экономика для чайников

YMeHllweHlfe MOpanllHoro plfeK8

Cnoco6, KOTOpbIM KOMnaHHH, 3aHHMalOmHeCH CTpaXOBaHHeM aBTOM06HJIe~, peUIalOT npo6JIeMy MOpaJIbHOro pHCKa, 3aKJIIOqaeTCH B npe,llJIOlKeHHH ,llHCKOHTa B 06MeH Ha BbICOKHe <ppaHUIH3bI. HanpHMep, <ppaHUIH3a B 1 TbiC. ,110M., KOTOPYlO $I BbI6pan, 6y,l1eT 03HaqaTb, qro

BCHKH~pa3, Kor.na $I notta,ay B aaapHIO H B pe3YJIbTaTe H}')KHO 6Y,l1eT npOH3B0,l1HTb He06xo,l1H­ Mble IIJIaTelKl1, $I 6y,l1y ,I10JIlKeH Ol1JIaTHTb nepBYIO 1 TbIC. ,I10JUI. .

<I>paHUIH3a (OcBoqO)l{,lleHHe CTPaXOBmHKa OT y6bITKOB, He npeBbIUIalOWHX onpe,l1eJIeH­

Horo npoueHTa OT CTPaxOBOit oueHKH. - nOCJIYlKl1T,llJIH MeHH cyweCTBeHHbIM CTHMyJIOM He 6paTb Ha ce6H MOPaJIbHbIit pHCK H He BeCTH MawHHY He6pe)I{Ho. Ii nOCKOJIbKY CTPaxOBaR KOMnaHHH 3HaeT, 'ITO MOH BbiCOKaR <ppaHUIH3a H36aBHT ee OT 60JIbUIHHCTBa MOHX MOPaJIbHbIX np06JIeM, OHH XOTHT npe,llJIO)I{HTb MHe CTPaxOBO~nOJIHC no 60JIee HH3KOit npo­ ueHTHOH CTaBKe, qeM eCJIH 6bI H npe,l1noqen TOJIbKO 100,l1oM. <ppaHUIH3bI.

<1>paHUIH3bI - Pa3YMHbIH cnoco6 COKpaTHTb np06JIeMbI MOPaJIbHOro pHCKa H nOMOqb C,I1e­ JIaTb CTPaxoBaHHe 60JIee npHeMJIeMbIM ,llJIR OTBeTCTBeHHbIX BO,l1HTeJIeit.

AKCKpKMIIHSqKfI rpynn, H,q8HTKt/)KKSqllfl IIHAII.IIAYYM08

.7/ite90C~NI4eOO/lf8CllilelUtb£X tL.az

06w.eCm8eHHble 6Ilaea - 3TO Te BelUH, KOTOphIe He MOryr 6hITh npOH3Be.n;eHhI AJUI no.rryqe­ HHJI npH6hIJIH 'IaCTHhIMH ¢lHPMaMH, nOCKOJIbKY HeT cnoco6a HCKJIIO'IHTh HeruIaTe.lIbmHKOB H3 'IHCJIa nOJIb3YIOmmeCH HMH. HeB03MOJICHOCTb 'laCTHhIX ¢lHpM C BhIro.n;Oa ,lJ;JIH ce6H npOH3BO­ ,nHTh 06meCTBeHHhIe TOsaphI npOH3paCTaeT H3 TOro ¢laKTa, 'ITO 3TH TOsaphI 06JIa,D;aIOT ,D;BywI oco6eHHOCTHMH. 06meCTBeHHhIe TOBaphI HeKOHJCYPeHTHhI H OTHOCHTCH K KaTeropHH HeHC­ KJIIO'IaeMhIX 6JIar.

~CBOaCTBa HeKOHKypeHTHOCTH H HeHCKJIIO'IaeMOCTH 06mecTBeHHoro TOsapa ,neJIalOT CJIOJICHhIM ero npoH3Bo.n;CTBO 'IaCTHhIMH ¢lHpMaMH, KOTophIe He MOryr nOJIyqHTb

rrpH6hIJIb OT ero npOH3Bo,nCTBa. BcnOMHHTe 0 CTapaHHJlX 3aCTaBHTb JIIO,nea npH­ 06peCTH 6HJIeThI Ha ct>eaepsepK, ycrpaHBaeMhIa Ha 0TKPhITOM B03.nyxe. llOCKOJIbKY JIIO,nH 3HaIOT, 'ITO MOryr rrOCMorpeTh Ha Hero 6eCruIaTHO, HM He XO'IerCH rrOKYIIaTh 6HJIeThI. llOCKOJIbKY OHM He XOTHT nOKYIIaTh 6HJIeThI, 3Ha'IHT, HeT cnoco6a co6paTh ,neHbrH, Heo6xo,nHMhIe AJUI OruIaThI ,naHHOro 3peJIHma.

3Ta np06JIeMa H3 pa3pH,lla "'ITO nOHBHJIOCb paHbme - JCYPHu;a HJIH HHU;O", rrOCKOJIbKY XOTH JIIO,D;H H He XeJIaIOT ruIaTHTh 3a 'ITO-TO, 'ITO MOJICHO nOJIY'lHTh 6ecruIaTHO, ¢leifepBepK HM ,neaCTBHTe.lIbHO MpaBKI'CH, a 3TO 3HatDIT, 'ITO OHH B npHHU;Hne rOTOBhI 3aruIaTHTh 3HHYJO CYM­ MY 3a TO, 'IT06hI nOCMorpeTh Ha Hero. llpo6JIeMa B TOM, 'IT06hI HaaTH cnoco6, n03BOJIHIOmHH c,neJIaTb 3TO.

