Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018

KaK )')KeOTMeqaJIOCh, BY3hI Typeu,KoH Pecny6JIHKH 3aHHMaIOT ,n;aJieKo He IIOCJie,D;HHe MeCTa B Me)l{,ll;yttapo,n;HhIX o6pa30BaTeJihHhIX peHTHHrax, a KOJIHqecTBO 3aBe,n;eHHH c Ka)l{,ll;hIM ro,n;oM npo,n;oJDKaeT paCTH.

B KaqecTBe npHMepa MO)l(HO IIpHBeCTH peHTHHr, e:>Kero,n;Ho COCTaBJIBeMhlH HeMe:QKHM yttirnepCHTeTOM JiaH,n;eH. B 2016 r. B Hero IIOilaJIH cpa3y 12 TYPe:QKHx BY30B H3 CTaM6yJia, AHKaphl, lliMupa, Tpa63otta, Kai1cepH1. EoJiee ,n;o HaqaJia o6ocTpeHIDI KpH3Hca Ha 10ro-BOCT0Ke Typu,HH B cnHCOK BXO,ll;HJI TaK:>Ke yttirnepCHTeT ,ll;IDip6aKbrpa H3 O,ll;HOro H3 caMbIX OTCTaJiblX perHOHOB CTpaHbl.

HHTepectto, qTo noKa3aTeJIH Typu,HH npaKTHqecKH B,n;Boe BhIIIIe, qeM y llIBei1:u;apHH (7). ,ll;mI cpaBHeHIDI: H3 poccHHCKHX BY30B B peHTHHre npe,n;- CTaBJieHhI TOJihKO ,n;Ba - MocKOBCKHH H CaHKT-IleTep6yprcKHH rocy,n;apCTBeHHhie yttHBepcHTeThI2.

TeM He Mettee cpaBHHBaTh BY3hI Typ:u;HH c BhICIIIHMH yqe6HhIMH 3aBe- ,n;eHIDIMH CIIIA, fepMaHHH, HTaJIHH H BeJIHKo6pHTaHHH noKa CMhICJia HeT, Be,n;h corJiacHo peHTHHraM, TYPeU.KHe yttHBepcHTeThI 3HaqHTeJihHO oTcTaIOT H He B CHJiax COCTaBHTh HM ,ll;OCTOHHYJO KOHKypeH:QHIO.

l.JTO KacaeTai: o6pa3oBaTeJihHOH HHcppaCTPYKTYPhI B TYPe:QKHX yttHBepCHTeTax, TO HeJih3H He OTMeTHTh ,ll;OBOJihHO HH3KYJO CTOHMOCTh o6yqeHIDI. B rocy,n;apCTBeHHhIX By3ax OHa COCTaBmieT 3a CeMeCTp HeCKOJihKO COTeH ,n;oJIJiapoB. TaM, r,n;e o6yqeHHe H,D;eT Ha TYPeU.KOM H3hIKe, CTOHMOCTh ,n;JIH rpa)l{,ll;aH Typ:u;HH - OT 80 ,n;o 250 ,ll;OJIJI., ,ll;JIH HHOCTpaHIJ,eB - OT 240 ,n;o 750 ,ll;OJIJI. IlpH o6yqeHHH B rocBy3e Ha aHrJIHHCKOM H3hIKe c rpa)l{,ll;aH Typ:u;HH B3HMaeTCH DJiaTa B pa3Mepe 150-500 ,ll;OJIJI., c HHOCTpatt:u;eB -450-1500. B Herocy,n;apCTBeHHhIX By3aX CTOHMOCTh o6yqeHHH 3HaqHTeJibHO BhIIIIe - OT 5 ThIC. ,n;o 20 ThIC. ,ll;OJIJI., o,n;HaKO npH 3TOM cyi:u;ecTBYJOT ,ll;OBOJibHO o6IIIHpHhie B03MO)l(HOCTH ,ll;JIH IIOJiyqeHHH rpaHTOB3•

YposeHb Hay1.1Horo pa3BMTMH BTyp"MM

fOBOpH 06 o6pa30BaTeJihHOH CHCTeMe Typ:u;HH, HeJih3H He OTMeTHTh B03pocIIIy10 poJih ttayKH H TeXHOJIOrHH B ,n;aHHOH o6JiaCTH. B o6m;eMHpoBOM peHTHHre, KOTOpbIH COCTaBJIHeT npeCTH:>KHhIH HayqHhIH :>KypHaJI SCimago, no ,n;aHHhIM 3a 2015 r. Typ:u;HH 3aHHJia 18-e MecTo, JIHIIIh HeMHOro yCTynHB Hpatty H llIBei1:u;apHH H oCTaBHB no3a,n;H EeJibrHIO, ABcTpHIO H CHHranyp4.

PocT HaYKH H TexHoJiorHH B nepBYJO oqepe,n;h o6'hHCHHMrocy,n;apcTBeHHOH IlOJIHTHKOH, CBH3aHHOH c O~HCJieHHHMH HeKOTOpOH cyMMhl cpe,n;CTB

H3 rocy,n;apcTBeHHoro 610,n;:>KeTa Ha pa3BHTHe ,n;aHHOH oTpacJIH. B Typu;HH

I Leiden university ranking 2016. URL: http://www.leidenranking.com/ranking/2016/

list.

2 TaM )Ke.

3 AaamKDB B. A., KacamKUH II. 11. YKa3. coq.

4 Scimago Journal and country rating 2015. URL: http://www.scimagojr.com/ countryrank.php?year=2015.

161

B Typu;1111 pacITpocTJ)aHeHo 11JAaH11e HayqHhlx :>KypHaJIOB ~Byx Tl1ITOB:

HayqHo-ITorrym1pHbie, I.l;eJibIO KOTOpbIX HBJUleTOI ITorrym1p113au;1111 Hay<IHbIX OTKpbITl1H 11 11CCJI~OBaHHH cp~11 HaceJieHHH, H aKMeMl.PieCKHe.

