B pe3YJIbTaTe Cay,n;OBCKaJI ApaBHH MO)l(eT OKa3aTbCH B nOJIO)l(eHHH HaKa3blBaIOlUero yr
P030it 6aHKpOTCTBa OCTaJIbHble cTPaHbl-1JJIeHhI OPEC npH yCJIOBHH HapymeHHit HMH CBOHX KBOT. K CO)I(aJIeHHIO, B ,n;eHcTBHreJIbHOCTH HaKa3aHHe pa60TaeT He HaCTOJIbKO Xoporuo.
IIp06JIeMa JaKJIIO'IaeTCH B TOM, 'ITO Cay.nOBCKaJI ApaBHH HMeeT orpaHH'leHHble B03MO)l( HOCTH B He$re,n;06blBalOlUHX MOlUHOCTHX. Tor,na KaK Cay,n;OBCKaJI ApaBHH cnoc06Ha npOH3BO
,n;HTb ,n;onOJIHHTeJIbHO Hectrrn B ,n;eHb K TOMY 06'beMY, KOTOPblH OHa nOJIY'laeT 06bl'IHO,
3TO YBeJIH'IeHHe He 6y,n;eT ,n;OCTaTO'IHbIM ,WIH CHIDKeHHH ueHbl ,n;o 3 ,n;0JIJI. Ja 6appeJIb H MO)l(eT npHBeCTH K 6aHKpOTCTBy ,ZJ;pyrHX 1JJIeHOB OPEC.
B pe3YJIbTaTe BbIXO,lJ;HT, 'ITO yrp03a co CTOpOHbl Cay,n;oBCKoit ApaBHH He MO)l(eT 6blTb ,n;OC TaTO'IHO CHJIbHOH,WIH npe06paJOBaHHH ,n;OMHHHPYIOlUeit CTPaTemH H3 "HapymeHHH KBOThI" B "CJIe,n;OBaHHH KBOTe". 11 nOCKOJIbKY OPEC TaK H He HalliJIa cnoc06a ,n;eitCTBeHHoit yrpo3bl ,lJ)UI
B npe,n;bmyIUHX pa3,lJ;eJIax 06'MICIDIeTCH, nO'leMY cTParerHH ".nHJIeMMa 3aKJIlO'IeHHO m" 03Ha'laeT, 'ITO lPHPMbl BO MHOrHX OJIHronOJIbHbIX OTPaCJD1X nepe)I(HBalOT TPy,n; HOCTH C lPOpMHpoBaHHeM 3CPcPeKTHBHbIX KapreJIeit. O,n;HaKO B HeKOTOpbIX OTPaCJUIX KapreJIH iJeucm6UmeJlbHO 3CPll>eKTHBHbI, Kor,n;a pe'lb H,lJ;eT 0 COKpameHHH npo.nyKTa H nOBbIlIIeHHH ueH. 06bI'1HO 3TH QTPaCJIH HMelOT o,n;HY lPHPMY, ,n;OCTaTO'IHO KpynHYIO H BJIHHTeJIbHYIO,WIH TOm, 'IT06hI nO-HaCTOHlUeMY HaKaJaTb ,n;pyrne lPHPMhI, c,n;enaB HX 6aHKpOTaMH.
AOMMHMPYIO~M8cl>MpMbl
B XIX BeKe B CIllA KOMnaHHH Standard Oil Company, PYKOBO,n;HMaJI ,l],xOHOM.n. POKlPeJIJIepOM, ,n;OMHHHpOBaJIa B OJIHrOnOJIbHoit npoMhIlliJIeHHOCTH. OHa KOMTpO JIHpoBaJIa npHMepHO 90% npo,n;aBaeMoit Ha phIHKe CIllA Hectrrn, H eCJIH KOHKfpeH Thl He ,n;enaJIH Tom, 'ITO TPe60BaJIOCb POKcPeJIJIepy, OH npocTO ,n;OBO,n;HJI HX lPHPMY ,n;o 6aHKpOTCTBa, yCTaHaBJIHBaJI faKYIO HH3KYIO ueHY Ha He$Tb, KOTOPYIO He Mor HaJHa'lHTb ero KOHKYIJeHT.