Hanoroofino)l(eHMe C~enblO npeAOCTaBneHMH OfiLL\eCTBeHHbIX finar

~6JIar eCTb BMemaTeJIbCTBO rocy,napCTBa H HCrrOJIb30BaHHe iJ.eHer, no.rryqeHHhIX B pe­ 3YJIbTare c60pa HaJIOroB, lJ)IJI OruIaThI 3THX 6JIar. ECJIH roBOpHTh 0 ¢leaepBepKax, TO

nOCKOJIbKY KaJK,IJ;OMY 113 Hac OHH HpaBHTCH, TO MOJICHO 6e3 rrpo6JIeM nOJIytJ:HTh ,nOC­ TaTO'IHYIO nOJIHTH'IecKYIO nOiJ.iJ.epXKY AJUI HCn0JIb30BaHHJI HaJIOroBhIX ,neHer Ha ycT­

poaCTBO ct>eaepBepKOB. H nOCJIe TOro, KaK ¢leHepBepK 6y,neT OruIa'IeH HaJIororuIa­ TeJIbmHKaMH, I<llJIC,D;hIa H3 Hac CMoxeT nOJII060BaTbCH 3THM KPaCHBhIM 3peJIHmeM.CaMhIM pacrrpocrpaHeHHhIM pemeHHeM rrpo6JIeMhI rrpe,nOCTaBJIeHHJI 06meCTBeHHhIX

HCTOpH'leCKH TlI.K CJIO)(QfJIOCb, 'ITO OGoPOH}' C'fP3HhI 0OOcnelfllBaJIO roey.n;apCTBO, nOCKOJIb­ KY 06opoHa TllIOKe OTHOCHTCg K HeHCKJIIOtraeMhIM 6JIaraM H HeKOH~HTHhIM 06meCTBeH­ HhIM TOBapaM. HanpHMep, H3-3a TOro, qTO"3amHTa Bawero rocy.n;apCTBa OT HH03eMHbIX 3a­ BOeBaTeJIeit gBJIJleTCg HeHCKJIIOqaeMhIM 6JIaroM, BCer.n;a cymeCTByeT Co6JIaJH 3a Hee He IUIa­ THTb, nOCKOJIbKY KlUK,!J;hIit 3HaeT, qTO eCJIH 6y.n;YT IUIaTHTb .n;pyrHe, TO eMy TaIOKe - npuqeM OOcIUIaTHO! - npe.n;OCTaBgT TaxyIO xe 3amHTY OT HHOCTpaHHbIX 3axBa~KOB.A nOCKOJIbKY 3amHTa roey.n;apcTBa OTHOCHTCg K paJpg.n;y HeKoHKYPeHTHbIX, TO KlUK,lJ;OMy H3 Hac H3BeCTHO, qTO OO3OnaCHOCTb, nonyqaeMaJI HaMH, 6y.n;eT TaKOro xe KaqeCTBa, KaK H Y BCex OCTaJIbHbIX.

3ToT cPaKT Toxe YMeHbwaeT CTHMYJI 3aIUIaTHTb. B HTOre rocy.n;apCTBO npH.n;YMaJIO cxeMY, no KOTOpoit JIIO.n;H COBMeCTHO OIUIaqHBaIOT pacxo.n;bI Ha rocy.n;apcTBeHH}'IO 6e3OnaCHOCTb - ,ll;JIJI 3TOro 6hIJIH yCTaHOBJJeHhI HaJIOm.

HaJIOrK H cymeCTBeHHaJI qaCTb rocy.n;apcTBeHHldX pacxo.n;OB 3aqacTYIO BhICMeHBllIOTCg, KaK HllIIPacHaJI TpaTIi.n;eHer (H .n;eitCTBHTeJIbHO, OqeHb qacro HX TpaTJIT Ha nycTJIKH), HO H)')KHO He 3a6b1BaTb 0 TOM, 'ITO BO MHOrHX cnyqaJIX Ha,JIOm ....,.. e.n;HHCTBeHHhIit cnoc06 OIUIaTHTb WHpO­

KHit cneKTP 06me,cTBeHHbIX TOBapoB, KOTQPhIMH Bce MhI IIOJIb3yeMCg. XOTg BceM HaM He Hpa­ BHTCg IUIaTHTb HaJIOm, CKopee Bcero, HHKOMY He JaXOqeTCg COKPaTHTb HaJIOroBoe 6peMJI - H B pe3YJIbTaTe JIHWHTbCg apMHH, OCTaTbCg 003 ropO.!lCKHX TeHHCTbIX IIapKOB, HHKor.n;a He BH­

.n;eTb cPeitepBepKOB, He e3,lJ;HTb no .n;oporaM H He nOJIb30BaTbCg 06meCTBeHHoit KaHaJIH3llUHeit H MHOrKM .npyrHM. ECJIH 6hI rocy.n;apcTBo He 3aCTllBJIIDIO Hac OIUIaqHBaTb BCe 3TH BemH, MhI, CKopee acero, )(QfJIH 6hI 003 HHX - BO BCgKOM CJIY'Iae, nOJIY'IaJIH 6hI HX He B TlI.KOM KOJIuqeCT­ Be H KaqeCTBe, KOTOphIMH paCIIOJIaraeM ceitqac.