ECJI11 rOBOp11Tb 6oJiee ITO~po6Ho 0 ITepBOM Tl1ITe, TO cero~HH B pecITy-

6JI11Ke cyiu;ecTByeT TJ'l1TaKHx :>KypHaJia.

nepBbIH - Bilim ve Teknik TUBiTAK, 113~aBaeMbIH OpraH113an;11eli ITO Hay<IHbIM 11 TeXHOJior11qeCKHM HCCJI~OBaHHHM, rnaBHbIM rpaHTOOITepaTopoM B CTpaHe, KOTOpbIH BHOCl1T O~HH H3 caMblX 60JiblllHX BKJia~OB B pa3B11T11e TYPen;KoH: HaYKH. Co~ep:>KaH11e 11~aH11H BeCbMa pa3Hoo6pa3HO, B HeM rry6Jil1KYJOTOI CTaThH Ha caMbie pa3Hble TeMhl, CBH3aHHhie c l1CCJI~O­

BaH11eM KOCMOCa, <P11311KOH, 6110Jior11eH:, 300JIOr11eH:, reHHOH l1H:>KeHep11eH:. HaIT11caHHh1e ~OCTYfiHhIM H3hIKOM cTaTbl1 KacaIOTC.H KpaH:tte aKryaJihHhIX TeM. HaITp11Mep, ITOCJie KpyrrHoro 3eMJieTp.HceHH.H BbIXO~T CTaThl1 06 3TOM

ITp11pO~HOM .HBJieHHl1.

BtopoH: ITO ITOITYJI.HpHOCTl1 HayqHblH :>KypHaJI - Bilim ve Teknik

CUMHURIYET. Ero cITeu;11<!>11Ka B TOM, qTo B HeM qacTo oCBern,aIOT He CTOJihKO

caMy HaYKY, CKOJibKO HOBOCTl1 113 Hay<IHOH c<Pepbl. )KypHaJI paccKa3hIBaeT

0 He~aBHl1X OTKpbITH.HX 11 B~yID,11XC.H pa3pa60TKax 11 T.IT. Bo MHOrOM TaKa.H ~e.HTeJihHOCTh CB.H3aHa c TeM, qTo Bilim ve Teknik TUBiTAK .HBJI.HeTOI co6-

crneHHocTbIO HayqHOH opraHHJan;1111, a Bilim ve Teknik CUMHURIYET ITp11HaMe:>Kl1T ra3eTHOMY 113~aTeJibCTBy.

Cyrn,ecrnyeT TaK:>Ke :>KypHaJI ITO~ Ha3BaH11eM FOCUS, CTPyKTYPa KOToporo

COBepllleHHO orn11qaeT01 OT ITepBbIX ~Byx. Ey~yq11 co6cTBeHHOCTbIO Me~11a­ XOJI~l1Hra DMG, OH B CKOpee KOMMepqeCKl1H, 11MeeT 60Jibllle peKJiaMbl,

.HpK11X HJIJIIOCTJ)al.1;11H.

qTO KacaeTC.H a1rn~eM11qecK11X :>KypHaJIOB, TO 11X rnaBHOe OTJI11q11e OT HayqHO-ITOITYJI.HpHbIX 3aKJIJOqaeTC.H B TOM, qTo B CB060~HOH ITpo~a:>Ke

11X ITpaKT11qecK11 HeB03MO:>KHO HaHTl1. B Hl1X, KaK ITpaBHJIO, ITy6Jil1KYIOTC.H CTaThl1 Ha OITpe~eJieHHble TeMhI, BHe 3aBl1Cl1MOCTl1 OT aKTyaJihHOCTl1,

a caM11 cTaTb11 B TaKHX :>KypHaJiax TPY~HhI ~JI.H ITpoqTeH11.H He CBe~yrn,ero B cITen;11aJIH3an;1111 :>KypHaJia qeJioBeKa. UeJieBa.H ay~11Top1rn aKa~eM11qecK11x

:>KypHaJIOB - HayqHhie COTPY~HHKH.

AKa~eM11qecK11e :>KypHaJihI, KaK 11 HayqHo-IToITymipHhie, 11ccJie~yIOT ~ocTaTOqHo 1ll11poK11i1 Kpyr ITpo6JieM B pa3JI11qHbIX o6Jiacrnx HayK11. B Typ- u;1111 ll3~aIOTC.H :>KypHaJibl ITO 6110Jior1111, 300Jior1111, Me~11u;11He, l1H:>KeHep1111 11 ~pyr11e, a 11X q11cJIO CTpeMl1TeJibHO B03pacTaeT. TeM He Mettee 11X ITOITYJI.HpHOCTb 3a py6e:>KOM II Me:>K~yHapo~Ha.H 3Haq11MOCTb OCTaIOTC.H HH3K11M11 B 6oJibllleH CTeITeHl1 H3-3a Toro, qTO OHl1 113~aIOTC.H Ha Typeu;KOM,

a He aHrJil1HCKOM .H3bIKe.

Ponb y'leHoroe nonMTMKe

KaK 6b1JI0 OTMeqeHo, Hayqtta.H 11 o6pa3oBaTeJihHa.H cttcTeMa B Typu;.11.11

~OBOJihHO c11JibHO u;eHTpaJIH30BaHa. B pe3yJihTaTe 6oJiblll.HHCTBO BY30B

163

H ttayqtthIX opraHH3aQHH }'TPaTHJIHCBOH He3aBHCHMhIH xapaKTep, a Hx ,a;eR:- TeJihHOCTh CBO,ll;HTCH K BbIIIOJIHeHHIO yi<a3aHHH rocy,a;apcTBeHHbIX opraHOB, qTo q>aKTHqecKH HCKJIIQqHJio BblCIIIHe yqe6Hhle 3aBe,a;emrn H3 BHJ'TPHllOJIHTHqecKOH 6opb6bI.

