>KeT OKOHqaTeJibHO BbIHTH H3-no,n; ee KOHTPOJIJI. 11 ecJIH paHbIIIe OT peIIIHTeJibHblX ,n;eHCTBHH pecny6JIHKY c,n;ep:>KHBaJia no3HI.J;HJI CIIIA B 3TOM Bonpoce, TO Tenepb, Kor,n;a rocy,n;apcTBO CTpeMHTeJibHO OT,ll;aJIHeTCJI OT 3ana,n;a, cy,n;H no npOTHBopeqHBbIM ,n;eH:cTBHHM zypeu;Koro pyKOBO,ll;CTBa, MHeHHe napTHepa no HATO He CHJibHO HHTepecyeT pyKOBO,ll;CTBO CTpaHbl.

B CBOHX ,n;eH:cTBHHX Typeu;KaH Pecrry6JIHKa pernmrn npH,n;ep:>KHBaThCJI TOH :>Ke CTpaTerHH, qTo H B HaqaJie 90-x rr. xx B., pernaJI CBOH BOnpOCbl nyreM BOOp)')KeHHblXCTOJIKHOBeHHH. TaK, B 2015 r., no,n; npe,n;JIOrOM BOeHHOH no,n;roTOBKH 1<yp,n;cKHx <PopMHpoBaHHH, oKa3hrna10ru;Hx conpoTHBJieHHe

182

3anpe~eHHOH B Pocc1rn 11fl1JI, TypQllil BBeJia soH:cKa B 11paK, 'ITOHa ,n;e.ne orpaHHtJHJIOCb TOJibKO TIOCTO.flHHbIMH aTaKaMH npOTHB Kyp,ll;OB H Bbl3BaJIO HeraTHBttylO pea~HIO B MHpe KaK CJle,ll;CTBHe.

B KOHQe JieTa 6hlJia HatJaTa ,n;pyra.fl BOeHHa.fl onepaQH.fl - «111,HT EB<l>paTa», QeJihIO KOTopoH: CTaJIH }')KecHpHHCKHe Kyp,ll;hI. TaKHM o6pa3oM, B HaCTO.fl~ee BpeM.fl TypQllil npHH.flJia perneHHe H,ll;TH npOTHB BCex, OKa3blBa.fl ,n;aBJieHHe Ha Kyp,ll;OB H, B qacTHocrn, Ha PTIK nocpe,n;cTBOM ,n;eMOHCTpa-

QHH soeHHOH CHJibI. B OTBeT Ha 3TO Pa6otJM napTllil Kyp,n;HcTaHa Hepe,n;Ko opraHH3yeT TeppopHCTH'IeCKHeaKThl, TIO,ll;pbIBaIO~He CTa6H..1IbHOCTb BHyTpH CTpaHhI H HanpaBJieHHbie, KaK npaBHJIO, nponrn ,n;eH:crnyro~eH: BJiaCTH H rocy,n;apCTBeHHbIX opraHOB.

B yCJIOBllilX, Kor,n;a MHpOBhie CMl1 BpeM.fl OT BpeMeHH ny6JIHKYJOT cse- ,n;eHllil o HOBhIX y,n;apax TypQHH no no3HQH.flM Kyp,ll;OB, a npe3H,n;eHT cTpaHbI YKPeTIJI.fleT HCJiaMcKHe QeHHOCTH Hap.fl,ll;y c QeHTpaJIH3aQHeH: BJiacTH BHYTPH CTpaHbI, roBOpHTb 0 CKOpOM pa3perneHHH KOH<l>JIHKTa, OtJeBH,ll;HO, npe)K,ll;eBpeMeHHO. 0TTeCHeHHe Kyp,ll;OB OT rocy,n;apCTBeHHOH rpaHHQbl He pernaeT npo6JieMhI, KOTOPM no-npe:i1rneMY OCTaeTC.fl O,ll;HOH H3 Ba:>KHeHIIIHX B TypeQKOM o6~eCTBe. TipaBHTeJibCTBO TypQHH IlbITaeTC.fl OTJIO:lKHTb Kyp,ll;CKHH Bonpoc, perneHHe KOTOporo eCJIH H eCTb, TO Tpe6yeT MHOro CHJI, BpeMeHH H ycTYflOK, KaK c o6eHx cTopoH.