npMBne'leHMe cl»MnaHTponOB AnSI c03AaHMSI 061L\eCTBeHHblx 6nar

e~~ Tor.n;a KaK 60JIbWaJI qaCTb 06meCTBeHHbIX TOBapOB OIUIaqHBaIOTCg C IIOMOmbIO .n;e­ Her, nOJIY'IeHHbIX B pe3YJIbTaTe HaJIoroo6JIoXeHHJI," yCTaHOBJIeHHoro roey.n;apCTBOM,

~ eCTb H TaKHe TOBaphI, 3a KOTOpble IUIaTfl qaCTHble JIHua. B caMOM ueHTpe nOC­

~eJIeca,r.n;e IIpOWJIO Moe .n;eTCTBO, paJ6HT OrpOMHblit H npeKPaCHbIit roPHhIit napK, HaJBaHHhIit fpHcP<PHT-IIapK. 3eMJIJl,ll;JIJl 3TOro napKa 6hIJIa IIo.n;apeHa ropo.n;y MHJIJIHOHepOM no HMeHH fpHcPcPHT ~. fpHcPcPHT. 3To 03HaqaeT, ~O 3TOT qeJIOBeK npe.n;OCTaBHJI 06mecTBeHHhIH TOBaP 3a C06cTBeHHhItf CqeT.

B .npeBHeH fpeUHH H PHMe cPHJIaHTpOnhI .n;eJIaJIH .n;axe GoJIbwe; GoraTble apHCTOKpaTbI 3a­ HHMaJIHCb CTpOHTeJIbCTBOM .n;opor, aKBeJlYKOB H xpaMOB, KOTOPhIMH IIOJIb3OBaJIHCb BceM MH­ poM. H3BecTHhI CJIY'IaH, Kor.n;a Goran.i.e JIIO,ll;H OIUIaqHBaJIH UeJIhIe apMHH ,ll;JIJI TOro, qTOOhI BO BpeMR BOitHhI nOCJIaTb HX Ha 3aIUHTY C'IPaHhI.

TaK qTO, IIOJKaJIyHCTa, He .nYMam-e, 'ITO TOJIbKO rocy.n;apcTBO MoxeT npe.!lOCTaBHTb 06me­ CTBeHHhIe 6JIara. Ho BapHaHT npe.n;oCTaBJIeHHJI 06mecTBeHHbIX 6JIar rocy.n;apcTBOM GoJIee Ha­

.n;exeH, nOCKOJIbKY B 3TOM CJIyqae He H)')KHO 3aBHceTb OT me.npOCTH GoraTbIX cPHJIaHTpOIIOB, KOTOphIe COBepWeHHO He 06g3aHhI TpaTHTb c06CTBeHHhIe cpe.n;CTBa Ha ynyqrneHHe XH3HH 06­ mecrna BMecTO TOro, ~hI npH06peTaTb TOBaphI ,nJUI ce6g JIH'lHO.

ITpOWY Bac He c.n;eJIaTb pacnpoC'IPaHeHH}'IO OWH6KY, npe.n;nOJIOXHB, ~o 06meCT­ BeHHhIe 6JIara HaJBaHbI 06meCTBeHHbIMH IIO npHqHHe TOro, ~o HX 06hIqHO npe­

.n;OCTaBJIJleT roey.n;apcTBo, a He qaCTHhIit ceKTOp 3KOHOMHKH. 3KOHOMHCTbI HaJhIBa­ lOT HX 06mecrneHHhIMH 6JIaraMH nOTOMY, 'ITO qaCTHhIe cPHpMhI He MOrYT nQnyqHTb npH6hIJIb OT HX npoH3BO.n;CTBa, a He nOTOMY, 'ITO OHH .n;0JI)KHhI 6hITb npoH3Be.n;eHhI roey.naPCTBOM. <l>HJIaHTpOIIhI-qaCTHHKH MOrYT npOH3BO.n;HTb 06meCTBeHHhIe TOBa­ phI 0030 BCgKOit IIOMOmH co CTOpoHhI rocy.n;apcrna.

npeAocTasneHMe 06lQeCTBeHHOrO TOBapa

nyTeM npOAalKM '1aCTHOrO TOBapa

~~TeJleBH3HOHHLIe npOrpaMMhI - TOBap 06IUeCTBeHHhIit IIocJIe TOro KaK TeJIeCHrHaJI

OrneT: nOTOMY qro TeJIeBH3HOHHaH HH.llYCTPHSI H3hICKBJIa cnoc06, KOr,lla TeJIeBH,lleHHe CaMO no ce6e HBJIHeTCH TOaapoM 06IUecTBeHHbIM, HO peKJIaMa, KOTOpo1l conpoBO)((JJ,aIOTCSI TeJIenpo­ rpaMMbI, HBJlHeTCSI caMhIM HaCTORIUHM qaCTHhIM TOBapoM, 3a KOTOpbI1I MO:lKHO Ha3HaqHTb 6oJIbIIIYIO lleHY. 3To 03HaqaeT, qro eCJIH KaK01l-HH6Y,llb npOH3BO,llHTeJIb MaIIlHH HJIH nHBOBap, HJIH H:maTeJIb peBOJIIOIIHoHHo1l HOB01I KHHrn no 3KOHOMHKe B)lCeJlTO-qepHo1l 06JIOXKe, 3a­

XOqeT nOKa3aTb peKJIaMY cBOe1l npo,llyKIIHH MHJIJIHOHaM TeJIe3pHTeJIe1l, KOTopble 6ecllJIaTHo nO,llKJlIOqaIOTCH K o6IUecTBeHHOMY TOBapy no,ll HaJBaHHeM "TeJIeBH,lleHHe", OHH (peKJIaMO,lla­

TeJIH) ,llOJl:lKHhI 6y.llYT 3anJIaTHTb 3a 3<PHPHoe BpeMH, OTBe,lleHHOe ,llJISI HX peKJIaMbI.