TeM He Mettee 3TO He 03HaqaeT, qTo caMH qJieHbI 11pocpeccopcKo-11pe110- ,a;aBaTe.nhcKoro COCTaBa, KOTOpbie HBJUllOTCH HaH6oJiee HpKHMH 11pe,a;cTaBHTeJIHMH rypeQKOH HHTeJIJIHreHQHH, He yqacTBYJOT B llOJIHTHqecKOH )KH3HH

CTpaHhl.

011epaQHH 11poTHB KYP,ll;CKHX rpy1111HpOBOK Ha IOrO-BOCTOKe cTpaHbI H llOllbITKa BOeHHOro 11epeBopoTa JieTOM 2016 r. CTaJIH HarJIH,ll;HblM 11pHMepoM CKa3aHHOfO. B HaqaJie 2016 r. CBOe pa3BHTHe llOJiyqHJIO ,ll;BH:lKeHHe «.H He CTaHy yqacTHHKOM 11peCTYJIJieHHH», 11pe,a;cTaBJIHB1IIee co6oif 11eTHQHIO, KOTOPYJO 110,ll;llHCaJIH 1128 yqeHbIX: 900 rypeQKHX H 400 HHOCTpaHHbIX 11pocpeccopoB. IJ,e.nh 11eTHQHH 3aKJIJOqaJiacb B 11pH3bIBe K 11paBHTeJ1hCTBY 0 11peKparn;eHHH KpOBOllpOJIHTHbIX ,a;eifCTBHH Ha IOfO-BOCTOKe CTpaHhl: «OqeBH,a;Hbl pa3pYIIIHTeJlbHble H He11011paBHMbie pe3yJibTaTbl KOHcpJIHKTa, KOTOpbIH 11po,a;OJI:lKaeTCH Ha IOfO-BOCTOKe HallleH CTpaHbl y:lKe MHOrHe MeCHQbl. B 3TOH CH'ryaQHHHeo6xo,a;HMO 11pH3BaTb K MHpHOMY H c11paBe,a;- JIHBOMY pa3pellleHHIO KOHcpJIHKTa. Mbl TaK:lKe qYBCTByeM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb Ka)K,ll;oro ,a;eHTeJIH HayKH B 3TOH CTpaHe 3a 06ec11eqeHHe CBo6o,a;bI CJIOBa, HBJIHIOrn;eifcH 6a30BbIM llpHHQHllOM Me)K,ll;yttapo,a;Horo 11paBa H 3aKpeIIJieH-

HOH B Me)K,ll;yttapo,a;HhIX corJiallleHHHX».

YqacTHHKaMH 11eTHQHH KpHTHqecKH oQeHHJIH 110,a;xo,a; rypeQKOH BJiaCTH

K ,a;aHHOH 11po6JieMe: «HeJib3H 3a6hIBaTh, qTo HeOTbeMJieMOH qacTblO CB0-

60,a;bI CJIOBa HBJUieTCH 11paBO Ha KpHTHKY BJiaCTIL TaK:lKe Ha,ll;O IIOMHHTh, qTo rrepBooqepe,a;HOH 3a,a;aqeif BJiaCTH HBJIHeTCH C03,a;aHHe B CTpaHe YCJIOBHH, rapaHTHPYJOlll;HX rpa)K,ll;aHaM rrpaBO Ha )KH3Hb, qero HbIHellIHee rrpaBHTeJlh-

CTBO He ,a;e.naeTl». -

,lJ,aHHM aKQHH rrpo,a;eMOHCTpHpOBaJia, qTO aKTHBHOe COTpy,a;HHqecTBO rypeQKHX yqeHbIX Ha MHpOBOM ypOBHe I103BOJIHJIO HM C03,ll;aTh ,ll;OBOJihHO 061IIHpHYJO ceTb KOHTaKTOB, KOTOpM B Tpy,a;HhIH MOMeHT OKa3aJia HM rro,a;- ,a;ep:lKey. CBOH IIO,ll;IIHCH 110,ll; ,ll;OKyMeHTOM llOCTaBHJIH aMepHKaHCKHH llOJIHTOJIOr HoaM XoMCKHH H cJioBeHCKHH <i>HJioco<P CJiaBoif )1(11:lKeK.

AKQHH He 11po1IIJ1a 6eccJie,a;tto c ToqKH 3peHHH Me)K,ll;yHapo,a;Horo coo6rn;ecTBa H 11pHBJieKJia oco6oe BHHMaHHe BH,ll;HhIX llOJIHTHqecKHX ,a;eHTeJieH Coe,a;11HeHHh1x illTaTOB AMepHKH. BHQe-11pe3H,a;eHT CillA ,lI,:lKo Eaif.a;eH c,a;e- JiaJI Tor,a;a 3MBHJI, qTo AMepwKa 110Mep:lKHBaeT ,a;OKYMeHT 110,a; tta3BaHHeM «.H He CTaHy yqacTHHKOM 11peCTYIIJieHHH» H 6y,a;eT 3arn;Hrn;aTb TaKHe o6rn;eqeJIOBeqecKHe QeHHOCTH, KaK 11paBO Ha CB06o,a;y CJIOBa, 11paBO «KpHTHKOBaTh H ,ll;hilllaTb CB06o,a;Ho»2.

11402'liklerden 1128'e Destek. URL: http://bianet.org/bianet/insan-haklari/171149- 1402-liklerden-1128-e-destek.

2ABD Ba§kan Yard1mc1S1 Biden'den akademisyenlere destek: Ozgiirce ele§tirebilmek, ozgiirce nefes almak kadar degerli. URL: http://t24.com.tr/haber/abd-baskan-yardimcisi- biden-ozgurce-elestirebilmek-ozgurce-nefes-almak-kadar-degerli,325215.