B ,n;eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH, nOCKOJIbKY Standard Oil ocymeOTBJIHJIa TaKOit )I(eCTKHH KOHTPOJIb, ee OTpaCJIb 6hIJIa HaMHoro 60JIblIIe noxoxa Ha MOHOnOJIHIO, '1eM Ha OJIHronOJIHIO.
O,n;HaKO 3ll>$eKTHBHOCTb ,n;eitcTBIIH POKcPeJIJIepa BCKOpe npHBeJIa K BMeruaTeJIbCTBY rocy
.n;apcTBa. Standard Oil 6bma paJ6HTa Ha ,lJ;lO)I(HHy MeMbrum, He3aBHCHMbIX HelPTHHbIX KOMna HHit, HH O,lJ;Ha H3 KOTOPbIX He 6hIJIa ,n;OCTaTO'lHO 6oJIbruoit H BJIHHTeJIbHOit, 'lT06hI ,n;OMHHHPO BaTh B CBoeit 0TPaCJIH H 3aCTaBJIHTh BCTynaTb B TaitHoe COfJIameHHe reM cnoco6oM, KOTOPhIM 3TO ,n;enaJIa Standard Oil.
IlPMM8H8HM8 aHTMTpaCTOBbiX 3aKOHOB
B XIX BeKe KapTeJIH Ha3hIBaJIHCb mpacmOMU - 6hIJI, K. npHMepy, CaxapHhIit TPaCT,
. CTaJIbHOit TPacT, )l(ene3Ho,n;0p0)I(HhIit H T.,n;. II03ToMY 3aKOHhI, KOTophIe TPe60BaJIH paJ6He HHH MOHOnOJIHH H KapTeneit, HaJhIBaJIHCb aHmumpaCm06blMU 3aKOHOMU. CaMhIM H3BeCTHhIM
B COe,lJ;HHeHHbIX IIInnax 6bIJI AHTwrpacroBhIii 3aKOH IIIepMaHa, a ceA1lac H MHome .npyrHe CTPaHbI npOBeJIH y ce6J1 noxoJlQle 3aKoHonpoeKThI, HarrpaBJIeHHbIe Ha pa3,lJ;eJleHHe MOHono mtii H KaPTeJIen.
.eTCH BJIeBO B rrOJIQxeHHe D2, KaCaHCb ICpHBOit ATe B 1'O'lKe B. ITOCKOJIbKY Jq>HBaH crrpoca eUJ,aeTCSI BJIeBO, TOIlHO TaK xe rrocTYJIaeT H ICpHBaH rrpe.u;eJIbHoro .u;oxo.u;a, KOTOpaH rerrepb ~rrOJIO)KHJIaCbHa MR2• Cne.u;OBareJlbHO, Kor.u;a <lJHpMa OITTHMH3HPyeT CBOit ypoBeHb rrpOH3 !l:CTBa, HaxO.z:lHUJ,HitCSI B TOIlKe rrepecelleHHSI ICpHBbIX Me H MR:z, OHa rrpOH3Bo.u;HT q'2 e.u;H II rrpo.u;yKTa.