«1>oK)'C TeJleBH,lleHHSl COCTOHT B TOM, qro npo.n;aHHhI1I qaCTHhIM 06PaJOM TOBap no,ll HaJBa­ HHeM "peKJIaMa" OnJIaqHBaeT 6ecnJIaTHo npe,llOCTaBJIHeMhIii TOBap no,ll HaJBaHH~M "TeJIeBH­ ,lleHHe". B OOJIee orpaH~eHHOM 06'beMe, HO TOqHO TaK )ICe, ,lle1lCTBYIOT H raJeThI. XOTSI OHH H nonyqaIOT HeKOTOpYIO CYMMY ,lleHer OT CBOHX nO,llnHC~KOB HJIH TeX, KTO ,llaeT CBOH Ooo,SlB­ JIeHHSl, Bce )ICe OrpOMHaH qaCTb HX ,llOXO,llOB nOCTYllaeT OT peKJIaMhI, MeCTO,llJlSl paJMellleHHSI KOTOpoil: OHH npo,llaIOT.

nO'IeMy HOBbie TeXHonorMM OTHOCRTCR K 06lQeCTBeHHbiM TOBapaM

MbI )!{HBeM BO BpeMeHa 6hICTPO nOBhIllIaIOIUHXCH )!{H3HeHHhIX CTaH,llapTOB. IIoqeMY 3m npoHCXO,llHT? IIOTOMY, qro cymeCTBYIOT OpraHH3aIIHH, KOTopbIe 3a60TS1TCH 0 co:maHHH HOBhIX H ynyqIlleHHhIX TeXHOJIOrH1I, n03BOJUIIOIUHX HaM npoH3BO,llHTb 60JIbIlle TOBapOB H ycJIyr H3 HMeIOIUHXCH B HarneM pacnopHXeHHH pecypcOB, HJIH npoH3BO,llHTb COBepIlleHHO HOBbie TOBa­ phI H ycJIyrH, KOTOphIe paHee npOH3BeCTH 6hIJIO HeB03MO:lKH0.

TeXHOJIOr~ecKHiI:nporpeCC - TOBap 06IUeCTBeHHbI1t.H no 3T01I npHqHHe o6111ecTBo ,ll0JI:lKH0 6hI.!I0 Ha1tTH cnoc06 OOecneqHTb TeXHOJIOrnqecKH1I nporpeCC npH ycJIOBHH, qro qaCT­ HbIe JIHlla H qmpMhI 6y.llYT HMeTb He60JIbIll01l CTHM}'JI ,llJlSI H306peTeHHSl HOBbIX TeXHOJIOrH1t.

e~~ ~ TOro qT06b1 nOHHTb, KaK HOBbie TeXHOJIOrnH MOryT 6blTb 06111eCTBeHHhIM TO-

BapoM, ,llaBa1tTe paCCMOTPHM OTKphITHe fyreH6eproM B 1435 ro,lly nO,llBHXHoro ne­ ~ .. qaTHoro npecca. JJ;0 JYreH6epra KHHrn ~epenHChIBaJIHBpyqHfIO. Ho nOCJIe TOro, KaK 6hIJI H306peTeH neqaTHhIiI: npecc, npollecc KHHronpoH3BO,llCTBa CTaJI HaMHOro

60JIee ,lleIlleBhIM.

DOJIee TOro, nO.nyMaiITe 0 TOM, HaCKOJIbKO npocT01I 6hIJIa TeXHOJIOrHSI. B OCHOBHOM ne­ qaTHhI1I npecc - 3TO licero JIHIllb 60JIbIllaH BepCHSI pe3HHOBhIX IllTaMnHKOB, KOTOphIMH TaK JII06m HrpaTb MaJIeHbKHe ,lleTH. Cyrb H306peTeHHSI CTaHOBHJIaCb nOHSITH01l BceM H Ka)((JJ,OMy, KTO 0 HeM CJIhIIllaJI, a 3TO 3HaqHJIO, ~O Ka)((JJ,hIii Mor CaM H3roTOBHTb neqaTHhI1I npecc.

I1TaK, noqeMY no H306peTeHHe Y~OBJIeTB0pSleTxapaxrepHCTHKaM 06mecTBeHHoro TOBapa?

./ OHO 6bIJIO HeKOHKYPeHTHhIM, nOCKOJIhKY C03,D;aHHeH HCnOJIh30BaHHe neqaT­ HOro npecca HHKOHM 06PaJOM He Momo yMeHhIIIHTh BaIIIY JIHqHYIO B03MOX­ HOCTb Co~aTh H HCnOJIh30BaTb neqaTHbIA npecc•

./ OHO B OCHOBe cBoeA SlBIDIeTCH HeHCKJIIOqaeMhIM 6JIaroM, nOCKOJIbKY 3aTPaThI Ha co06meHHe HOBOi!' ~eH ~pyrOMY qeJIOBeKY OqeHb HH3KHe - Bcero JIHilib O~Ha KOP0TeHbKaSI 6ece~a.