164

IlpoBe,ll;eHHCUI aKU;IDI CTaJia B KaKOM-TO CMhICJie CHMBOJIOM e,ll;HHCTBa yqeHhIX H COTPY,ll;HHKOB yttHBepCHTeTOB 1'ypQHH,no,11;qepKHYB, 'ITOHHTe.JvmreHQIDI npe,ll;CTaBmieT co6oii e,ll;HHYJO COQHaJlhHYJO H IlOJIHTH'leCKyrorpynny,

KOTOpaH HMeeT CBOH co6CTBeHHhie HHTepeChl H onpe,11;eJieHHOe KOJIH'leCTBO pecypcoB, 'IT06hIOTCTOJITh HX.

BhlCTYTIJiem1e yqeHhIX 6hIJIO cephe3HO BocnpHHHTO pyKoBO,ll;CTBOM TypQHH, ,ll;JIH KOToporo 3TO 6hIJIO HBHhIM CHrHaJIOM 06 onacHOH aKTHBH3aQHH HHTeJIJIHreHQHH. Mac111Ta6HOCTh aKQHH npHBJieKJia BHHMaHH:e npoKypa-

pe)l{HM BOeHHOro IlOJIO)l{eHIDI H Ha'IaJiaCh6oph6a co BCeMH, KTO He cornaceH c noJIHTHKOH npaBH~eH: napTHH, 'IJieHhInpocl>eccopcKo-npeno,11;aBaTeJih- cKoro COCTaBa yttHBepCHTeTOB OKa3aJIHCh O,ll;HHMH H3 nepBhIX, KTO IlOilaJI IlO,ll; y,11;ap.

Ilo ,ll;aHHhIM ,ll;OKJia,ll;a, KOTOphIH B KOHQe CeHTH6pH 2016 r. IlO,ll;rOTOBHJia onno3HQHOHHCUI Hapo,11;Ho-pecny6JIH:KaHcKCU1 napTIDI, c HIOAA Toro )Ke ro,11;a B TypQHH 6hIJIH 3aKphIThI 15 yHHBepcH:TeToB (yqHThIBaH, 'ITO,KaK 6hIJIO CKa3aHO BhIIIIe, Bcero B TypQHH HaC'IHThIBaeTCHOKOJIO 200 BY30B, IlOCJie IlOilhITKH nepeBopoTa 6hIJIO 3aKphITO Ka)l{,ll;Oe TpHHa,ll;QaToe 3aBe,ll;eHH:e).

06~ee )Ke KOJIH'leCTBOnpocl>eccopoB, KOTOphie 6hIJIH OTCTpaHeHhl OT pa60Thl no pacnopH)l{eHHIO PYKOBO,ll;CTBa By3a HJIH YBOJieHhI B cooTBeTCTBHH c peIIIeHIDIMH rocy,11;apCTBeHHhIX opraHOB, npeBhICHJIO 6 ThIC. 'IeJI.

Teneph oCTaeTCH 60.JihIIIOH Bonpoc: coxpaHHTCH JIH noCJie 3THX co6hITHH TOT )Ke ypoBeHh CB060,ll;hl CJIOBa cpe,ll;H pa60THHKOB ytti-rnepCHTeTOB, HJIH noJIHTMKa npaBHII~eii TiapTHM cnpaBe,ll;JIHBOCTM H pa3BHTHH npHBe,ll;eT K CHH- )l{eHHIO ,ll;O MHHHMYMa IlOJIHTH'leCKOHaKTHBHOCTH yqeHhIX B CTpaHe?

***

¥fayqem1e BHYTPHTIOJIHTH'lecKo:HCHCTeMhI TypeQKo:H pecny6JIHKH 6e3 yqeTa no3HQHH TYPeQKHX yHHBepcttTeTOB B HaCTOH~ee BpeMH He npe,11;- cTaBJIHeTCH HeB03MO)l{HhIM, IIOCKOJihKY HMeHHO OHH Ha rrpoTH)l{eHHH Bce:H HCTOpHH rocy,11;apCTBa HrpaJIH Ba)l{He:H111yro pOJih B IIOJIHTH'IeCKHXrrpoQeCcax cTpaHhI.

Cero,11;HH H3yqaTh yttHBepcttTeThI KaK caMOCTOHTeJihHhIH o6'heKTB KOH-

TeKCTe TYPeQKo:H rroJIHTHKH TaK)l{e Kpa:HHe CJIO)l{HO. KaK npaBHJIO, OH rro,11;- pa3,11;eJIHeTcH Ha ,ll;Be COCTaBJIHIO~He: CTy,ll;eHThl H rrpocl>eccopcKO-IIperro-

,ll;aBaTeJihCKMH COCTaB. Ka)l{,ll;hlH H3 3JieMeHTOB MMeeT CBOM IIOJIMTH'leCKHe HHTepeChl, H Ha Hero OKa3hIBaeTCH oco6eHHOe BJIHHHHe.

CTy,ll;eHTaM, Harrp11Mep, CBOHCTBeHHhI orrrro3HQHOHHhie B033peHHH no OTHOIIIeHMIO K rrpaBH~eH napTHH crrpaBe,ll;JIHBOCTH H pa3BMTMH, 6Jiaro,11;apH pa3JIH'IHhIMMe)l{,ll;yttapO,ll;HhlM rrporpaMMaM OHH IlOCTOHHHO HaxoMTCH rro,11; BJIHHHHeM ClllA H EBpOIIhI. Y'IeHhie,B CBOIO oqepe,11;h, TaK)l{e

I Bohannon J. Turkish academics pay price for speaking out on Kurds. URL: http://www. sciencemag.org/news/2016/01/turkish-academics-pay-price-speaking-out-kurds.

