- •Contents
- •Preface
- •Radiation Space Environment
- •Radiation Effects in Microelectronics
- •In-flight Anomalies on Electronic Devices
- •Multi-Level Fault Effects Evaluation
- •Effects of Radiation on Analog and Mixed-Signal Circuits
- •Design Hardening Methodologies for ASICs
- •Fault Tolerance in Programmable Circuits
- •Automatic Tools for Design Hardening
- •Test Facilities for SEE and Dose Testing
- •Using the SEEM Software for Laser SET Testing and Analysis
- •Index
RADIATION EFFECTS ON EMBEDDED SYSTEMS
Radiation Effects
on Embedded Systems
edited by
RAOUL VELAZCO
TIMA Laboratory, Grenoble, France
PASCAL FOUILLAT
Université Bordeaux 1, France
and
RICARDO REIS
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil
A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISBN-10 1-4020-5645-1 (HB)
ISBN-13 978-1-4020-5645-1 (HB)
ISBN-10 1-4020-5646-X (e-book)
ISBN-13 978-1-4020-5646-8 (e-book)
Published by Springer,
P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
www.springer.com
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2007 Springer
No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception
of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered
and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work.
CONTENTS
Preface |
vii |
Radiation Space Environment |
1 |
J.-C. Boudenot (THALES) |
|
Radiation Effects in Microelectronics |
11 |
R.D. Schrimpf (Vanderbilt University) |
|
In-flight Anomalies on Electronic Devices |
31 |
R. Ecoffet (CNES) |
|
Multi-Level Fault Effects Evaluation |
69 |
L. Anghel (TIMA), M. Rebaudengo, M. Sonza Reorda, |
|
M. Violante (POLI Torino) |
|
Effects of Radiation on Analog and Mixed-Signal Circuits |
89 |
M. Lubaszewski, T. Balen, E. Schuler, L. Carro (UFRGS), J.L. Huertas |
|
(IMSE-CNM) |
|
Fundamentals of the Pulsed Laser Technique |
|
for Single-Event Upset Testing |
121 |
P. Fouillat, V. Pouget (IXL), D. McMorrow (NRL). F. Darracq (IXL), |
|
S. Buchner (QSS), D. Lewis (IXL) |
|
Design Hardening Methodologies for ASICs |
143 |
F. Faccio (CERN) |
|
Fault Tolerance in Programmable Circuits |
161 |
F.L. Kastensmidt (UFRGS), R. Reis (UFRGS) |
|
Automatic Tools for Design Hardening |
183 |
C. López-Ongill, L. Entrena, M. García-Valderas, |
|
M. Portela-García (Univ. Carlos III) |
|
v
vi |
Contents |
Test Facilities for SEE and Dose Testing |
201 |
S. Duzellier (ONERA), G. Berger (UCL) |
|
Error Rate Prediction of Digital Architectures: Test Methodology |
|
and Tools |
233 |
R. Velazco, F. Faure (TIMA) |
|
Using the SEEM Software for Laser SET Testing and Analysis |
259 |
V. Pouget, P. Fouillat, D. Lewis (IXL) |
|
PREFACE
Since the loss of Telestar satellite in 1962, as a consequence of a high altitude nuclear test, it is known that natural or man-made radiation may perturb the operation of electronic equipments. Today, space vehicles highly rely on electronics and consequently space radiation effects must be considered at the design phase to guarantee the high-reliability and safety requirements of such projects. Even if spacequalified devices exist, so-called “hardened” with respect to radiation effects at the design and/or the manufacturing level, their high cost and lower performances compared with equivalent commercially available devices (Commercial Off The Shelf, COTS) make mass production components, not designed on purpose for space use, quasi mandatory for space applications. This constitutes a major challenge for the feasibility and success of future missions: on one hand it must be understood as far as possible both the nature and variability of space environment, on the other hand the consequences of this environment on electronic devices has to be evaluated taking into account the constant evolution of the technology and the large scope of device’s types.
Moreover, with the constant progress achieved in the manufacturing technologies, nano-electronics devices have features (transistor’s dimensions, operating frequencies) which make them potentially sensitive to the particles present in the Earth’s atmosphere, even at ground level. The very large presence of integrated circuits in all kind of applications result in a non negligible probability of transient errors, gathered under the acronym ‘SEE’ (Single Event Effects) resulting from the ionization generated by secondary particles issued from the nuclear reactions induced by the impact of atmospheric neutrons with atoms present in the silicon. This makes mandatory, for those applications requiring high reliability/safety, of considering this problem at the early application’s design phase to include the needed hardware/software fault tolerance mechanisms.
The estimation of the sensitivity to radiation of a device or architecture is a mandatory step to get an insight about the impact of radiation on the level of reliability/safety. Such a step requires both radiation ground testing, so-called accelerated tests, performed in radiation facilities such as particle accelerators or laser equipment and software tools modeling the applications environment. Such estimation, particularly when they deal with the Single Event Upset (SEU) phenomena, which results in the perturbation of the content of memory cells, may also require the realization of fault injection campaigns in which the consequences of radiation effects are taken into account at a level for which suitable description of the tackled device are available. The realization and exploitation of the results issued from such off-beam fault injection sessions constitute a source of precious information concerning both the estimation of the sensitivity to SEEs of the studied application and the identification of potential “week points” of a design or architecture supposed to be hardened.
This book aims at providing the reader with the major guidelines for coping with radiation effects on components supposed to be included in today’s application devoted to operate in space, but also in the atmosphere at high altitude or at ground
vii
viii |
Preface |
level. It contains a set of chapters based on the tutorials presented at the International School on Effects of Radiation on Embedded Systems for Space Applications (SERESSA) that was held in Manaus, Brazil, from 20 to 25 November 2005. The book is organized in twelve chapters, the first three dealing respectively with the analysis and modeling of the Space Radiation Environment, the basic mechanisms related with the effects of radiation on electronic devices, a description of a set of known cases of in-flight anomalies on electronic devices due to cumulated or transient effects of radiation.
The following three chapters are devoted to the evaluation of multi-level faults effects and the effects of radiation on analog and mixed-signal circuits that are translated into Single Event Transients (SETs) and Single Event Upsets (SEUs) and the fundamentals of the pulsed laser technique for Single-Event Upset simulation.
The following three chapters deal with mitigation techniques of radiation effects: Hardening By Design” (HBD) methodologies used in CMOS technologies to protect the circuit from radiation effects, the radiation effects on FPGAs and related techniques allowing to mitigate them, and research and development of automatic tools for design hardening.
Finally, the last three chapters are devoted to the description facilities for SEE and dose testing, test methodologies and tools to handle error rate prediction of digital architectures and the possibilities of a pulsed laser system for studying radiationinduced single-event transients in integrated circuits. Three case studies are presented to illustrate the benefits of the spatial and temporal resolution of this technique.
Raoul VELAZCO, Pascal FOUILLAT, Ricardo REIS
April 2007