E,ll;HHCTBeHHhIM perneHHeM, KoTopoe y,n;osJieTBopHJio 6b1 H TYPeQKoe npaBHTeJihCTBO, H Kyp,n;oB, .flBJI.fleTC.fl C03,ll;aHHe Kyp,n;cKoro rocy,n;apCTBa 3a npe,n;eJiaMH TypQMM. 0,n;HaKo 3TO HeB03MO:lKHO: ,n;a:lKe ecJIM roBOpHTh 06 o6he,n;MHeHHOM Kyp,n;McTaHe, TO TeppMTOpMaJibHhie noTepM 6y,n;YT HeM36e:lKHhI ,ll;Jl.fl Bcex perMOHaJihHbIX CTOpOH KOH<l>JIMKTa, tJeMy He o6pa,n;yeTC.fl HM 11paH, HM CMpM.fl, KOTOpa.fl M TaK, BepORTHO, 6y,n;eT pa3,n;eJieHa B CJiyqae 3aBeprneHM.fl rpa)K,ll;aHcKoH: BOHHhI M c HaMMeHhrneH: cTeneHhIO BepoRTHoCTM cMo:lKeT coxpaHMTh yttMTapHbIH xapaKTep rocy,n;apcrna.

B TO :lKe BpeM.fl perneHMe Kyp,n;cKoro Bonpoca OCJIO)l(H.fleTC.fl TeM, 'ITO Kyp,ll;hI OTtJMHHO ,n;o6MBaIOTC.fl c03,n;aHM.fl e,ll;MHoro Kyp,n;McTaHa, HO npM 3TOM HMKTO He npe,n;CTaBJI.fleT, 'ITO3TO ,ll;OJl:lKHO 6bITb 3a rocy,n;apcTBO. KaK }')Ke OTMetJaJIOCb, y Kyp,ll;OB HeT e,n;MHOH COQMOKYJibTYPHOH OCHOBbl ,ll;Jl.fl ero C03- ,n;aHM.fl.

0,ll;HMM M3 perneHMH Bonpoca MOrJIM 6hI CTaTb nonpaBKM B ,n;eHCTBYJO-

~YIO KOHCTMTYQMIO TypeQKOH Pecny6JIMKM OTHOCMTeJibHO npe,n;oCTaBJieHM.fl HeKOTOpbIX eyJihTypHhIX npaB HaQMOHaJihHhIM MeHbIIIMHCTBaM, 'ITOMorno 6bI ycKOpHTb MMpOTBOptieCKMH npoQecc, O,ll;HaKO KOHCTMTYQllil H TaK BCKope 6y,n;eT M3MeHeHa, a OTIMCaHHbie BOTipOCbl 6y,n;~Me nonpaBKM He npe,n;ycMaTpMBaIOT.

B ,n;aHHbIH MOMeHT sapMaHTOB pa3perneHM.fl Kyp,ll;CKOro BOnpoca MO:lKeT 6hITb HeCKOJibKO. JIM6o Kyp,ll;bl npHMYT cy~eCTBYIO~ee TIOJIO:lKeHMe ,n;eJI, OCTaBMB 6oph6y 3a CBOM npaBa H, TeM 6oJiee, aBTOHOMHIO, 'ITOHeB03MO:lKHO

183

CoBpeMeHHaH BHYTITHIIOJIHTWiecKaH c11creMa 'fypQHH~HHaMH'!Ha 11 IIOk BepraeTCH H3MeHeHHHM Ka)l{,ll;blH ~eHb. 3JieMeHTbl 3TOH CHCTeMbl nepe)KHBaIOT TpaHccpopMaQHIO, Ha CMetty CTapbIM ttrpoKaM npHXOMT HOBbie. 3TH