B pe3YJlhTaTe OKa3aJIOCb, qTO nOKa 06mecTBo He co~aCTonpe~eJIeHHoroB~a HHCTHTYTOB ~ B03Harp~eHHHreHepaTOpOB HOBhIX H,lleA, ~O Tex nop He 6y~eT CTHMYJIa B B~e 60JIb­ IIIHX npH6bIJIeH ~ pa60ThI B cl!>epe HCCJIe~OBaHHiI:.Be~ B caMOM ~eJIe npecc, KOTOphIH 6bIJI H306peTeH fyreH6eproM, 6hIJI ~OCTyIIeH ~OMY: Bce MomH nepeHHTh ~eIO H He llJIaTHTb

aBTOpy 3a ee HCnOJIh30BaHHe. TaK'ITO nOKa BhI He CyMeeTe Haj;!:m cnoc06 l!>HHaHCOBO B03Ha­ rp~HTh Co~aTeJIei!'HOBhIX H306peTeHHH, y BaC UK 6y~eT HeMHoro.

nSTeHTOSBHHe C L(enblO npeSpSllIeHHfI 061l1eCTSeHHblX 6nsr

S TOSSpW, npe"qHS3HBlfeHHWe Anfl nHIfHoro nOTpe6neHHfI

#-lHr PeIIIeHHe np06JIeMhI 3aKJIIOqeHO B co~aHHH naTeHTOB. npe~OCTaBJUISIH306peTa­ I~ TeJIHM 3KCKJII03HBHOe npaBO B TeqeHHe 20 JIeT nOCTaBJIHTh Ha PhIHOK H npO~aBaTh

\~ CBOH H306peTeHHSI, naTeHTblC03~aJIHHe06xo~HMbliI:cPHHaHcoBhIiI: CTHMyJI MSI TOro, qT06hI onpe~eJIeHHaSIKaTeropHH rp~aH CMoma nOTPaTHTb c06cTBeHHoe BpeMSl H 3HeprHIO, He06xo~HMYIO~ C03~aHHHHOBhIX TeXHOJIOrnil:, KOTophIe 6y­

~ nOJIe3HhI ~ Bcex. 11 He ~aeH TOT l!>aKT, qTO CTpeMHTeJIbHhIiI: 3KOHOMHqe­ CKHiI: POCT HaqaJICSI TOJIbKO nOCJIe TOro, KaK B 3anMHoil: EBpone XVIII BeKa CTaJIH IIIHpOKO npHMeHSlTbCH oxpaHSleMhIe rocy~apcTBOMnaTeHThI.

Cy6CH"qHpOSSHHe HCCne"qOSSHHfI TeXHOnorHii,

KOTopble He MOryr 6WTb 3snBTeHTOSBHbI

Ho ~axe B HaUIH ~HH He K~aSI HHHOBaUHH MoxeT 6hITh 3anaTeHTOBaHa. 31'0 npOHC­

XO~HT nOTOMy, qTO BhI MoxeTe 3anaTeHTOBaTh TOJIbKO qTO-TO BHOBb H306peTeHHoe, a He OT­ KPhIToe H3 yxe cymecTByIDmero B npHpo~e. HanpHMep,eCJIH BhI np~aJIH XHMHqecKHiI:

npo~, KOTOphIH paHee He cymeCTBOBaJI, H 3areM CMOrJIH ero CHHTe3HpOBaTh, BhI MoxeTe 3anaTeHTOBaTh ero. Ho eCJIH npocTO OTKPbITb roroBhIi!' XHMJIlIeC~ripo~, KOTOphIiI:, 6y~­

qu HeH3BecTHhIM IIIupOKOil: ny6JIHKe, npocro llJIaBaJI r~e-HH6y~B MOpe HJIH 3aJIeraJI B rpYH­

Te, ero BaM 3anaTeHTOBaTh He y~acTCSI.

3'1'0 CTaHOBHTCSI 60JIbiliOH np06JIeMoil: B onpe~eJIeHHhIX ~aHX, Kor~a, K npHMepy, yqe­ HbIe npOBO~T HCCJIe~OBaHHHC ueJIbIO 06HapyxeHHH cnoc06a JIeqeHHSI paKoBhIX 3a60JIeBa­ HHH, nOCKOJIbKY MHorne nOTeHUHaJIbHhIe JIeKapCTBeHHhIe npenapaThI OTHOCHTCH K rpynne XHMHKaJIHiI:, nonyqaeMhIX H3 paCTeHHi!' H XHBOTHhIX, XHMHKaJIHiI:, KOTOphIe ~OJIrHe BeKa cy­ meCTByIDT B npHpo~e. 3TH XHMJIlIeCKHe npenapaThI HMeIOT OrpoMHyID nOTeHUHaJIbHyID nOJIb­ 3Y, HO nOCKOJIbKY OHH He MOryT 6hITh 3anaTeHTOBaHhI, HHKTO He pacnOJIaraeT ~OCTaTOqHOBe­

COMhIM l!>irnaHcoBhIM CTHMYJIOM CTapaTbCSI OTKP~ HX.

B pe3YJIbTaTe rocy~apcTBOH MHoxecTBO l!>O~OB, co~aHHhIxHa ~eHbrn l!>HJIaHTPOnOB­ H~HB~aJIOB,BKJIMhIBaIOT cpe~CTBaB Te cl!>ephl HaYKH, r~e npo6JIeMa 06meCTBeHHhIX TOBa­

poB MOXeT orpaHHqHTb HCCJIe~OBaHHH.

nO.l106Hoe peWeHHe OqeHb BaJIQIO ,lJ)ISI 3KOHOMHCTa, nOCKOJIbKY npe.llOCTaBJIeHHe 06m;ecT­ BeHHhIX 6JIar OTHOCHTCH K reM 3KOHOM~eCKIIMnpo6JIeMaM, KOTOpble phlHKH H "HeBH,llHMaH

PYKa" peWHTb He MOlYf. ,[lpyroit BH.ll HeCOCTOHTeJIbHOCTH pblHKa - aCHMMeTPHqHOCTb HH­ <popMaUHH - 06JIa.uaeT .llOCTaTOqHO xopOIllllM: Ha60poM peweHHit (06 3TOM paCCKl13b1BaeTCH B pa3.lleJIe "BTOPaH :lKH13Hb XOpOWHX Bem;eit: peweHHe np06JIeMbl 6apaxOJIOK" paHee B 3Toii

maDe).