165

rnaea 10 nPOTECTHblE BblCTYnnEHMJI

BTYPUMM

c yqeTOM BOCTOqHoro MeHTa.JUfTeTa H IIOJIHTHqecKOH K}'Jlb'fYPblTypu;HH MO)l(HO KOHCTanipoBaTb, qTO KpyrrttoMaCUITa6Hbie ,n;eMOHCTpau;HH, aKu;HH H HHble cpopMbl Bblpa)l(eHJUI rrpoTeCTa BCer,n;a 6hmH HeOTbeMJieMOH qacTblO COIJ;HaJibHO-IIOJIHTMqecKOH )l(M3HM rpa)l(,Zl;aH rocy,n;apCTBa. 3a MHOroJieTHIOIO MCTOpMIO Typeu;KCUI Pecrry6JIHKa rrepe)l(MJia MHOro co6bITMH, OT KpyrrHbIX BOCCTaHHH, xapaKTepHbIX, KaK rrpaBMJIO, ,n;mi: BOeHHOro M IIOCTBOeHHOrO rrepMO,ll;OB, ,n;o Mettee 3HaqMMbIX rrpoTeCTOB, KOTOpbie OXBaTbIBa.JIM rocy,n;apCTBO BO BTopoH: IIOJIOBMHe xx B. M Hepe,n;Ko Ha6JIIO,ZJ;alOTCfl B Haurn ,ll;HM.

vfayqaH BHYTPHIIOJIMTMqecKMe rrpou;ecCbI Typu;MM, HeJib3fl MrHOpHpoBaTb HapO,ll;Hbie BbICTYIIJieHMJI Typeu;KMX rpa)l(,ZJ;aH. I1o,n;po6HbIH aHaJIM3 cou;MaJibHbIX rrpoTeCTOB c MOMeHTa o6pa30BaHMJI rocy,n;apcTBa BIIJIOTb

,n;o HaCTOHIIJ;MX ,n;HeH 1103BOJIMT TIOHJITb npHqlfHbI, no KOTOpbIM B03HMKalOT rrpo6JieMbl B Typeu;KOM o6rn;ecTBe, a TaK)l(e BblJIBMTb MeTO,ZJ;bI, rrocpe,n;CTBOM KOTOpbIX rpa)l(,Zl;aHe rocy,n;apCTBa IlbITalOTCH peIIIMTb MX M BJIMJITb Ha BJiaCTHble KpyrM .

.VfayqeHMe rrpHpo,n;hI TaKoro HBJieHMH, KaK cou;MaJihHhIH rrpoTeCT B TypIJ;MM, cJie,n;yeT ttaqMHaTb co BpeMeH o6pa3oBaHMH rocy,n;apCTBa M rrpe,n;rneCTBOBaBrnMx 3TOMY co6hITMH.

06CTaHOBKa nepBOM nonoBMHbl xx BeKa

BHYTPMIIOJIMTMqeCKYJO o6cTaHOBKY Typu;MM rrepBoH: rroJIOBl1HbI XX B. HeJih3H Ha3BaTb crroKoH:ttoH:. I1ep110,n; Me)l(,n;y ,ZJ;BYMH M11poBhIM11 BOHHaM11 MO)l(HO oxapaKTep1130BaTb ,ll;OCTaTOqHo KpyrrHbIMl1 11 rrpo,n;OJI)l(l1TeJibHbIMl1 BOCCTaHl1JIMM, 6oJibllil1HCTBO KOTOpbIX pa3BepHyJIOCb Ha BOCTOKe CTpaHbI.

K TaKOBbIM OTHOCMTCH 11 MHTe)I( rneH:xa Ca11,Z1;a, H BOCCTaH11e y r. CacoH

(1925-1937), 0 KOTOpOM coxpaHHJIOCb Kpa:H:He MaJIO MHcpopMau;H11. B 11Tore Bee 3Tl1 rrpoTeCTbI CTaJil1 O,ll;HOH H3 rnaBHbIX rrp11qHH pa3BHTHJI KpyrrHOMaCIIITa6HbIX aKu;11H: Herro,n;qHHeHMH, Ha KOTOpbIX 6bmO cocpe,n;OTOqeHO OCHOBHOe BHl1MaH11e BJiacTeH:.

CTapT rrpoTeCTHbIM BhICTyrrJieHMHM Mor 6hITb ,n;aH ern;e B ro,n; o6pa3oBaHl1H Typeu;KoH: Pecrry6JIHKl1, Kor,n;a ttapfl,Zl;y c c03,n;aHMeM pecrry6JI11KaHcKoro

167

rocyp;apCTBa 11peTep11e.n: c~eCTBeHHbie H3MeHeHIDI H ero 110JIHTHqecKHH cTpoii. HoBaH Hau;110HaJibHaH 110JIHTHKa M. K. ATaTIOpKa, HeH3BeCTHaH TYPeu;KOMY o6iu;ecTBY paHee cBeTCKOCTb BhI3bIBaJIH BCilJieCK Hau;110HaJIH3Ma B OT,ll;eJibHbIX perHOHax, O,ll;HaKO 110JIHOIJ;eHHbIX BOJIHeHHH Torp;a y,ZJ;aJIOCb H36e:>KaTb.

0,ZJ;HaKO BCKOpe 110CJie :noro - B 1924 r. - 11epBbIH Kpy11HeHIIIHH 11poTeCT, HMeHyeMbIH «HeCTOpHaHCKHM BOCCTaHHeM» acc11p11iiu;eB, Bee :>Ke ,ZJ;o6paJICH ,ZJ;O Typu;1111, CTaB 11poHBJieHHeM 6opb6b1110BcTaHu;eB 3a He3aBHCHMOCTb. AccHpHHIJ;bl, BOeBaBIIIHe 11pOTHB OcMaHCKOH HM11ep1111 B rO,ZJ;bl IlepBOH MHpOBOH BOHHbl, KaK H MHOrHe ,Zl;pyrHe HapO,Zl;bl, CTpeMHJIHCb C03- ,ZJ;aTb co6cTBeHHYJO aBTOHOMHIO B6JIH3H 11p11rpaH11qHh1x paiioHOB Typu;1111, l1paKa H l1paHa, O,ZJ;HaKO 110,ZJ; yrpo30H TeppHTOpHaJibHbIX 110Tepb, u;e.n:ecoo6pa3HOCTb 3TOH H,ZJ;eH HHKTO He pa3,ZJ;eJIHJI1, H OHa TaK H OCTaJiaCb HepeaJIH30BaHHOH.