Te~eHQHH oco6eHHO '!eTKOnpoCJie)KHBaIOTCJI Ha npHMepe IIOJIHTH'leCKHX napTttif. TaK, BJIHHHHe npoK)'p~CKoif ,ll;eMOKpaTtt'leCKOHnapTHH Hapo~oB,

KOTOpaH IIOCJie BbI6opoB JieTOM 2015 r., Ka3aJIOCb, CMO)KeT COCTaBHTb KOH- K)'peHQHIOHa BffYTPHIIOJIHTH'lecKoifapeHe TypQHH, no~ BJIHHHHeM npaBH- m;11x 3JIHT COKpaTHJIOCb Ha IIOPMOK, a HJIJII03HH 0 ee IIOJIHTH'leCKOHCHJie HC'!e3JiaTaK )Ke 6bICTpo, KaK H IIOHBHJiaCb.

B HaCTOHID;HH rrep110~ BHyrpeHHHJI IIOJIHTHKa TypQHH nepe)KHBaeT

KopeHHbie H3MeHeHHH, KOTOpbie, 6e3yCJIOBHO, IIOBJIHHIOT KaK Ha XO~ BHeIIIHeH IIOJIHTHKH, TaK H Ha IIOJIHTH'leCKHHCTpoif rocy~apCTBa, H, CJie~OBa­

TeJibHO, Ha )KJ13Hb T)'peQKOroo6m;ecTBa.

Cero~HJI OT npe)KHHX npaB H CB06o~ OCTaJIOCb MaJIO, 3IIOXY ~eMOKpa­

TH'leCKHXQeHHOCTeH MeHHeT KOHCepBaQHJI H IIOCTeneHHaH HCJiaMH3aQHJI o6m;ecTBa, KOTopaH aKTHBHO nponara~11pyeTCJI npaBHm;eif napTtteif cnpaBe~JIHBOCTH H pa3BHTirn H y)Ke ycneJia IIpOHHKHyYb ITO'!TlfBO Bee ccpepbl

o6m;ecTBeHHOH )KH3HH, BKJIIO'la.H3KOHOMHK)'.

Ee3aJihTepHaTHBHOCTh BHyrpeHHeif noJIHTHKH 11 KYPC Ha QeHTpaJitt3aQHIO BJiaCTH cym;eCTBeHHO orpaHH'lHJIHB IIOJIHTH'leCKOH)KJ13HH o6m;eCTBa pOJib apMHH, KOTOpaH Ha IIpOTH)KeHHH ~OJirHX JieT HBJIHJiaCb OCHOBHbIM QeHTpOM CHJibl, a Hey~aBIIIHHCJI nepeBopoT B HIOJie 2016 r. H HOBaH KOHCTHT)'- QHJI JIHIIIb cnoco6cTBYJOT ycKopeHHIO 3Toro npoQecca.

l-faMeHeHHe IIOJIHTH'leCKOrOKypca B 6JIH)KaHIIIHe ro~bl MO)KeT npott30HTH c HattMeHhrneif cTeneHbIO BepoHTHOCTH. Hao6opoT, cym;eCTBYJOID;Hif cTaT)'C-KBO,a BMeCTe c HHM 11 II03HQHH npe3~eHTa Pe~)Kena Taif11rra 3p~o­ raHa 6y~yr )'KpeIIJIJITbCJIc Ka)K~bIM ro~oM, 11 era no6e~a Ha pecpepe~YMe

0 BBe~eHHH KOHCTHT)'QHOHHbIXnonpaBOK BeCHOH 2017 r. - HarJIJI~Hoe TOMY no~TBep)K~eHtte. E~HHCTBeHHbIM npenJITCTBHeM MO)KeT CTaTb HJIH

BHeIIIHHll cpaKTOp, HJIH 3KOHOMH'!eCKOepa3BHTHe.