Ho .llO rex nop, nOKa 06w:ecTBO He nplf.llYMaeT Y.llaqHYJO cxeMY ,lJ)ISI npe.llOCTaBJIeHHH 06w:e­ CTBeHHhIX TOBapoB, OHO nOCTOHHHO 6Y.lleT repneTb onpe.lleJIeHHble JIHWeHHH. ):(rrsI TaKOro BH,lla 06m;eCTBeHHblX 6JIar, KaK .lleMOHCTPaUHH <l>eitepBepKoB, 3m e.llBa JIH 6Y.lleT HMeTb 3HaqeHHe. Ho ,lJ)ISI BHe.llpeHHH reXHOJIOlWIeCKHX HHHOBaUHii - K npHMepy, B o6JIacTH JIeqeHHH paKOBhIX 3a60JIeBaHHit - 3m B 6YKBaJIbHOM CMblCJIe Bonpoc XH3HH H CMevm.

J)a6'U'I :Puitaful(J

,lJ;aBH,ll PHIGlP.nO (1772-1823) OTICphIJI CPllBHHTeJIbHbIe npeHMylIJ,eCTBa H CnpllBe.D:JIHBO .no­

Ka3aJI, 'ITO npH Me:lK,ll,yuapo.nuoit ToproBJIe BbIHIPbIBalOT 06e CTOpoHbI, Me)lGJy KoroPhIMH ocy­ meCTBJUIIOTCSI TOproBbIe onepamm. CpaBHHTeJIbHOe npeHMylIJ,eCTBO pll3pymHJIO HHTeJIJIeKTY­ aJIbH}'IO peCneKTa6eJIbHOCTb MepKQHmWZU3MQ - OWH60'IHoit TeOpHH 3nOXH KOJIOHHaJIH3Ma,

KOTOPasr npe.nCTaBJISIJIa TOproBJIIO O.nHOCTOpOHHeA H, CJIe.nOBaTeJIbHO, .nOKa3bIBaJIa, 'ITO TOp­ roBJISI .nOJDKHa 6bITb yCTaHOBJIeHa.D:JISI nOJIy'IeHHSI BbIrO~bI o.nHoA CTPaHbI-MaTepH 3a C'IeT ee

KOJIOHHAI.

K TOMY xe, PHKap.nO npaBHJIbHO npOaHaJIH3HpOBaJI 3KOHOMHtIeclGdi: l!>eHoMeH YMeHbWe­ HHSI OT.na'IH, KOTOpbI1t o6'bSIcIDIeT, nO'IeMY npH YBeJIH'IeHHH ypoBIDI npOH3BO.nCTBa JaTPaTbi HMeIOT Teu.neHQHIO K YBeJIH'IeHHIO. OH TaKXe 6hIJI O.nHHM H3 nepBbIX pa,n:HKaJIbHbIX CTOpOH­ HHKOB KOJIH'IeCTBeHHo1t TeOpHH .neHer - H,lleH 0 TOM, 'ITO YBeJIH'IeHHe .neHexuoit MaCCbI npH­ Be.neT K YBeJIHtIeHHIO QeH.

KaPJI MapKc (1818-1883) 6hIJI nepe.nOBbIM 3KOHOMHCTOM CBoero BpeMeHH. HH o.niIa H3 ero OCHOBHbIX 3KOHOMHtIeCKHX TeOpHit B HawH .nHH .nOBepHeM He nOJIb3yeTCH, HO nOCKOJIbKY B XX BeKe CTOpOHHHKH MapKCHCTCKHX H,lle1tnpHIllJIH K BJIaCTH B .necSITKaX CTPaH, OH, 6e3­ YCJIOBHO, HBJISIeTCSI O.nHHM H3 caMbIX BJIHSITeJIbHhIX 3KOHOMHCTOB, KPr.na-JIH60 :JKHBymHX Ha Haweit 3eMJIe. (MapKCY H OTBeJI 6o.Jq>we BCero TeKCTa He noroMY, 'ITO OH - CaMbIit BaxHbIit 3KOHOMHCT H30 Bcex, nepe'IHCJleHHhIX B 3TOM CnHCKe, a noroMy, 'ITO MIle JIYXHO 6hIJIO o6'bSIc­ HUTh ero H,lleH nepe.n TeM, KaK HX .D:HCKpe.D:HTHpOBaTb. Hneu JJ:Pyrnx 3KOHOMHCTOB U3 .naHHoro CnHCKa yxe 6bIJIH .neTaJIbHO 06'bSIcHeHbI B JJ:Pyrnx rJIaBaX 3TOit KHHrH.)