Ha1160JibIIIHH HHTepec acc11p11iiu;eB BhI3bIBaJI 6oraTbIH 11p11po,Z1;HbIMH pecypcaMH MocyJI, KOTOpbIH KOr,ZJ;a-TO BXO,ZJ;HJI B COCTaB OcMaHCKOH HMl1epHH, 11 B cooTBeTCTBHH c CeBpcKHM ,ZJ;oroBopoM, 3aKJI10qeHHOM B 1920 r. 6bm 11epe,ZJ;aH l1paey, qTo 110 110HHTHbIM 11p11q11HaM Typu;IDI OTKa3aJiacb 11p113HaTb.

B11ocJie,ZJ;CTBHH Typu;m111 Be.n:11Ko6p11TaHHH, KOTOpaH cpaKTHqecKH oTcTaHBaJia HHTepeCbl acc11p11iiu;eB, TaK H He CMOrJIH ,ZJ;OCTHqb cornacIDI 110 3TOMY B011pocy. 3TOMY He c11oco6cTBOBaJIH ,ZJ;a:>Ke Jlo3aHHCKaH KOHcpepeHIJ;HH H IJ;eJlbIH pH,Zl; 11eperoBopoB, 11pH3BaHHbIX peIIIHTb B011p0Cbl TeppHTOpHaJibHOH u;e.n:ocTHOCTH rocy,ZJ;apcTB. B HTore 6hmo 11p11HHTO peIIIeH11e, qTo cy,ZJ;h6y MocyJia 011pe,Z1;eJIHT JI11ra Hau;ni1J.2.

0,ZJ;HaKo y:>Ke B TO BpeMH 11p11 aKTHBHoii 110,ZJ;,ZJ;ep:>KKe Be.n:11Ko6p11TaHHH accHpHHIJ;bl 110,Zl;HHJIH KpyrrHOMaCIIITa6Hoe BOCCTaHHe, HaqaB KOHcppOHTaIJ;HlO c TYPeu;KHMH BoiicKaMH, KOTOpb1e, HeCMOTpH Ha 11poB0Kau;110HHhie Tpe6oBaHHH 11peKpaTHTb aTaKH, 11pO,Zl;OJI:>KHJIH HaCTYilJieHHe, 110,ZJ;aBHB BOCCTaHHe. l1 xorn TYPKaM y,ZJ;aJIOCb oT6pocHTh acc11p11i1u;eB Ha 10r l1paKa, TeM caMbIM H36e:>KaB co3,ZJ;aHHe aBTOHOMHH, MocyJI BepHYTh TaK 11 He y.ZJ;aJIOCb - OH H cero,ZJ;HH OCTaeTCH B COCTaBe l1paKa H 110-11pe:>KHeMy HBJIHeTCH o6'beKTOM 6ecrroKoi1cTBa Typeu;Koii Pecrry6JIHKH.

l1HTepec Typu;HH K 3TOMY perHOHY Bl10JIHe 011paB,ZJ;aH: 110MHMO 60JibIIIOro KOJI11qecTBa 3HepropecypcoB pec11y6,Z1;11Ka ,ZJ;O c11x 11op cq11TaeT ,ZJ;aHHYIO TeppHTOpHlO CBOeH, 110CKOJibKY ,ZJ;OJiroe BpeMH OHa HBJIHJiaCb qacTblO OcMaHCKoii HM11ep11113.

BoccTaHHe acc11p11iiu;eB, 11ycTh 11 He caMoe yc11eII1Hoe, MrHOBeHHO Bbl3BaJIO BCl1JieCK Hau;HOHaJibHOro caMOC03HaHHH H B KaKOM-TO CMbICJie CTaJIO 11pHMepoM ,ZJ;JIH ,ZJ;pyr11x HapO,ll;OB B HX 6opb6e 3a He3aBHCHMOCTb.

1 3pJZUXMaH B. HerroKopeHHbie / / Po,111rna. NQ 8. 2006. C. 75-78.

2 AeamKOB B. A. u ap. Poccllil H CTpaHbl BocTOKa B IIOCT6HIIOJIHpHbIH rrepHO,ll I ITO,l\ pe,11. ,[(. B. CTpeJibl\OBa. M. : Mfl1MO (Y) ; AcrreKT npecc, 2014.

3 AeamKOB B. A. u ap. Tepp11TOp11aJibHbIH Borrpoc B aqipo-a311aTCKOM MHpe I ITO,l\ pe,11. ,[(. B. CTpeJibl\OBa. M. : AcrreKT CTpecc, 2013. 319 c.

168

IlepBhIMH, KTO HCIIOJlh30BaJI TaKTHK)'acc11p11ifu;eB, CTaJIH K)'p,ll;hl,KOTOphie Bcer,a;a cqHTaJIH cefo1 yrHeTeHHhIM Hapo,a;OM.

Y)l(e qepe3 ro,a; 110CJie co6hITHH 1924 r. Typu;1110 IIOTPRCJIO ,a;pyroe, 6011ee Kpyrrnoe K)'p,ll;CKOeBOCCTaHHe BO r11aBe c rneHXOM op,a;eHa HaKllI6eH,a;H CaH- ,ll;OM. B HeM 11pHHJiJIO yqacTHe 6011ee HeCKOJihKHX coTeH ThICJiq qe110BeK, a caMH IIpOTeCTHhie BhICTYIIJieHHR pac11pOCTPaHHJIHCh BO MHOrHe perHOHhl CTPaHhI.