3a noCJie~Htte ro~hI TypeQKaH Pecny6JittKa cTaJia o~HHM 113 Ba)KHeifrn11x

Me)l{,ll;yttapo~HbIX HrpoKOB If cero~HJI Bbl3bIBaeT HHTepec MHOrHX perHOHOB Mttpa. 3a npoQeccaMH, npo11cxOMID;HMH B TypQHH, Ha6JIIO~aeT npaKTH'le-

CKH Bee MHpOBOe coo6m;ecTBO, Ha'lHHaHc MHpOBbIX ~ep)KaB H 3aKaH'lHBaH perHOHaJibHbIMH rocy~apCTBaMH oJIH)KHero BocTOKa. 11 XOTJI B IIOCJie~Hee BpeMJI TypQHH CTapaeTCJI yrBep~HTbCJI Ha co6CTBeHHOM, He3aBHCHMOM OT BHeIIIHHX ttrpOKOB nyrtt pa3BHTHJI, 3KOHOMHKa rocy~apcTBa B HaCTOJI-

185

CnMCOK MCTO'IHHKOBH nH1epatypb1

l1cToqHHJCH Ha pycCKoM H3h1Ke

1. KoHcnrTyu;tt.R: PoccttHCKOH <t>e,n;epau;tttt / / PocttiicKa.R: ra3eTa. -

2009. - NQ 7. - 21 RHB.

2. IOptt,n;ttqecKHH apxttB. URL: http:/ /docs.pravo.ru/document/ view/19382329/.

l1cToqHHKH Ha TYPe~oM H3bIKe

3.Ban§ andla§mas1 (Traile de Paix) Lozan, 24 Temmuz 1923. URL: http://sam.baskent.edu.tr/belge/Lozan_TR.pdf.

4.Diyanet ile AFAD arasmda i§birligi protokoli.i. 23 Arahk 2016. URL: http://diyanet.gov. tr/tr/icerik/diyanet-ile-afad-arasinda-isbirligi- protokolu/39372?getenglish.

5.Diyanet i§leri ba§kanhg1kuruku§ ve gorevleri hakkmda kanun. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/Metin.Aspx?MevzuatKod=l.5.633&Mevzuatil iski = O&sourceXmlSearch.

6.Ti.irkiye bi.iyi.ik millet meclisi. URL: https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/

tutanak/donem26 /yil2/ham/b03801h.htm.

7.fpCDK,D;aHCKH:H KO,ZJ;eKC Typeu;KOH Pecrry6;rnKH: OT 1926 r. URL: https:// tr.wikisource.org/wiki/743_Say1h_Ti.irk_Kanunu_Medenisi.

8.fpa)K,ll;aHCKH:H KO,ZJ;eKC Typeu;KOH Pecrry6JrnKH OT 2002 r. URL: http:// www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.5.4721.pdf.

9.KoHCTttzyu;tt.R: Typeu;Koii Pecrry6;rnKH OT 1982 r. URL: https://www. tbmm.gov. trI anayasa/anayasa_201 l.pdf.

10.KOHCTH:Tyu;H:.R: Typu;tttt OT 1924 r. URL: https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/ anayasa/anayasa24.htm.

11.0 6opb6e c Teppoptt3MOM: 3aKOH Typeu;KOH Pecrry6JIH:KH: OT 1991 r .. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.5.3713.pdf.

12.0 BHYTpeHHeM: cJI~6e: 3aKoH Typeu;Koii Pecrry6JittKH: 1961 r. URL:

http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.4.211.pdf.

13.0 BOeHHOH cJI~6e: 3aKoH Typeu;KoM: Pecrry6JittKH: OT 1935 r. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.3.llll.pdf.

14.0 BOeHHOM yroJIOBHOM Ko,n;eKce: 3aKoH Typeu;Koii Pecrry6JittKH OT 1930 r. URL: http://www.basarmevzuat.com/dustur/ kanun/3/1632/1632.htm.

15.0 BhICIIIeM o6pa3oBaHtttt: 3aKoH Typeu;Koii Pecrry6JittKH: OT 1981 r. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.5.2547.pdf.

187

16.0 rpa)K,ll;aHCKHX cy,n;ax: 3aKOH TypeQKOH Pecny6JIHKH OT 2011 r. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/1.5.6100.pdf.