Me
ATe
a:I
:I:
~P2
°2
q; qeotnp
KOJlI'l'lecTllO
PHC. 13.5. (/>HpMa, pat5oT81O~aSl S ycnOSHSlX MOHonOnHCTH'4eCKO~
Ha pblHKe (HnH YXOAB C pblHKa) nepeMecTHna CSOIO KpHsylO cnpoca
P.O K8CBHHSl C KpHSOH ATC
Ha 3TOM ypoBHe rrpo.u;yKTa rrpH6hlJIb paBHa HYJlIo. Bhl MOXeTe BH.z:leTb 31'0, eCJIH paCCMOT Te rpa<IJHK, KOTOpbIit rrOKa3hlBaeT, 'ITO Cpe,llHHe COBOKYIIHhle H3,l:lepXKH Ha e.u;HHHQY ypOBHH OH3BO,LlCTBa rrpo.u;yKTa q'2 paBHhl ueHe Ha e,LlHHHlly, KOTOPYIO <lJHpMa MOXeT rroJIy'lHTb, rrpo
B 3TH e,LlHmlUhl. ITo.u;HHMaih'ecb BePTHKaJIbHO OT 1'OIlKH, pacrrOJIOXeHHOH Ha roPH30HTllJIb 'it OCH, q"2' .u;o TOIlKH B. ITOCKOJIbKY TOIlKa B JIeXHT H H8 ICpHBOH crrpoca, D2, H H8 KPHBOH e.u;HHX COBOKYIIHhlX H3,l:lepXeK, ATe, TO BePTHKaJIbHhlR 0TPe30K, coe.u;HHHIOJl(HH TOIlKY q"2 roPH30HTaJIbHOH OCH H 1'OIlKY B, rrpe.u;CTaBIDleT H cpe.u;HHe COBOKYIIHhle H3,l:lepXKH Ha e.u;H fUY, H ueHY 3a e.u;HHHllY, KOTOPYIO <lJHPMa MoxeT H83H8IlHTb. OHH paBHhl, TaK 'ITO <lJHpMa iJIY'I8eT HYJIeBYIO rrpH6bIDb.
ECJIH rro KaKOU-TO rrpHllHHe <lJHPMhl, p86OT8IOJl(He B MOHOrrOJIHCTHlleCKH KOHJCYpeHTHOit p8CJIH, H8WHaIOT HeCTH rrOTepH, HeKOTOphle H3 HHX rrOKH,l:laIOT OTP8CJIb. C YXO.u;OM KIDICIlOU (WR <lJHpMhl ICpHBhle crrpoC80CTaBIIIHXCSI B OTP8CJIH <lJHpM rro.u;HHMaIOTCH BBepx H BrrpaBO. no.u; <lJHpM H3 <rrp8CJIH rrpo.u;OJ1)K8eTCH.u;O rex rrop, rrOK8 He 6y.u;eT .u;OCTHrHYTO paBHOBeCHe, 1.u;06Hoe H306paxeHHOMY H8 pHC. 13.5, Kor.u;8 BCe <lJHPMhl rroJIY'IaIOT HYJIeByIO rrpH6bVIb.
aBa 13. Ontfronontffl tf MOHOnOntfCTtflfeClCBfI KOHICYPeHqtffl
293
Heac1'c1'eICTH8Hoe npOH38o,QCT80
OCHOBHOe, 'ITO HYJKHO CKa3aTb 0 paBHOBeCHH, OTPaJKeHHOM Ha pHC. 13.5, 3aKJIIOqaeTCH B CJIe.n:yroIlleM: KIDK,llaH qmpMa npOH3Bo.n:HT npo.n:yKT C MeHbrneD 3q,q,eKTHBHOCTbIO, qeM q,Hp
MbI, q,YHKUHOHHpyroIllHe B KOHKYPeHTHoD OTPaCJIH. ):lmI: TOro qT06bI y6e.n:HTbCH B 3TOM, HYX HO CPaBHHTb 06'beM npOH3Bo.n:CTBa q,HpM, pa60TaIOIllHX B MOHOnOJIHCT~eCKH KOHKypeHTHoD
OTPaCJIH, Kor.n:a OHa HaxO.ll:HTCH B paBHOBeCHH, q"2' C reM 06'beMOM BbIIIYCKa, KOTOPbIit 6bIJl 6bI npOH3Be.n:eH q,HpMOD C TeMH x<:e KPHBblMH JaTPaT, HO B yCJIOBIDIX nOJIHOCTbIO KOHKYPeHTHOD OTPaCJIH, B KOTOPOtt Bce q,HpMbI npo.n:aIOT o.n:HHaKOBbIli npo.n:yrcr. Ha pHC. 13.5 3TOT ypOBeHb rrp0.ll:YKTa 0603HaqeH qcomp.