Ilp11q11Ha He,ll;OBOJihCTBa H, CJie,a;oBaTeJihHO, BOCCTaHHJi CXO)l(a c TeMH 11peTeH3HRMH, KOTOphle Kyp,a;hI 11pe,a;'hRBJIRIOTTypeu;KoMy pyKoBo,a;cTBY 11 cero,a;HR - ttau;11ottaJihHM IIOJIHTHKa. EIQe co BpeMeH M. K. ATaTIOpKa 3aKpeIIHJIOCh 011pe,a;e11eHHe, cornaCHO KOTOpOMY Bee rpa)l(,ll;aHe Typu;1111 Ha3hIBaJIHCh T}'PKaMH,qTo He MOrJIO He Bhl3BaTb COIIpOTHBJieHHJi co CTOpOHhl 3THOHaQHOHaJlhHhIX rpYIIII, ttapR,ll;y c 3THHqeCKHMH T}'PKaMHIIpO)l(H- BaIOIQHX Ha TeppHTOpHH rocy,a;apcrna.

KaK H accHpHHI.l;bI, K)'p,ll;hlCTpeMHJIHCb H CTpeMJiTCJi K C03,ll;aHHIO CBOero He3aBHCHMOro rocy,a;apcrna. 3ttMOH 1925 r. OHH HaqaJIH BOCCTaHtte, o,a;HaKO Ha IIpOTJi)l(eHHH Bcero BpeMeHH ero OCHOBHOM CHJIOH JiBJIJiJIOCh K)'p,ll;CKOe 1111eMR 3a3a, B TO BpeMR KaK 11tt,zi;eph1 Myrna, CttttpTa, CeBepttKa, ,l(epcttMa OCTaJIHCb B CTopoHe, He Bbipa3HB 110,a;,a;ep)l(K)'Ca11,a;y1, qTo BIIOCJie,ll;CTBHH CTaJIO O,ll;HOH 113 rJiaBHhIX IIpttqHH IIOpa)l(eHHJi K)'p,ll;OB.

B cpeBpane 110BcTattu;b1 OKKYIIHPOBaJIH feH,ll;)I(, pac11paBttBIIIttCb c 11paBRIQHMtt TaM TyrpeQKHMH BJiaCTJiMH H Bhl,ll;BHHYB Ha HX MeCTa CBOHX 11pe,a;- CTaBttTe11eH. C11e,a;yIOIQeH u;eJiblO CTaJia tteocpttu;ttaJihHaJi CTOJittu;a Kyp,ll;OB Typu;tttt - ,l(ttRp6aKhip, o,a;ttaKo y)l(e Ha 3TOM 3Ta11e, BCTpeTttB rypeu;Koe COIIpOTHBJieHtte IIptt aKTHBHOM 110,a;,a;ep)l(Ke ,a;epcttMCKHX IlJieMeH, IIOBCTattu;bI IIOTepIIeJIH IIOpa)l(eHtte.

HeCMOTpR Ha 3TO; IIOCJie Hey,zi;aqHOH oca,a;bI ,l(ttRp6aKbipa IIpOH30IIIJIO eIQe ttecKOJibKO CTOJIKHOBettttif y EttTJittca, Myrna tt EaR3ttTa, o,zi;ttaKo tt otttt He 11ptttteCJitt K)'p,ll;CKHM<PopMttpoBaHttRM yc11ex. Il03,zi;ttee, Becttoif, rypKtt B3RJIH oca)l(,a;eHHhIH pattee Kyp,a;aMtt fett,zi;)I(. C11ycTR ttecKOJibKO MecRu;eB 11pe,a;BO,ll;HTeJib BOCCTaHHR rneifx CaH,a; H Bee, KTO 6bm IIpttqaCTeH K opraHH3au;11tt H peaJitt3aQHH BOCCTaHHJi, 6bmtt IIpttroBopeHbl cy,a;oM K CMepTHOH Ka3HH, KOTOpaR 6hma 11p0Be,a;etta HOqbIQ Toro )l(e ,ll;HJi2.

TeM He Mettee BOCCTaHtte CaH,a;a, BepORTHO, CTaJIO TOJibKO O,ll;HHM H3 11epBbIX CTOJIKHOBeHHH YypKOB c K)'p,ll;aMH.T..J:epe3 ,a;Ba ro,a;a 110 TeM )l(e IIpttqHHaM B paHOHe ropbl ApapaT BCIIhIXHYJIO CJie,ll;yIOIQee BOCCTaHtte (1927-1931), KOTOpoe 6hmO 110,a;rOTOBJieHO BOeHHblM KOMHTeTOM «Xoif6ytt» («He3aBHCHMOCTh») H B03rJiaBJieHO K)'p,ll;OMYixcaHOM Hyptt3.

OcHOBHOe OTJIHqtte OT BOCCTaHHJi 1925 r. 3aKJIIOqaJIOCh B TOM, qTo K IIpOTHBOpeqJfJ{M TIO IIOBO,ll;y K)'p,ll;CKOMHe3aBHCHMOCTH, KOTOpyIO 11pe,a;cTaBttTeJIH 3TOro ttapo,a;a CTpeMHJIHCh IIOJiyqttTb, ,a;o6aBHJIOCh eIQe H TJi)KeJIOe

1 focpal1l.ilH M.A. Kyp~bI 1'yp111111 BHOBeiirnee BpeMH. EpeBaH: NiacTaH, 1990. C.61-114.

2 Kupeee H. r. l1crnpIDI ... C. 167.

3 focpal1l.ilH M.A. YKa3. coq. C. 150.

169

COD;Ha.TlbH0-3KOHOMifqecKoe ITOJIO:>KeHHe, Bbl3BaHHOe pe3KHM pOCTOM u;eH Ha npO,ll;OBOJibCTBHe.

Ha roro-BOCTOKe CTPaHbI BOCCTaHHe 6bmo :>KeCTOKO no,n;aBJieHo, a Kyp,ll;bI 6bmH BbIH)l)K,ll;eHbl Tin;aTeJibHO npO,n;yMbIBaTb TaKTHK)'HaCT)'IIJieHJrnIf npo- ,ll;BHH}'TbCHB Ma.Tio,n;oczyrrHhIH pai1oH rophI ApapaT H 6JIH3Jie:>KaID;He paifoHhI Batta, Myrna, 6HTJIHCa.