17.0 rpa)K,ll;aHCKOM COCTOHHHH: 3aKOH TypeQKOH Pecrry6JIHKH OT 2001 r. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/1.5.4721.pdf.

18.0 HeKOMMepqecKHX TOBapHIQecTBax: 3aKoH TypeQKoH: Pecrry6JIHKH OT 2004 r. URL: https://www.dernekler.gov.tr/tr/mevzuat/kanun/5253- dernekler-kanunu.aspx.

19.0 q,oH,n;ax: 3aKoH TypeQKOH Pecrry6JIHKH OT 2008 r. URL: http:// www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/l.5.5737.pdf.

20.0 IIITaTHOM coCTaBe Boopy)KeHHhIX CHJI TypQHH: 3aKoH Ty- peQKoH: Pecny6JIHKH OT 1967 r. URL: http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/ MevzuatMetin/1.5. 926.pdf.

21.PerneHHe KOHCTHTYQHOHHoro cy,n;a TypeQKOH: Pecrry6JIHKH. URL: http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2010/08/20100801Ml-1.htm.

22.CTpaTemH «BH,n;eHHe 2023». URL: http://www.tsv2023.org/index.

php/en/.

23. ToproBhIH Ko,n;eKc TypeQKOH Pecrry6JIHKH OT 2011 r. URL: http:/I www.resmigazete.gov.trI eskiler/2011/02/20110214-1-1.htm.

HcTO'IHHKHHa aHI'JIHHCKOM.H3hIKe

24.MI1,ll, l'ypQHH. URL: http://www.mfa.gov.tr/iv-european-security- and-defence-identity_policy-_esdi_p_.en.mfa.

25.Pe30JIIOQHH CoBeTa Ee3orracttocTH OOH. URL: https://documents- dds-ny. un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN /N04/381 /18/PDF /N0438118. pdf. ?OpenElement.

26.Pe30JIIOQHH CoBeTa Ee3orracttocTH OOH. URL: https://documents- dds-ny. un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/NOl/708/57 /PDF /NOl 70857. pdf. ?OpenElement.

27.Pe30JIIOQHH CoBeTa Ee3orracttocT11 OOH. URL: https://documents- dds-ny. un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN /N96/362/ 45/PDF /N9636245. pdf. ?OpenElement.

JlHTeparypa Ha pyccKOM .H3hIKe

28.«mwT EB<l>paTa» - rnwpMa ,n;JIH TypQ1111. URL: http:/ /www.kp.ru/ daily/26573.4/3588776/.

29.S&P IIOHH3HJIO peHTHHrH TypQHH ,n;o «BB/B» c «BB+ /B», rrporH03 HeraTHBHhIH. URL: https: I /ria.ru/economy/20160720/1472440841.html.

30.AaamKoB, B. A. ,ll,eHTeJihHOCTh aHaJIHT11qecK11x QeHTpoB BTypQHH rrp11 rrpaBJieHHH TiapTHH crrpaBe,n;JIHBOCTH 11 pa3BHTHH I I B. A. ABaTKOB, A. C. Bw-

MHKHH // BecTHHK Mfl1M0-YHHBepcmeTa. - 2013. - NQ 3. URL: http:// www.vestnik.mgimo.ru/sites/default/files/pdf/16politologiya_avatkov. pdf.

31. AaamKoB, B. A. Kyp,n;CKM rrpo6JieMa Ha TYPeQKOM rroJie I B. A. ABaTKOB / / BecTHHK Mfl1M0-YHHBepcHTeTa. - 2012. - NQ 2. URL: https:/I cyberleninka.ru/article/v/kurdskaya-problema-na-turetskom-pole.

188

35.Eo.JiblllaH B3HTKa. URL: http://expert.ru/2013/12/23/bolshayavzyatka/.

36.B EC npoKOMMeHTHpoBa.JIH Il.JlaHbl TypQHH BepHYTh cMepTHYIO Ka3Hb. URL: http://www.rbc.ru/politics/18/07/2016/578cb2899a7947e4 ee658705?from= main.

37.B TypQHH B OTCTaBKY oTnpaBH.JIH no'ITH600 no.JIKOBHHKOB. URL: https://www.gazeta.ru/army/news/9030299.shtml.