B maBe 11 06bHcHHeTCH, KaK PbIHOqHbIe CHJIbI no.n:TaJIKHBaIOT KOHKYPHpyroIUHe q,HPMbI npoH3Bo.n:HTh Ha ypoBHe qcomp, H noqeMy B pe3YJIhTaTe OHH OKa3bIBaIOTCH TO~O Ha TOM ypOBHe npo.ll:YKTa, npH KOTOpOM KpHBaH ATe .n:ocmraeT cBoero MHHHMyMa, - 3TO 3HaqHT, qTO qcomp
COOTBeTcTByeT caMoli HHX<:Heli TOqKe U-06pa3HoD KPHBOD ATe. COI.J,HaJIbHO 3HaqHMbIe no CJIe.n:CTBHH 3TOro q,aKTa 3aKJIIOqeHhI B TOM, qTO KOHKYPHpYIOIUHe q,HPMbI npOH3BO,UJIT npo.nyKT no B03MOX<:H0 CaMoit HH3KOli ce6eCTOHMocm B pacqere Ha e.n:HHHuY npo.nyKTa. 3To )].eJIaeT HX MaKCHMaJIhHO 3q,q,eKTHBHbIMH, eCJIH onepHpOBaTb BeJI~HHOli "npoH3Bo.n:CTBeHHbIe 3aTPaTbI B pacqere Ha e.rr:HHHI.J,y npOJl.YKIlHH".
l1>HpMa, q,YHKUHOHHpyroIUaH B MOHOnOJIHCmqeCKH KOHKYpeHTHOD OTPaCJIH, )].elicTByeT B YCJIOBIDIX HHLl.HBHLl.YaJIHJaI.J,HH npOJl.YKIlHH, qTO n03BOJIHeT eli HMeTb HeKOTopbIH KOHTPOJIb HaIl I.J,eHaMH, Ha3HaqaeMbIMH eIO. 3Ta B03MOX<:HOCTb n03BOJIHeT HaJIallHTh npOH3BO)].CTBO npH 60JIee BbICOKHX cpe)].HHX CYMMapHhIX H3Ll.epX<:Kax B pacqere Ha e)].HHHUY npo.nyKTa. 3TO xopo rno BHLl.HO Ha pHC. 13.5, nOCKOJIbKY BePTHKaJIhHbIH OTPe30K OT roPH30HTaJIhHOH OCH)].O TOqKH
B )].JlHHHee, qeM BePTHKaJIhHbID 0TPe30K OT ropH30HTaJIhHOD OCH )].0 TOqKH C. ,naHHhIH q,aKT 03HaqaeT, qTQ q,HPMbI B MOHOnOJIHCTHqeCKH KOHKYPeHTHhIX 0TPacJllIX He 3q,q,eKTHBHbI B ToD Mepe, KOTOpaH npHcym:a q,HpMaM H3 KOHKypeHTHbIX OTPacJIeD.
KOMMyHH3M, rSM6yprepbl Wendy
H AH~~epeHqHSqHfInpo,qyKTs
OAIIIH 1113 caMbiX CMeWHblX peKllaMHblX POllI11KOB, KorAa-1l11160 nORB11RBWIIIXCR Ha 3KpaHax aMeplIIKaHCKIIIX TelleB1II30pOB, nORBlllllCR B
1987 rOAY. OH BbiCMelllBall peallllllll cOBeTcKoH aAMIIIHIIICTpaTIIIBHo-KoMaHAHoH 3KOHOMIII'feCKOH CIIICTeMbl. )I(eHllllIIHa cnycKaeTcR no TPOnlllHKe B Mpa'iHOH cepoH epa6plll'fHOH p06e, a rOllOC Ja Ka,QpOM B03BelllaeT: "nOBceAHeBHblH HapRA!" 3aTeM Ta lKe lKeHllllIIHa CHOBa cnycKSeTCR no TponlllHKe B TOM lKe HapR.Qe, HO Ha 3TOT pa3 B ee PYKe CBeTIIITCR epOHapIIIK. rOll0C 3a KaAPOM C006lllaeT: "Be'fepHIIIH HapR.Q!" 3aTeM Bce Ta lKe lKeHllllIIHa CHOBa cnycKaeTCR no TponlllHKe - Bce B TOH lKe Helll3MeHHOH YHlllepopMe - III HeceT HaAyBHOH pe3111HoBblH MR'f. "HapR.Q.Q11R KynaHIIIR!" - c006lllaeT Bce TOTlKe rOll0C...