0,n;HaKo B perHoH 6hmH nepe,n;HCJion;HpoBaHbI npaBHTeJibCTBeHHbie BoifcKa, ITOCTOHHHO ITOJiyqaIOID;He ITO,ll;KpeITJieHH.fl ,l1;JIH no,n;aBJieHHH npoTeCTOB. E,iJ,HHCTBeHHOH rro,n;,n;ep:>KKOH K)'p,ll;CKHXOTpH,ll;OB CTaJIH ,n;anrnaKH - ,n;eH-

TeJIH KOHTPpeBOJIIOD;HOHHOH napTHH ApMeHHH, roTOBbie no,ZJJJ;ep:>KaTb noCJie co6bITHH 1915 r. BCex, KTO opraHH3yeT KaKY1Q-JIH60 ,ll;eHTeJibHOCTb rrpOTHB Typn;HH. ITOMHMO 3Toro ,n;anrnaKaM 6bmO oco6eHHO BbirO,ll;HO MeCTOITOJIO:>KeHHe BCITblXHYBlllero BOCCTaHH.fl. fopa ApapaT c ,n;aBHHX BpeMeH cqHTaeTCH CHMBOJIOM BeJIHKOif ApMeHHH, KOTopyro ,n;arnHaKH cTpeMlfJIHCh rrocTpOHTb, a B ycJIOBHHX ITO,ll;HHBllleroc.H B 3TOM perHOHe BOCCTaHH.fl 3TO rrpHo6peJIO oco6hIH CHMBOJIH3M.

IToCJie Toro, KaK BOCCTaHHe CTa.TIO HOCHTb ,ll;JIHTeJibHbIH xapaKTep, conpoBO:>K,D;aBlllHHC.fl HenpepbIBHbIMH CTOJIKHOBeHHHMH, napJiaMeHT Typn;HH npe,n;rrpHHHJI norrbITK)'yperyJIHpoBaTb Kott<l>JIHKT ITYTeM co3,n;aHHH rrpHMHpHTeJihHOH KOMHCCHH, D;eJiblO KOTOpoif 6hma BCTpeqa c JIH,D;epoM ITOBCTaH- u;eB 11. HypH. HecMoTpH Ha rrpe,ll;Jlo:>KeHHbie KOMHCCHeif rrpHBlfJierHH B BH,D;e aMHHCTHH If npe,n;ocTaBJieHH.fl noqeTHOro rocy,n;apCTBeHHOrO IIOCTa npe,n;- BO,ll;HTeJIIO BOCCTaHHH, 11. HypH OT o6In;eHapo,n;HbIX u;eJieH He OTKa3aJICH H ttacTaHBaJI Ha rrpe,n;ocTaBJieHHH He3aBHCHMoro cTaryca Kyp,n;HcTatty, qTo npe,a;cTaBHTeJIH KOMHCCHH 6bmH He HaMepeHbl ,ll;eJiaTb, If B HTOre rreperoBOpbl 3anmH B zyrrHK1.

MHOrHe Hey,n;aqlf Kyp,ll;OB 6bIJIH Bbl3BaHbl He TOJibKO HexBaTKOH KOHCTPYKTHBHOro ,n;HaJiora c BJiaCTHMH, HOH OTCYTCTBHeM y rroBcTattn;eB rpaMOTHOH Koop,n;Httan;HH ,n;eifcTBHH H cpe,n;cTB. B BoeHHOif TexHHKe Kyp,ll;bI 3HaqifTeJibHO ycrynaJIH TypKaM, aKTHBHO HCITOJib3YIOID;HM aBHaD;HIO. B HTOre B 1930-1931 rr. BOCCTaBlllHe 6bIJIH OT6porneHbl K rpaHHn;e c 11paHoM2, a y:>Ke B 1932 r. Typu;HH If 11paH, o6ecrrOKOeHHbie 3a CBOH TeppHTOpHH, no,a;- ITHCaJIH ,n;oroBop o rpattHn;ax.

Dre,n;yroID;ee, ,ll;epCHMCKOe BOCCTaHHe npOH30llillO B 1937-1938 rr. ,ll;a:>Ke Ha <l>otte npOllillbIX Hey,n;aq JIH,D;epbl K)'p,l.l;CKHXITJieMeH 6hIJIH He HaMepeHbl OTczyrraTb OT CBOeti H,l.l;eH yKperrJieHH.fl BJiaCTH B perHOHe. B 3TOT pa3 Bee ClfJibl IIOBCTaHn;eB 6hmH CKOHD;eHTpHpOBaHbl B paifoHe ,ll;epCHMa, KOTOpbIH npeHMyID;eCTBeHHO 6bm HaCeJieH Kyp,a;aMH If HaXO,l.l;lfJICH B Henocpe,a;CTBeHHOH 6JIH30CTH K perHoHaM, y:>Ke nepe:>KHBlllHM cou;HaJibHo-noJIHTHqecKHe npoTeCTbl, qTo IT03BOJIHJIO yqacTHHKaM rrpe:>KHHX BbICTYITJieHHH o6'be,ll;H- HHTbC.fl B HOBOH 6opb6e 3a BJIHHHHe.

HaqaJiaCb OHa c IIOIIbITKH pe<l>opMHpoBaHH.fl o6JiaCTeif Ha BOCTOKe CTpaHbI, rrpe,a;Jio:>KeHHOH M. K. ATaTIOpKoM B xo,a;e era peqlf B rrapJiaMeHTe

1 I'acpamRH M. A YKa3. coq. C. 156.

2 Karpe 0. Osmanh'dan Cumhuriyet'e Ayaklanmalar. istanbul, Paraf, 2013, p. 332.

170