38.B TypQHH Ha'la.JICHpecpepe~ o nonpaBKax B KoHCTHTYQHIO. URL:

https: I /ria.ru/world/20170416/1492337288.html.

39.B TypQHH paccKa3a.JIH o cpoKax BhIBO~a CBOHX BOHCK H311paKa. URL: https://rg.ru/2017/01/09/v-turcii-rasskazali-o-srokah-vyvoda-svoih-vojsk- iz-iraka.html.

40.B TypQHH Tpex reHepa.JIOB ocy~H.JIH 3a nonhITKY nepeBoporn. URL: http://www.bbc.com/russian/international/2012/09/12092 l_turkey_ army_coup_verdict.

41.B TypQHH yrnep~H.JIH HTorH pecpepeMyMa no KOHCTHTYQHH. URL:

https://ria.ru/world/20170427/1493273027.html.

42.Bepm.ReB, K. B. 11CJiaMCKHH cpaKTOp B no.JIHTHqecKOH )l(H3HH TypQHH / K. B. BeprneB I I 11c.JiaM Ha coBpeMeHHOM BocToKe I OTB. pe~. B. JI. EenoKpeHHQKHH, A. 3. EropHH. - M. : 11H-T BOCToKoBe~eHHH PAH ; KpacpT+,

2004. - 4440 c.

43. Bepm.ReB, K. B. Kyp~CKHH HaQHOHa.JIH3M: HCTOpHH H coBpeMeHHOCTh / K. B. BeprneB, C. M. 11BaHOB. - M. : JIEHAH,ll,, 2015. - 352 c.

44.8.JiaCTH TypQHH Haqa.JIH KaMnaHHIO no MaccoBoMy 3aKpbITHIO CMl1. URL: https://vz.ru/news/201617/27/823882.html.

45.BoeHHaH 3HQHK.Jione~HH. URL: http://www.globalsecurity.org/

military/world/europe/tu-military-coup-1997.htm.

46.Boi1Ha, KOTOPYIO HHKTO He 3aMeTH.JI. URL: https://www.gazeta.ru/ politics/2017/03/22_a_10587923.shtml#page6.

47.Boop~eHHbie CH.JihI OcMaHCKOH HMnepHH B XV-XVII BB. H BOeH-

HCUI peBO.JIIOQIDI. URL: http://www.xliby.ru/istorija/velikaja_ognestrelnaja_ revolyucija/p4.php.

48. I'acpam.RH., M.A. Kyp~bl TypQHH B HOBeHlllee BpeMH IM. A. racpaTHH. - EpeBaH: AHaCTaH, 1990. - 388 c.

49. feHllITa6 TypQHH pa3pellIH.JI )l(eHIQHHaM-BOeHHOCJI~aIQHM HOCHTh x~a6. URL: https://ria.ru/world/20170222/1488590747.html.

SO. I'eop2UR.1-1., 3. A. TypeQKCUI Pecny6.JIHKa. OcHOBHbie HHCTHzyThI rocy- ~apcTBeHHoro cTpoH I 3. A. reoprIDIH. - M. : HaYKa, 1975.

189

51.,4attwzoa, B. 11. Cpe,zi;HHe CJIOH B noJIHTHqecKoH: >KH3HH T'ypQHHB ne-

pHo,n; no.n;roTOBKH rocy.n;apCTBeHHoro nepeBoporn 27 MaJI 1960 r. / B. 11. ,ll;a- HHJIOB - M., 1984. - c. 150.

52.,4J1Cottc, ,4. T'ypQIDI:CoqTeT JIH EC npoBO,ll;HMhie AHKapoH: pe<}>opMhI

.n;ocrnTOqHo urnpoKHMH? I ,n;. ,ll;>KoHc. URL: http://russian.eurasianet.org/ node/60344.