CaMbI1t KpynHbIit no BaJKHOCTH HHTeJIJIeKTYaJIbHbI1t BKJIa,n: MapKca - 3TO H,lleH 0 TOM, 'ITO

KanHTaJIH3M eCTb HCTOpHtIeCKH YUHKaJIbHasr «lK>PMa COQHaJIbHOit H npoH3Bo.nCTBeHHoit opra­ HH3aQHH. B cBoeit KHHre "KanHTaJI" OH aHaJIlpupyeT KanHTaJIH3M KaK cOBepweHHo HOB}'IO $OPMY COQHaJIbHOit H 3KOHOMHtIecKOH OpranH3aQHH, OCHOBaHnyIO Ha HaKOnJIeHHU KanHTa­ JIa H npOMbIWJIeHHoro npoH3Bo.nCTBa. OH Hll3bIBaJI BJIa,n:eJIbQeB 3llBO.nOB "KanHTaJIHCTaMH" H

.nOKll3bIBaJI, 'ITO OHH 6hIJIH BbIHY:lK,lI,eHbI 3KcIIJIYaTHpoBaTb pa60'IHX, KoropbIe pa60TaJIH Ha HX

~ npOH3BO.nCTBe.

B 'IaCTHOCTH, OH 6hIJI HCKpeHHe yGe:lK,ll,eH, 'ITO e.nIl:HCTBeHHO KalIHTaJIUCTbI BHHOBaTbi BO BceM, H HX 6H3Hec pacwupSIeTCSI TaM, r.ne pa60'IHM nJIaTSIT,MeHbwe .neHer, He06xo.nHMhIX.D:JISI BbDKHBllHHSI. TaKHM 06p1l30M, .naxe eCJIH npOH3BO.D:HTeJIbl:lOCTb H npo.llYKT pocJIH 6bICTpo, pa­ 60'IHe XHJIH B yCJIOBHSIX nOCTOHHHoit, HeBbIHOCHMoit 6e.nuOCTH, H3 KoropoA HeT HHOro cno­ c06a BbI6paTbCSI, KpOMe KaK HaCHJIhCTBeHHbIM 06Pll30M CBeprHYTb KanHTaJIHCTOB - TaKHM

06pll3OM pa60'IHe MOrJIH nOJIY'IHTb KOHTPOJIb Ha,n: '3llBO.naMH.

MapKC .nOKll3bIBaJI, 'ITO 3TOMY HaCHJIbCTBeHHOMY CBepxeHHIO 6y.neT cnoC06CTBOBaTb TO, 'ITO OH paccMaTPHBaJI KaK HeH36eXHYJO Teu.neHQHIO K KOHQeHTPaQHH KanHTaJIa H MOHOno-

I 3KOHOMH'leCKOe yqeHHe H 3KOHOMH'leCKaJI nOJlHTHKa,- OTPaxaBIIIHe HHTepeChI TOProBOro KanHT!l1Ia 3nom, npe):lIIIeCTBOBaBIIIe1l: npoMhlIIIJIeHHOMY :pmHTaJIY. B03HHK B XV BeKe, OCO­ 60e paJBHTHe nOJIY'lHJI B XVI H XVII BeKax. CropoHHHKH MepKllHTIllIH3Ma OIIIH60'IHO nOJIara.JIH, 'ITO HCTO'IHHKOM 60raTcTBa HBJISIeTCH c4Jepa 06paIIIeHHH, a He CcPepa ITpoH3BO):lCTBa, 6oraTCTBO xe OTO)K):le­ CTBJISIeTCH C ):leHbraMH. MepKaHTHJIHCTbI C'IHT!l1IH, 'ITO 6JIarococTOHHHe rocy):lapcTBa 3aBHCHT OT 6OJIb­ woro CKOIIJleHIDI ):leHer - 30JIOTa H cepe6pa - B c1paHe H ):106HB8JIHCb npeo6JIa.llaHHH BhIB03a TOBapoB Ja rpaHHlO' Ha.ll HX BB030M B C1paHY. -

JIH3aI.l,HH. Kor,D;a B KIDlQl;OH H3 OTPaCJIeH npOMbIlIIJIeHHOCTH eCTb TOJlbKO O.D;Ha MOHOrrOJlbHWI cPHPMa, paOO'llIM 6y,D;eT HaMHOro Jlel'le rrO,D;IDlTb 6YHT H 38XBaTHTb BJlaCTb Ha.D; CHCTeMOH.

ECJlH CeHqaC, CrryCTR CTOJleTHe C qeTBepTbIO, rrpOBeCTH peTPOCrreKTHBHblH aHaJIH3, TO MO:lKHO RCHO YBH.D;eTb, qTO MapKC B CBOHX 3KOHOM~eCKHX Cyx,neHIDIX OIIIH6aJICR. B qaCT­ HOCTH, 3apa6OTHWI lIJIaTa pa60qHX CO BpeMeHeM ,D;eHCTBHTeJlbHO, B cpe.D;HeM . OHa rrOBbIIIIaeTCR C TaKOH CKOPOCTbIO, C KaKOH, TeXHOJlO~eCKHeHHHOBaI.l,HH YBeJIH'llIBalOT

YPOBeHb IIpoH3BO.D;HTeJIbHOCTH. 3To IIpoHCXO.D;HT rrOTOM}', qro KalIHTaJIHCTbl KOHKYPHPYIOT 3a orp~eHHoerrpe.D;JIOXeHHe TPY,D;OBhIX peCYPCOB, H BeJI~HHa 3apa60THOH lIJIaTbl paCTeT C TaKOH CKOpocTblO, qT06b1 rrpoH3BO,D;CTBeHHble yCOBepIIIeHCTBOBaHHR rr03BOJlHJlH O.D;HOMY Ka­ rrHTaJIHCTY rrOBbICHTb 3apa6OTHyIO lIJIaTY C I.I,eJlbIO rrepeMaHHBaHHR pa60qHX y .D;pymx KarrH­ TaJIHCTOB.