aTa peKllaMa BblCMelllBalla TOT epaKT, 'fTO l.\eHTpalllll30BaHHoe nllaHlllpoBaHllle, pacnpocTpaHeHHoe B KOMMYHIIICTIII'leCKIIIX cTpaHax,
COBepweHHO He 3a60Tlllll0Cb 0 pa3Ho06pa3111111 npOAYKTOB.
06b1'fHO BblnYCKallaCb OAHa-eAIIIHCTBeH HaR MOAellb KaKoro-H1II6YAb npoAyKTa C TeM, 'lT06b1 IIIMeTb B03MOlKHOCTb MaCCOBO npOlll3 BOAIIITb ero no B03MOlKHO caMoH HIII3KOH ce 6ecToIIIMoCTI'I .. B pe3YllbTaTe B COl.\lIIanIllCTIII 'feCKOM 06111ecTBe Ha61110.QallOCb TaKoe O.QHO06pa3111e, 'fTO peKllaMy Wendy MOlKHO CMellO Ha3BaTb "caMOH MRrlCOH".
'IUHe OTPaCJIH B KOHKYPHPYIOIUHe. Ho 3KOHOMIDI npoH3BO,llCTBeHHbIX 3aTPaT MoxeT He CTOHTh nOTepb B YBeJI~eHHH KO~eCTBa MO.llHcPHKaUH1t npo)lyKTa.
B KOHeqHOM HTOfe pa3Hoo6pa3He - no ,llOBOJIbHO "nHKaHTHM qacmqKa" )l(H3HH. Ae1t CTBHTeJIbHO JIH BbI XOTeJIH 6bI, qro6bI Bce peCTopaHbI 6bIJIH BO BceM noxo)I(H ,llpyr Ha ,llpyra, qro6bI Be3,lle BaM fOTOBHJIH O,llHHaKOByIO nHlUY, nO,llaBaJIH ee B O,llHHaKOBbIX 3anax, O,llHHaKOBO Me6JIHpoBaHHbIX H OllHHaKOBO OCBeJ..U.eHHbIX? liTO KaCaeTCH MeHH, TO MHe 6bI noro He XOTe JIOCb. l1: eCJIH CTOHMOCTb pa3HOo6pa3ID1 3aBHCHT OT 60J1ee BbICOKHX 3aTPaT Ha npOH3BOllCT BO np0)lyKTa cPHPM, paGoTaIOIUHX B MOHOnOJIHC~eCKH KOHKYPeHTHbIX oTPacJIHX, HeXeJIH y cPHPM H3 KOHKYPeHTHbIX OTPaCJIe1t, H 6bIJI 6bI He npoTHB peIDHTbCH Ha 60J1bIDHe paCXOllbI llJUI no~eHIDI HeKOTOpOfO pa3Hoo6pa3ID1.
KroK,nbI1t llOJI)KeH peIDHTb MH ce6H, Hf)KHO JIH CqHTaTb BbICOKH1t ypOBeHb 3aTPaT Ha C03 llaHHe pa3HOo6pa3ID1 nO,llXOiJ,HIUHM - H B KaKHX KOHKpemo CHTYaI.(HHX. TOflla KaK nOllo6HbIe 3aTPaTbI, Ha Bam B3fJIH,ll, MOryT OKaJaTbCSI OnpaB,llaHHbIMH MH peCTopaHOB, a HaCqeT Pa3HO 06pa3ID1 3anpaooqHbIX CTaHl.(H1t yBaC MoxeT 6bIT!> ,llpyroe MHeHHe.