53.,l!oJZzoa, E. B. <l>eHoMeH «apa6cKOH BeCHhI» 2011-2016 rr.: npHqHHhI, pa3BHTHe, nepcneKTHBhI IE. B. ,ll;oJirOB I I Tyirnc, ErHneT, JlHBIDI, CH-

pIDI, AmKHp: MOHOrpa<}>IDI I OTB. pe.zi;. 11. ,n;. 38.fireJibCKaJI. - M. : JIEHAH.Zt 2017. - 200 c.

c.18.

55.,l!py:>ICUJZOBCKUU, c. E. 0 BHyrpeHHHX npHqHHax ITOJIHTHqecKOH He-

CTa6HJibHOCTH B TypeQKOH Pecny6JIHKe I C. E. ,ll;pY>KHJIOBCKHH I I BecTHHK Mfl1M0-YHHBepcHTeTa. -2016. - NQ 2. -. c. 15-21. URL: http://www. vestnik.mgimo.ru/sites/default/files/pdf/002_druzhilovskiisb.pdf.

56.Epe.Meea, ,4. E. T'ypQIDIB ro,n;hI BTOpoH: MHpoBoH: H «XOJIO,ll;HOH» BOHH (1939-1990) I ,n;. E. EpeMeeB. M. : Afl1, 2005. c. 158.

57.EcJIH He BH,ll;HO pa3HHQhI. URL: https://lenta.ru/articles/2013/ 06/25/s300vshq9/.

58.)l(uzaJZutta, 0. Pe<}>opMhI H TypeQKHe Kyp,ll;hI. 2013 I 0. )KHraJIHHa. URL: http://ru.journal-neo.org/2013/10/21/reformy-i-turetskie-kurdy/

59.)l(uzyJZbCKa.R., ,a. B. BoccTaHHe TYPeQKHX Kyp,ll;OB B ,ll;eprnMe (19371938 rr.) I ,n;. B. )K11ryJihCKaH // l13BeCTHH Pocc11ikKoro rocy.n;apcTBeH-

Horo ne.n;arorHqecKoro YHHBepCHTeTa HM. A. 11. repQeHa. - 2013. - NQ 161. - C. 19-24. URL: http://lib.herzen.spb.ru/media/magazines/ contents/1/161/zhigulskaya_161_19_24.pdf.

60. 3anopo:>1eeq, B. M. TypQHH: npo6JieMhI BOeHHO-nOJIHT11qecKoro pa3BHTHH / B. M. 3anopo>KeQ. - M., 1991. q, I. - C. 300.

61. 36apa:>1CcKuii, K. 0 cocTOHHHH 0TTOMaHcKoH: HMnepHH H ee BOHCKa / K. 36apa>KCKHH I I OcMaHCKaJI HMnepHH B nepBoH: qeTBepTH XVII B. - M. : HaYKa, 1984. - C. 157.

62. 3uzattzuutta, r. M. 11cJiaM B o6rn;eCTBeHHo-noJIHTHqecKoH: >KH3HH TypQHH (1980-2000-e rr.) Ir. M. 3HraHIIIHHa. - M. ; EHIIIKeK, KPCY, 2007. -93 c.

63.3y6Koaa, A. 11. «BeJ,n;e TaKCHM, BeJ,n;e conpoTHBJieHHe»: IIOJIHT11qeCKHH aHaJIH3 npoTecToB B TypQHH I A. 11. 3y6KoBa I I BecTHHK PY,ll;H, cepIDI lloJIHTOJiorHH. - 2013. - NQ 4. - C. 72. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/ article/v/vezde-taksim-vezde-soprotivlenie-politicheskiy-analiz-protestov-v- turtsii.

64.11aattoaa, 11. 11. K11npcKaH npo6JieMa Ha coBpeMeHHOM 3Tane /

11.I1. 11BaHOBa // TypQJ.rn: HOBbie peaJIHH BO BHyrpeHHeH ITOJIHTHKe H yqa-

CTHe B per110HaJihHhIX reonoJIHTHqecKHX npoQeccax. - M. : Mfl1M0-YHn- BepCHTeT, 2015. - C. 83-96. URL: http://imi-mgimo.ru/images/pdf/ Knigi_i_broshury/t27.pdf.

190