K TOMY xe, KOHKYPeHI.J;HR He rrplIBO.D;HT K TOM}', qTOObi B KIDlQl;OH OTPaCJIH rrpoH3BO,D;CTBa ,IlOMHHHpoBaJIa O,D;Ha MOHOrrOJlLHWI cPHPMa. BMeCTO 3TOro B 60JlbIIIHHCTBe OTPaCJIeH HaJI~e­

CTByeT xeCTKWI KOHKYPeHI.l,HR, KOTOpWl H rrpe,D;OCTaBJlSleT 3KOHOMHKe Bee BbIro.D;bl "HeBH.D;H­ MOH PYKH" MaMa CMHTa•

./!.,tbtpfte9 vIIajultfLU

AJIb$pe,D; MapIIIaJIJI rrpHMeHHJI MeTO,D; crrpoca H rrpe.D;JIOXeHHR .D;JIR aHaJIH3a ,D;eRTeJlbHOCTH pbIHKOB. npHMeHHB MaTeMaTHKY K 06hl1cHeHHIO 3KOHOM~eCKOHTeOpHH, OH cyMeJl qeTKO OT,D;eJIHTb CMelqeHUe Iq)HBhIX cIlpoca H IIpe.D;JIoxeHHR OT .D;BH)KeHHR 600/lb KpHBbIX

cIIpoca Hrrpe.D;JIoxeHHR. Ero HaxO.D;Ka pacIq)bIJIa OIIIH60'IHOCTb ymepxmeHHH, KOTOpble cyII.J;e­ CTBOBaJIH.D;Be TbICflH JleT. K TOMY xe OH Cq,oPMYJlHPOBaJI rrO-HaCTO~eMYpeBOJIIOI.J;HOHHYIO H.D;eIO 0 TOM, qro PblHO'IHWI I.I,eHl,l HaxO.D;HTCR B TOqKe rrepeceqeHHR KpHBhIX crrpoca H IIpe.D;JIO­ XeHHR.

3aTeM MapIIIaJIJI rrOIIIeJl ,D;aJIbIIIe H orrpe,D;eJIHJI" qro IIpH cpaBHeHHH TOqeK, pacrrOJlOXeH­ HhIX Ha KpHBhIX crrpoca H rrpe.D;JIOXeHHR, C PbIHOqHOH I.I,eHoH BhI Moxere KOJI~eCT8eHHOorr­ pe,D;eJlHTb BbIro.ny, KOTOpYIO rroope6HTeJIH H npOH3BO.D;HTC.nH H3BJ1eKyT H3 PbIHOqHhIX TPaHCaK­ lUDt. fua BbIro,D;a rrpe,D;CTaBJISIeT C060H, COOTBeTCTBeHHO, H3JlHIIIeK rrQTPe6HTeJIR H H3JlHIIIeK rrpoH3BO,D;HTeJIR, a BMecre OHH COCTaBJISIIOT COBOKYIIHhIH 3KOHOM~eCKHHH3JIHIIIeK.

B HaIIIH .lUfH Bee ew;e HCrrOJlb3yeTCR 3TOT MeTO,D; Ko~eCTBeHHoro OIIpe.lleJIeHHR BbIro.D;bI OT rrpoH3BO,D;CTBa H rrQTPe6JIeHHR; OH <PoPMHPyeT OCHOBY 3KoHOMUlteCKoU meopuu 6JZazococmoRHUR (welfare economics), KOTOPWI H3yqaeT 3aTPaTbI H BbIro.D;bI OT 3KOHOM~eCKOH,D;eRTeJlbHOCTH.

3ToT MeTO,D; TalOKe MO:lKHO Hcrrc)Jlb30BaTb .D;JIR TOro, qT06bI Ha OqeHb rrpOCTOM rpacPHKe rrpo­ ,D;eMOHCTPHpOBaTb CYTb "HeBH.D;HMOH PYKH" MaMa CMHTa. PaBHOBeCHe cBo60.D;Horo pblHKa, 06HapyxeHHoe B TO~e rrepeceqeHHR crrpoca H rrpe.D;JIOXeHHR, 6y,D;eT TaKHM xe, KOTOpoe BbI­ 6epeT HRCTPoeHlIbllt Ha COI.l,HyM IIJIllHHpOBUJ;HK, CTaPWlCb MaKCHMH3HPOBaTb 6J1arococTOSlHHe 06w;ecTBa C rrOMOlllbIO MaKCHMH3auHH COBOKYIIHOro 3KOHOMHqeCKoro H3JlHIIIKa. ):WyrHMH CJIOBaMH, CBo6o,D;HbIH PbIHOK ,D;e:A:CTBHTeJIbHO cPYHKI.I,HOHHPyeT TaK, "KaK eCJIH 6bI HM PYKOBO­

.D;HJIa HeBH.D;HMWI PYKR", pa6oTaIOlUWI Ha 6J1aro 06lUecTBa.

2).J/tOIt·..JIeultaM Ketiltc

.l{JKOH MeHHap,D; KeitHc rrpH.D;yMaJI COBpeMeHHYIO MaKp03KOHOMHKY H H.D;elO

HCrrOJlb30BaHHR 3KOHOM~ecKoroCTHMYJlHpOBaHHR co CTOpoHbI rocy,D;apCTBa .D;JIR rrpeO,D;OJle­ HHR 3KOHOM~ecKorocrra.D;a. 3Ha~eJlbHWI qaCTb MaKpo3KOHOMHKH XX BeKa 6bIJ1a cepHeil:

OTKJIHKOB Ha ero rrpO.D;yKTHBHhIe H.D;eH.

/